majiayu000 PR Feedback Integration
Parse PR review comments and integrate actionable items into the devloop plan.
When to Use
- PR has review comments or change requests
- Reviewer requested changes
- Need to track which feedback has been addressed
- Iterating on PR after initial review
Fetching PR Feedback
Get PR details with comments:
# View PR with all comments
gh pr view --json number,title,body,comments,reviews,reviewDecision
# Get review comments (inline code comments)
gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/pulls/{number}/comments
# Get PR conversation comments
gh api repos/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{number}/comments
Key fields to extract:
| Field | Purpose |
|---|---|
reviewDecision |
APPROVED, CHANGES_REQUESTED, REVIEW_REQUIRED |
reviews |
List of reviews with state and body |
comments |
Conversation comments |
Parsing Feedback
Categorize feedback:
| Type | Description |
|---|---|
| Blocker | Must fix before merge |
| Suggestion | Should consider |
| Question | Needs response |
| Nitpick | Nice to have |
Identify actionable items:
Look for patterns:
- "Please..." / "Could you..." → Action request
- "This should..." / "Consider..." → Suggestion
- "Why..." / "What if..." → Question
- "Nit:" / "Minor:" → Low priority
Adding to Plan
Create PR Feedback section in plan:
## PR Feedback
PR #123 - Review by @reviewer (CHANGES_REQUESTED)
### Blockers
- [ ] [PR-123-1] Fix null handling in parseConfig (@reviewer)
- [ ] [PR-123-2] Add tests for edge cases (@reviewer)
### Suggestions
- [ ] [PR-123-3] Consider caching config (@reviewer)
### Questions
- [ ] [PR-123-4] Respond: Why not use existing parser? (@reviewer)
Task ID format: [PR-{number}-{item}]
Tracking Resolution
When addressing feedback:
- Make the fix
- Mark task complete in plan
- Reply to the comment on GitHub
- Push changes
Reply template:
gh pr comment {number} --body "Addressed in commit {sha}:
- Fixed null handling
- Added edge case tests"
Example Workflow
# 1. Check PR status
gh pr view --json reviewDecision,reviews
# 2. If changes requested, get details
gh pr view --comments
# 3. Parse into plan tasks (manual or use /devloop:pr-feedback)
# 4. Work through feedback tasks
# 5. Push and reply
git push
gh pr comment --body "Ready for re-review"
Integration with /devloop:pr-feedback
The /devloop:pr-feedback command automates:
- Fetching current PR comments
- Parsing actionable items
- Presenting to user for selection
- Adding selected items to plan
- Updating Progress Log
Best Practices
- Address blockers first
- Reply to each comment when resolved
- Push frequently during feedback iteration
- Re-request review when ready