Modernize Move

Skill: modernize-move

Detect and modernize outdated Move V1 syntax, patterns, and APIs to Move V2+. Preserves correctness through tiered transformations with test verification after each tier.

Essential Principles

Five non-negotiable rules for every modernization:

1. Test safety net is mandatory WHY: Modernization must preserve behavior. No tests = no safety net. If no tests exist, invoke generate-tests skill first to create comprehensive tests before making any changes.

2. Analyze before modifying WHY: The user must see exactly what will change and confirm the scope. Never surprise-edit code. Present the full analysis report and wait for confirmation.

3. Tiered execution order WHY: Syntax changes (Tier 1) are zero-risk. API migrations (Tier 3) change semantics. Always apply safest changes first so riskier changes build on a clean, verified foundation.

4. Verify after each tier WHY: If tests break, you know exactly which tier caused it. Revert that tier and investigate before proceeding. Never apply the next tier on a broken baseline.

5. Preserve error code values WHY: Tests use #[expected_failure(abort_code = N)]. Changing numeric values breaks tests silently. When creating named constants, the numeric value MUST match the original literal.

When to Use This Skill

• Upgrading Move V1 contracts to V2 syntax
• Migrating public(friend) to package fun
• Converting vector::borrow to index notation
• Converting while loops with counters to for range loops
• Replacing manual vector iteration with stdlib inline functions (vector::for_each_ref, vector::map, vector::fold, etc.) and lambdas
• Replacing magic abort numbers with named constants
• Migrating legacy coin/TokenV1 to modern fungible_asset/Digital Assets
• Converting EventHandle to #[event] pattern
• Upgrading custom signed integer workarounds to native i8-i256 types

When NOT to Use This Skill

• Writing new contracts from scratch — use write-contracts
• Fixing bugs or adding features — modernization is structural, not functional
• Optimizing gas usage — use analyze-gas-optimization
• Auditing security — use security-audit (run AFTER modernization)

Workflow

Phase 1: Analyze Contract

Entry: User provides a Move contract or project to modernize.

Actions:

1. Read all contract source files (.move files in sources/)
2. Scan for V1 patterns using detection rules from detection-rules.md:
   • Grep for Tier 1 patterns (syntax) — highest confidence, most common
   • Grep for Tier 2 patterns (visibility, errors, events)
   • Grep for Tier 3 patterns (API migrations) — flag for manual review
3. Cross-reference coupled patterns (T3-09+T3-10)
4. Categorize each finding: line number, rule ID, pattern name, proposed change, tier, confidence
5. Build the Analysis Report

Exit: Analysis Report ready for presentation.

Phase 2: Present Analysis (GATE 1)

Entry: Analysis Report complete.

Actions:

1. Present the full Analysis Report to the user in this format:

## Modernization Analysis Report

### Summary
- Tier 1 (Syntax): X findings
- Tier 2 (Visibility & Errors): X findings
- Tier 3 (API Migrations): X findings

### Findings

| # | File:Line | Rule | Pattern | Proposed Change | Tier | Confidence |
|---|-----------|------|---------|-----------------|------|------------|
| 1 | src/mod.move:15 | T1-01 | vector::borrow | → index notation | 1 | High |
| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |

### Tier 3 Warnings (if any)
- T3-03: coin → fungible_asset migration is a major rewrite (X locations)

2. Ask the user to choose scope:
   • syntax-only (Tier 1 only) — zero risk, just cleaner syntax
   • standard (Tier 1 + Tier 2) — recommended default, syntax + visibility + error constants
   • full (all tiers) — includes API migrations, higher risk
3. Highlight any Tier 3 items that require major rewrites
4. If scope includes Tier 3, ask the user about deployment context:
   • Compatible — Upgrading an already-deployed contract. Breaking changes are excluded even if the scope includes them. Rules marked ⚠ Breaking are skipped.
   • Fresh deploy — New deployment or willing to redeploy. All changes in the selected scope are applied including breaking changes.

Exit: User has confirmed scope (and deployment context if Tier 3 is included). Do NOT proceed until confirmed.

Phase 3: Establish Test Safety Net

Entry: User confirmed scope.

Actions:

1. Search for existing tests:
   • #[test_only] modules within source files
   • *_tests.move files
   • tests/ directory
2. If no tests found: stop and invoke generate-tests skill to create comprehensive tests first, then return here
3. Run aptos move test to establish a passing baseline
4. Record baseline: number of tests, all passing status

Exit: All tests pass. Baseline recorded. If tests fail pre-modernization, stop and address test failures first — do not modernize on a broken test suite.

Phase 4: Apply Transformations (with Feedback Loops)

Entry: Test baseline established.

Actions — apply in tier order:

Tier 1 (if scope includes it — always):

1. Apply all Tier 1 syntax changes per transformation-guide.md
2. Run aptos move test
3. If tests fail → revert all Tier 1 changes, investigate which specific change caused failure, fix and retry

Tier 2 (if scope is standard or full): 4. Apply all Tier 2 changes per transformation guide 5. Run aptos move test 6. If tests fail → revert all Tier 2 changes, investigate and fix

Tier 3 (if scope is full only): 7. Apply Tier 3 changes ONE AT A TIME (not all at once)

• If deployment context is compatible: skip any rule marked ⚠ Breaking. Add to the skipped list with reason "breaking change, excluded in compatible mode."
• If deployment context is fresh deploy: apply all rules in scope normally.

8. Run aptos move test after EACH individual Tier 3 change
9. If tests fail → revert that specific change, note it as skipped, proceed to next Tier 3 item

Exit: All approved changes applied, all tests passing.

Phase 5: Final Verification

Entry: All transformations applied.

Actions:

1. Run aptos move test --coverage
2. Verify test coverage is >= baseline (should be same or better)
3. Generate Modernization Summary Report:

## Modernization Summary

### Changes Applied
- Tier 1: X changes (syntax)
- Tier 2: X changes (visibility & errors)
- Tier 3: X changes (API migrations)

### Changes Skipped
- [List any skipped items with reasons]

### Test Results
- Tests: X passing (baseline: Y)
- Coverage: X% (baseline: Y%)

### Files Modified
- [List of modified files]

Exit: Report presented to user.

Modernization Scope Quick Reference

Tier Quick Reference

See detection-rules.md for the complete rule catalog (22 rules across 3 tiers).

Rationalizations to Reject

Success Criteria

• Analysis Report presented before any modifications
• User confirmed modernization scope
• Test baseline established before changes
• Tests pass after each tier of changes
• All error code numeric values preserved
• No Tier 3 changes applied without full scope confirmation
• Breaking changes excluded when user selected compatible mode
• Modernization Summary Report generated
• Test coverage maintained at or above baseline

Reference Index

Related skills: generate-tests, write-contracts, security-audit