Plan Tracking

Plan File Tracking Guidelines

When working from a plan file (markdown file with task checkboxes), follow these guidelines to ensure proper tracking.

Core Rule

The plan file is the source of truth for task completion status.

Use the plan-file-management skill's subcommands to read and update plan files:

• Find next task: plan-file-management → get-next-task
• Mark task complete: plan-file-management → mark-task-complete

See the plan-file-management skill for invocation details.

Do NOT rely on internal tracking (like TodoWrite) as a substitute for updating the actual plan file.

⚠️ Verifying Observable and Evidence (CRITICAL - READ THIS)

THIS IS THE MOST IMPORTANT SECTION OF THIS SKILL.

A task is NOT complete until the Observable outcome is actually observed and the Evidence is actually collected.

If a task has these fields:

• Observable: What should be true after the task is complete
• Evidence: How to verify the observable

Then tests must verify the Evidence - not the agent manually running commands and checking output.

This applies to all test types:

• JUnit/unit tests
• Integration tests
• Component tests
• Shell test scripts

Example task:

- [ ] **Task 1.3: POST /orders endpoint creates order and returns 201**
  - Observable: Endpoint accepts order JSON, persists to database, returns 201 with order ID
  - Evidence: Integration test POSTs valid order, asserts 201 response, asserts order exists in database

The test must contain assertions that verify the Evidence:

@Test
void createOrder_returnsCreatedWithOrderId() {
    var response = restTemplate.postForEntity("/orders", validOrderRequest, OrderResponse.class);

    assertThat(response.getStatusCode()).isEqualTo(HttpStatus.CREATED);
    assertThat(response.getBody().getId()).isNotNull();

    // Verify persisted to database
    var saved = orderRepository.findById(response.getBody().getId());
    assertThat(saved).isPresent();
    assertThat(saved.get().getCustomerId()).isEqualTo(validOrderRequest.getCustomerId());
}

WRONG: Agent writes the endpoint code, assumes it works because the code looks right RIGHT: Tests contain assertions for the Evidence criteria; tests pass = Evidence verified

Tests are the source of truth for verification, not the agent's judgment.

Migration Planning

When creating migration or upgrade plans for existing codebases:

1. Before describing any file/directory creation tasks, verify whether the target already exists using Glob or Read
2. Use precise language: "Transform" or "Convert" for existing items, "Create" only for genuinely new items
3. Include a "Current State" section in plans that documents what exists before transformation

Review Plans for Technical Correctness

Before implementing a task from the plan, review its implementation details for technical flaws:

• Apply fundamental engineering principles (e.g., uniqueness constraints belong at database level, not application level)
• If the plan specifies a flawed approach, fix it before proceeding
• Do not blindly follow implementation details that violate best practices

Workflow

For each task in the plan:

1. Get the next task using plan-file-management → get-next-task
2. Review for technical correctness before implementing
3. Implement the task (write test, implement code, verify)
4. Verify Observable and Evidence criteria - tests must pass that verify the Evidence (see critical section above)
5. *Mark task complete using plan-file-management → mark-task-complete
6. Continue to the next task

Continue Without Stopping

When implementing a documented plan:

• Continue through all phases without stopping for confirmation
• Only pause if blocked, uncertain about requirements, or encountering errors
• The plan itself serves as the user's approval to proceed
• Summarize progress periodically but don't ask "should I continue?"

Why This Matters

• The plan file is visible to the user and persists across sessions
• Internal tracking (TodoWrite) is ephemeral and not visible in the codebase
• Commits should include both the implementation AND the updated plan
• Other developers can see progress by looking at the plan file

Common Mistake

BAD:

Complete task 1.1
Update internal TodoWrite
Complete task 1.2
Update internal TodoWrite
... (plan file never updated)

GOOD:

Complete task 1.1
Use plan-file-management → mark-task-complete for thread 1, task 1
Complete task 1.2
Use plan-file-management → mark-task-complete for thread 1, task 2

When to Apply

Apply this guideline when:

• User provides a plan file path (e.g., *-plan.md, *-tasks.md)
• User says "follow the plan" or "implement from the plan"
• Working with any markdown file containing - [ ] task checkboxes

Commit Guidelines

When committing completed tasks:

1. Stage the implementation changes
2. Stage the updated plan file (with checkbox marked)
3. Commit together so the commit reflects both the work done and the progress tracked

Commit Verification for Plan Files

Before running git commit, always:

1. Run git status from the repository root (not a subdirectory)
2. Verify the plan file appears in "Changes to be committed"
3. If the plan file is not staged, explicitly add it: git add path/to/plan.md

When committing from a subdirectory:

• Use absolute paths or navigate to repo root first
• Example: git add /path/to/plan.md or cd /repo/root && git add .