Spec Analyze

Spec Analyze Skill

Goal

Verify that the three core planning artifacts — PRD.md/spec.md, plan.md, and project/tasks.md — are fully aligned. Detect any requirements that have no implementation plan, any plan items with no tasks, and any tasks with no requirement.

Steps

1. Load all three artifacts

   • Read PRD.md (or spec.md) — get all EARS requirements
   • Read plan.md (or PLAN.md) — get all implementation phases and decisions
   • Read project/tasks.md — get all atomic tasks with their status

2. Check Requirement → Plan coverage For each EARS requirement in PRD.md:

   • Does plan.md have at least one item addressing this requirement?
   • Are there requirements with no corresponding plan entry?
   • Flag: [UNCOVERED] Requirement: "WHEN user resets password THE SYSTEM SHALL..." — no plan entry

3. Check Plan → Task coverage For each implementation phase/item in plan.md:

   • Does project/tasks.md have at least one task for this plan item?
   • Are there plan items with no corresponding tasks?
   • Flag: [NO_TASKS] Plan item: "Implement email verification" — 0 tasks in project/tasks.md

4. Check Task → Requirement traceability For each task in project/tasks.md:

   • Can this task be traced back to a requirement in PRD.md?
   • Are there tasks that don't correspond to any stated requirement (scope creep)?
   • Flag: [ORPHAN_TASK] Task: "Add admin dashboard" — no corresponding requirement

5. Check status consistency

   • Are there tasks marked DONE for requirements that haven't been approved yet?
   • Are there tasks IN_PROGRESS while a dependency task is still TODO?
   • Are there DONE tasks that don't have corresponding test coverage?

6. Check EARS syntax compliance

   • Scan all requirements for vague language: "should", "might", "user-friendly", "fast"
   • Flag: [VAGUE] "The API should be fast" — not a testable requirement. Rewrite with measurable criterion.

7. Generate alignment report

   ## Spec Alignment Report
   
   ### Coverage: Requirements → Plan
   - COVERED: [N] requirements
   - UNCOVERED: [N] requirements (listed below)
   
   ### Coverage: Plan → Tasks
   - COVERED: [N] plan items
   - NO_TASKS: [N] plan items (listed below)
   
   ### Orphan Tasks (no requirement)
   - [list any tasks with no corresponding requirement]
   
   ### EARS Compliance Issues
   - [list vague requirements]
   
   ### Status Inconsistencies
   - [list any status conflicts]
   
   ### Verdict
   ALIGNED: [YES/NO]
   Blocking issues: [count]
   Recommended actions: [list]
   

8. If mismatches found: present to human and ask which artifact should be updated

   • If requirement missing from plan: "Should I add this to plan.md?"
   • If task has no requirement: "Should I add a requirement to PRD.md or remove this task?"

Constraints

• This skill reads artifacts only — it does NOT modify them without explicit instruction
• After human decision, re-run the analysis to confirm alignment
• Run this skill whenever any of the three artifacts changes

Output Format

Alignment report in markdown with categorized findings and clear ALIGNED: YES/NO verdict.