majiayu000 gate
Verify before claiming completion.
Trigger
Before claiming: "done", "fixed", "complete", "working", "ready"
Pre-Work Gate (Before Starting)
Run before substantial work begins. Blocks execution if missing.
□ Verification method locked (not "assumption")
→ What type: execution output / observation / measurement?
→ What evidence will you show?
□ At least 2 "must NOT" criteria exist
→ What should this NOT do?
→ What scope should NOT expand?
□ Fit score determined workflow shape
→ <25: BLOCKED - clarify first
→ 25-29: Colleague-shaped (iterate each step)
→ 30-39: Tool-with-review (checkpoint major steps)
→ 40+: Tool-shaped (milestones only)
If any missing: STOP. Complete before proceeding.
Post-Work Gate (Before Claiming Done)
Workflow A: Build
□ Feature executes without errors (show output)
□ Edge cases tested (empty, null, boundary)
□ Rollback tested if Type 2B/1
□ Dependencies verified
Workflow B: Debug
□ Root cause identified with evidence
□ Fix tested and resolves symptom
□ Prevention added (test/automation/guard)
□ Related bugs checked (same class)
Workflow C: Refactor
□ Existing tests pass unchanged
□ Behavior identical (output comparison)
□ Deletion complete (no orphans)
□ No new abstraction without justification
Verification Types
| Type | Description | Sufficient for SHIP? |
|---|---|---|
execution output |
Ran command, showed result | ✓ Yes |
observation |
Screenshot, debugger session | ✓ Yes |
measurement |
Metrics, benchmark data | ✓ Yes |
code review |
Inspection only | ⚠️ Weak |
assumption |
Not verified | ✗ Blocks SHIP |
Require execution output, observation, or measurement before completion claims.
Verification Plan
Before claiming completion, define how you'll verify:
| Verification Type | Evidence Required | Time Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Execution output | Command output, test results | < 1 min |
| Observation | Screenshot, debugger inspection | 1-5 min |
| Measurement | Metrics, benchmarks, profiling | 5-15 min |
| Code review | Manual inspection only | Variable |
| Assumption | No verification | 0 (blocks SHIP) |
Verification Requirements by Stakes
| Stakes | Minimum Verification |
|---|---|
| High | Execution output + Observation |
| Medium | Execution output |
| Low | Code review acceptable |
Anti-Footgun Rules
- Never claim "done" with only assumptions
- "It compiles" is not verification
- "Tests pass" requires showing test output
- If verification would take > 15 min, that's a smell (task too big)
Anti-Patterns
| Claim | Problem | Required |
|---|---|---|
| "Should work" | Speculation | Actual output |
| "Looks good" | No verification | Test results |
| "Fixed the issue" | No proof | Before/after |
| "I think this resolves it" | No confidence % | X-Y% + basis |
Incomplete Work
When blocked, state:
- What's done (with evidence)
- What's blocking (specific)
- What's remaining
Type 2A Exception
Trivial changes (< 1 min rollback): completion allowed without full gate. Document undo command.
Common Rationalizations (All Wrong)
| Thought | Reality |
|---|---|
| "The tests passed" | Tests ≠ verification. Did you run the ACTUAL command? |
| "It should work" | "Should" = assumption. Show evidence. |
| "I already checked" | When? Show the output. |
| "The user is waiting" | Rushed verification = rework later. |
| "It's a simple change" | Simple changes break production too. |
| "I'm pretty sure it works" | Pretty sure ≠ evidence. Run it. |