Skill Product Analysis

Product Analysis & Vision

1. Objective

To define what we are building and why, before writing code. This skill powers the Product Analyst (p02) role.

2. Core Tooling

You MUST use the provided Python script to scaffold the Vision document. DO NOT write the PRODUCT_VISION.md header/structure manually.

How to Initialise

Run the following command (Headless mode):

python3 [skill_path]/scripts/init_product.py --name "Product Name" --problem "Problem description" --audience "Users" --metrics "KPI1, KPI2"

Note: [skill_path] is the path to this skill (e.g. .agent/skills/skill-product-analysis).

3. The 10-Factor Scoring Matrix

Before drafting the Vision, you MUST score the idea to determine viability.

Protocol

Run the scoring script with your estimated values (1-10, where 10 is Best/Easiest):

# Example: High problem intensity (9), but weak moat (3)
python3 [skill_path]/scripts/score_product.py --problem_intensity 9 --moat_durability 3 --market_size 8

• Goal: Score > 70/100.
• Output: Application of this script must be included in PRODUCT_VISION.md.

4. Artifact Standards (PRODUCT_VISION.md)

Template Structure

See assets/vision_template.md for the authoritative structure. All sections are mandatory.

INVEST Criteria (User Stories)

When breaking down the vision into the Backlog:

• Independent
• Negotiable
• Valuable (to the user)
• Estimable
• Small
• Testable

4. Frameworks (The "Soul")

Crossing the Chasm (Differentiation)

When defining the product features, you MUST position it for the Early Majority.

• The Beachhead: What is the single specific niche we can dominate?
• The Whole Product: What eco-system/integrations are needed to make it a complete solution?

Emotional Logic (User Centricity)

Every feature implementation plan must start with:

1. Trigger: What emotional state is the user in? (e.g. Anxiety about API keys)
2. Action: The feature they use.
3. Reward: The emotional relief/gain. (e.g. "Safety", "Control")

5. Verification Guidelines

• Problem Statement: Is it specific?
• Metrics: Are they SMART?
• Soul Check: Does the Vision allow for emotional connection?

6. Output

Use the Official Template for the full structure.

7. Examples

• Strong Go: examples/01_strong_go_devboost.md
• Consider: examples/02_consider_talentflow.md
• No-Go: examples/03_nogo_quickbites.md