Implement Feature

Implement Feature Skill

Purpose

Implement features from task specifications or user stories using Test-Driven Development (TDD). This skill writes tests first, implements code to make tests pass, and validates the implementation meets all acceptance criteria.

Core Principles:

• Test-Driven Development (Red → Green → Refactor)
• Deterministic operations via bmad-commands
• Automated acceptance criteria verification
• Continuous validation

Prerequisites

• Task specification exists at workspace/tasks/{task_id}.md
• bmad-commands skill available at .claude/skills/bmad-commands/
• Development environment configured
• Test framework installed (Jest or Pytest)

Workflow

Step 0: Load Task Specification

Action: Use bmad-commands to load task spec.

Execute:

python .claude/skills/bmad-commands/scripts/read_file.py \
  --path workspace/tasks/{task_id}.md \
  --output json

Parse Response:

• Verify success == true
• Extract outputs.content for task specification
• Parse sections: Objective, Acceptance Criteria, Context, Tasks

If task spec not found:

• Error: file_not_found in errors array
• Action: Create task spec first using create-task-spec skill
• Halt implementation

If subtask_id is provided:

• Parse the task specification to locate the specific subtask section
• Filter acceptance criteria to only those related to the subtask
• Scope implementation to only the subtask requirements
• Note: All workflow steps below apply only to the selected subtask

See: references/templates.md for required task spec format

Step 1: Analyze Requirements

Action: Break down acceptance criteria into test cases.

For each acceptance criterion:

1. Identify what needs to be tested (behavior/outcome)
2. Determine test type (unit/integration/e2e)
3. Plan test structure and data
4. Identify edge cases

Example Analysis:

AC-1: User can log in with valid credentials

Test Cases:
- [Unit] Should return user object when credentials valid
- [Unit] Should return null when email not found
- [Unit] Should return null when password incorrect
- [Integration] Should create session when login successful
- [Integration] Should return 401 when login fails

Identify Files:

• Files to create (new implementation + tests)
• Files to modify (existing routes, config)
• Files to reference (existing models, utilities)

See: references/requirement-analysis-guide.md for detailed analysis patterns

Step 2: Write Tests (TDD Red Phase)

Action: Write failing tests that cover all acceptance criteria.

Run Tests:

python .claude/skills/bmad-commands/scripts/run_tests.py \
  --path . \
  --framework auto \
  --output json

Verify RED Phase:

• Parse response: outputs.passed == false
• Tests fail because implementation doesn't exist (not syntax errors)

If tests pass in RED phase:

• Tests are invalid (code already exists)
• Refine tests to be more specific

See: references/test-examples.md for comprehensive test patterns and structure

Step 3: Implement Code (TDD Green Phase)

Action: Write minimum code to make tests pass.

Implementation Strategy:

1. Start with simplest test first
2. Implement just enough to pass that test
3. Run tests after each small change
4. Keep refactoring for later (Green phase)

Run Tests:

python .claude/skills/bmad-commands/scripts/run_tests.py \
  --path . \
  --framework auto \
  --output json

Verify GREEN Phase:

• Parse response: outputs.passed == true
• Check outputs.coverage_percent >= 80
• Verify outputs.failed_tests == 0

If tests still failing:

• Review failure messages in outputs.failures
• Fix implementation
• Re-run tests
• Repeat until GREEN

See: references/implementation-examples.md for implementation patterns

Step 4: Refactor (TDD Refactor Phase)

Action: Improve code quality while keeping tests green.

Refactoring Targets:

• Remove duplication (DRY principle)
• Improve naming (clarity)
• Extract functions/methods (single responsibility)
• Simplify conditionals (readability)
• Add type safety
• Enhance error handling

After Each Refactor:

python .claude/skills/bmad-commands/scripts/run_tests.py \
  --path . \
  --framework auto \
  --output json

Verify tests stay green:

• outputs.passed == true after each refactor
• If tests break, revert refactor
• Only commit refactors that keep tests green

See: references/refactoring-patterns.md for common refactoring techniques

Step 5: Verify Acceptance Criteria

Action: Check that all acceptance criteria from task spec are met.

For each acceptance criterion:

1. Identify corresponding tests
2. Verify tests pass
3. Verify behavior matches requirement
4. Check edge cases covered

Automated Verification:

# Run full test suite
python .claude/skills/bmad-commands/scripts/run_tests.py \
  --path . \
  --framework auto \
  --output json

Check:

• outputs.passed == true
• outputs.coverage_percent >= 80
• outputs.total_tests >= expected_count
• All acceptance criteria have corresponding passing tests

Manual Verification:

• Review code against technical specifications
• Verify API contracts match spec
• Check data models are correct
• Ensure error handling is complete

Step 6: Run Validation Suite

Action: Run comprehensive checks before completion.

Validation Checks:

1. All tests passing
2. Coverage >= 80%
3. No syntax errors
4. No linting errors
5. All files created as specified
6. Code follows project standards

Run Final Tests:

python .claude/skills/bmad-commands/scripts/run_tests.py \
  --path . \
  --framework auto \
  --output json

Acceptance Criteria Verification:

• ✅ tests_passing: outputs.passed == true
• ✅ coverage_threshold: outputs.coverage_percent >= 80
• ✅ no_syntax_errors: No syntax errors in output
• ✅ task_spec_loaded: Task spec was successfully loaded in Step 0
• ✅ requirements_met: All acceptance criteria verified in Step 5

See: references/validation-guide.md for complete validation procedures

Output

Return structured output with implementation status, test results, and telemetry.

See: references/templates.md for complete output format and examples

Error Handling

If any step fails:

• Task Spec Not Found: Create task spec first using create-task-spec skill
• Tests Failing: Review failures in outputs, fix code, re-run
• Coverage Below Threshold: Add more tests to reach 80%
• Syntax Errors: Fix syntax errors, re-run tests

See: references/error-scenarios.md for detailed error handling strategies

Common Scenarios

Scenario 1: Ambiguous Requirements

If acceptance criteria are unclear or not testable:

• Halt implementation
• Request requirement refinement
• Suggest using refine-story skill

Scenario 2: Missing Dependencies

If implementation requires files that don't exist:

• Check if dependency is from another task
• Suggest implementing dependency task first
• OR expand scope to include dependency (with user approval)

Scenario 3: Tests Failing After Refactor

If tests break during refactoring:

• Revert the refactor
• Run tests to verify green again
• Try smaller refactoring step
• Ensure tests are correct (not implementation-dependent)

Scenario 4: Large Task with Multiple Subtasks

If a task has multiple independent subtasks that can be implemented separately:

• Use the --subtask flag to implement one subtask at a time
• Example: /implement-feature workspace/tasks/task-auth-002.md --subtask subtask-1
• This allows for incremental development and easier code review
• Each subtask should have its own tests and can be committed independently

Best Practices

1. Follow TDD Cycle - Red → Green → Refactor, no shortcuts
2. Keep Tests Focused - One test per behavior
3. Mock External Dependencies - Database, APIs, file system
4. Commit Frequently - After each TDD phase

See: references/best-practices.md for detailed TDD best practices

Routing Guidance

Use this skill when:

• Task complexity is simple to medium (≤60 complexity score)
• Changes affect ≤5 files
• No breaking changes or migrations
• Clear, testable acceptance criteria

Use alternative when:

• High complexity (>60 complexity score)
• Large scale changes (>5 files)
• Breaking changes requiring discovery phase
• Migrations or schema changes
• → Route to: implement-with-discovery skill

Complexity Assessment:

• Low (0-30): 1-2 files, no database/API changes → Use this skill
• Medium (31-60): 3-5 files, minor schema changes → Use this skill with caution
• High (61-100): 6+ files, migrations, breaking changes → Use implement-with-discovery

Reference Files

• references/requirement-analysis-guide.md - Analyze acceptance criteria, plan tests
• references/test-examples.md - Complete test patterns (unit, integration, e2e)
• references/implementation-examples.md - Code implementation patterns
• references/refactoring-patterns.md - Common refactoring techniques
• references/validation-guide.md - Complete validation procedures
• references/error-scenarios.md - Error handling strategies
• references/best-practices.md - TDD and testing best practices
• references/templates.md - Task spec format, output format, commit templates

Using This Skill

Invoked by James subagent with routing, or called directly with task_id input.

Part of BMAD Enhanced Development Suite