Phase3 Ticket Investigation

Purpose

Investigate Phase 3 tickets (Orchestration, CLI, Scheduling, Monitoring, Testing) to clarify scope and provide implementation recommendation.

When To Use

• Manager assigns Phase 3 ticket investigation
• Ticket has empty/unclear body but tags indicate a Phase 3 component
• Need to decide if ticket should be scoped, deferred, or closed

Procedure

1. Gather Context

• List all Phase 3 tickets: loom ticket list --tag phase3
• Read ROADMAP.md to understand Phase 3 goals and components
• Check each Phase 3 ticket status and body content

2. Check Component Status

For Orchestration (vp-cf95)

• Check if ExecutionEngine exists in src/vibe_piper/orchestration/
• Verify orchestration tests in tests/test_orchestration.py
• Look for implementation commits in git log

For CLI (vp-6cf1)

• Check CLI commands in src/vibe_piper/cli/
• Verify CLI tests in tests/cli/
• Check if commands are registered and working

For Scheduling (vp-7d49)

• Check scheduling module in src/vibe_piper/scheduling/
• Verify scheduling tests in tests/scheduling/
• Check test pass rate

For Monitoring (vp-f17e)

• Check monitoring module in src/vibe_piper/monitoring/
• Verify monitoring tests in tests/monitoring/
• Check implementation status (metrics, logging, health, etc.)

For Testing (vp-0429)

• List existing testing infrastructure:
  • Unit tests: ls tests/*.py
  • Integration tests: ls tests/integration/*.py
  • Fixtures: check tests/conftest.py
  • Assertion helpers: check tests/helpers/assertions.py
  • Factory functions: check tests/helpers/factories.py
  • Fake data generators: check tests/fixtures/fake_data.py
• Check for snapshot testing:
  • tests/helpers/snapshots.py exists?
  • tests/helpers/test_snapshots.py exists?
  • tests/snapshots/ directory exists?
• Check if snapshot-testing skill exists: .opencode/skills/snapshot-testing/SKILL.md

3. Analyze Roadmap Context

• Check ROADMAP.md Testing Layer section (around line 167-174)
• Note which components are marked ✅ vs ⏳ vs ⏸️
• Identify any components marked "in progress" or "missing"

4. Determine Recommendation

Implement If:

• Component is called out as missing in ROADMAP
• Skill definition exists but implementation is missing
• Low effort (2-3 hours estimate)
• Independent of current sprint work
• High value (catches regressions, completes phase)

Defer If:

• Current sprint has higher priority work
• Component can wait until after current sprint
• Priority is P2/P3

Close If:

• Component already implemented elsewhere
• Component superseded by new approach
• No clear value add

5. Document Findings

• Create INVESTIGATION_NOTES.md with:
  • All Phase 3 ticket statuses
  • Existing infrastructure checklists
  • Roadmap context
  • Decision rationale
  • Recommended scope (if implementing)
• Commit investigation notes with clear message
• Update ticket body with:
  • Context (what was missing/incomplete)
  • Objective (what to implement)
  • Clear scope with tasks
  • Acceptance criteria checklist
  • Dependencies
  • Related tickets

6. Communicate to Manager

• Use loom team send MiyagiDo manager to summarize:
  • Investigation findings
  • Recommendation (implement/defer/close)
  • Scope (if implementing)
  • Estimated effort
  • Suggested timing (now vs. after sprint)
• Add note to ticket with progress update

Outputs

• INVESTIGATION_NOTES.md with detailed findings
• Updated ticket body with clear scope
• Manager notification with summary
• Git commit with investigation documentation

Example Investigation

## Phase 3 Status
| Ticket | Component | Status | Notes |
|--------|-----------|--------|-------|
| vp-cf95 | Orchestration | CLOSED | Body empty |
| vp-6cf1 | CLI | CLOSED ✓ | 7 commands implemented |
| vp-7d49 | Scheduling | CLOSED ✓ | 19/25 tests passing |
| vp-f17e | Monitoring | CLOSED ✓ | 76 tests created |
| vp-0429 | Testing | OPEN | Snapshot testing missing |

## Testing Infrastructure
✅ Present: Unit tests, Integration tests, Fixtures, Helpers, Factories, Fake data
❌ Missing: Snapshot testing framework

## Decision
IMPLEMENT - snapshot testing is only missing Phase 3 Testing Layer component

Manual notes

This section is preserved when the skill is updated. Put human notes, caveats, and exceptions here.