Review UI Screenshots

Review UI Screenshots Skill

Analyze UI screenshots captured during testing to identify visual issues, UX problems, and suggest improvements.

When to Use

• After /download-ci-artifacts retrieves screenshots
• After running Slicer integration tests locally
• When asked to "review the UI"
• When asked to "improve the widget"

Screenshot Location

# From CI artifacts
ls ci-artifacts/screenshots/
cat ci-artifacts/screenshots/manifest.json

# From local test run
ls MouseMaster/Testing/Python/screenshots/
cat MouseMaster/Testing/Python/screenshots/manifest.json

Manifest Format

{
  "screenshots": [
    {
      "filename": "001.png",
      "description": "[MouseMaster] Initial state",
      "group": "full_workflow",
      "capture_type": "widget",
      "metadata": {"widget_class": "QWidget"}
    }
  ]
}

Analysis Workflow

1. Read the manifest

cat ci-artifacts/screenshots/manifest.json | python -m json.tool

2. Review each screenshot

For each screenshot, Claude Code can view the image:

# View screenshot (Claude Code can read images)
# Just provide the path and Claude will analyze it

3. Check for issues

Layout Issues

• Widgets properly aligned
• Spacing consistent
• No overlapping elements
• Responsive to window size

Text Issues

• Labels readable
• No truncated text
• Proper capitalization
• Consistent terminology

State Issues

• Correct enabled/disabled states
• Selection highlighting visible
• Error states clear
• Loading indicators present

Usability Issues

• Controls discoverable
• Actions have feedback
• Navigation intuitive
• Error messages helpful

4. Document findings

## Screenshot Review: [filename]

**Description**: [from manifest]
**Workflow Step**: [what user just did]

### Issues Found
- [ ] Issue 1 description
- [ ] Issue 2 description

### Recommendations
1. Recommendation 1
2. Recommendation 2

### Code Changes Needed
- `MouseMaster.py:line` - Change X to Y

Common UI Fixes

Alignment issues

# Use layouts instead of absolute positioning
layout = qt.QVBoxLayout()
layout.addWidget(self.label)
layout.addWidget(self.combo)

Text truncation

# Set minimum width
self.comboBox.setMinimumWidth(200)

# Or use elide mode
self.label.setTextElideMode(qt.Qt.ElideRight)

Disabled state unclear

# Add tooltip explaining why disabled
self.button.setToolTip("Select a mouse first")

Missing feedback

# Add status message
slicer.util.showStatusMessage("Preset saved", 2000)

Workflow Comparison

Compare sequential screenshots to verify:

1. State transitions - UI updates after actions
2. Data persistence - Selections maintained
3. Error recovery - UI recovers from errors

Integration with Code

After identifying issues, edit the widget code:

# MouseMaster/MouseMaster.py - MouseMasterWidget class

def setup(self):
    # Apply fixes here
    pass

Report Format

## UI Screenshot Review Report

**Screenshots Analyzed**: X
**Issues Found**: Y

### Critical Issues (fix immediately)
| Screenshot | Issue | Fix |
|------------|-------|-----|
| 003.png | Button truncated | Increase min width |

### Minor Issues (nice to have)
| Screenshot | Issue | Recommendation |
|------------|-------|----------------|
| 005.png | Inconsistent spacing | Use standard margins |

### Positive Observations
- Widget layout is clean
- Color scheme consistent

### Recommended Changes
1. File: line - Change
2. File: line - Change

Verification

After making changes:

1. Run Slicer integration tests
2. Compare new screenshots to old
3. Verify issues resolved

Related Skills

• /download-ci-artifacts - Get screenshots
• /analyze-test-results - Fix test failures
• /generate-screenshots - Capture new screenshots