Evidence Review
Read references/review-contract.md. Review the artifacts and acceptance criteria, not the producer's confidence or narrative.
Review layers
Scientific: question, design, controls, experimental unit, and causal strength.
Citation: existence, bibliographic correctness, primary-source preference, and semantic support for the exact clause.
Numbers: every sample size, percentage, effect, interval, p value, and identifier traced to source data or output.
Figures: source table, code, labels, statistics, legends, and manuscript text agree.
Reproducibility: clean rerun, versions, parameters, seeds, failures, and environment evidence.
Privacy: no private dataset, credential, local path, or excluded organism-specific resource entered a reusable package.
Independence rule
If the reviewer participated in producing an artifact, disclose that conflict and perform only a provisional check. For a consequential gate, use a fresh review context or independent agent when available.
Verdict
Return exactly one: PASS, PASS WITH REQUIRED REVISIONS, or BLOCK. A PASS requires evidence for each required layer; silence is not evidence.
1---2name: evidence-review3description: Independently review a life-science manuscript, analysis, figure package, or repository for claim support, citation validity, numeric traceability, figure-code-data consistency, reproducibility, and privacy. Use as a final gate, not as author self-approval.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/minimax-ai/evidence-review6---78# Evidence Review910Read [references/review-contract.md](references/review-contract.md). Review the artifacts and acceptance criteria, not the producer's confidence or narrative.1112## Review layers13141. `Scientific`: question, design, controls, experimental unit, and causal strength.152. `Citation`: existence, bibliographic correctness, primary-source preference, and semantic support for the exact clause.163. `Numbers`: every sample size, percentage, effect, interval, p value, and identifier traced to source data or output.174. `Figures`: source table, code, labels, statistics, legends, and manuscript text agree.185. `Reproducibility`: clean rerun, versions, parameters, seeds, failures, and environment evidence.196. `Privacy`: no private dataset, credential, local path, or excluded organism-specific resource entered a reusable package.2021## Independence rule2223If the reviewer participated in producing an artifact, disclose that conflict and perform only a provisional check. For a consequential gate, use a fresh review context or independent agent when available.2425## Verdict2627Return exactly one: `PASS`, `PASS WITH REQUIRED REVISIONS`, or `BLOCK`. A PASS requires evidence for each required layer; silence is not evidence.