Story Reconcile Implementation

Story Implementation Reconciliation

Use this skill after moonspec-breakdown and before provider-backed issue creation when a breakdown may include work that is already fully or partially implemented.

Inputs

• Required: a MoonSpec story breakdown JSON path. Prefer storyBreakdownPath from the runtime inputs.
• Optional: storyBreakdownMarkdownPath for the human-readable reconciliation report.
• Optional: source design path or text from the breakdown source.
• Required: current repository checkout containing the implementation to inspect.

If no readable story breakdown JSON path is available, stop with a clear blocker. Do not create Jira issues or implementation tasks.

Workflow

1. Read the story breakdown JSON.
2. For each story, inspect relevant source, tests, docs, migrations, contracts, and configuration in the repository.
3. Compare repository evidence against the story acceptance criteria, requirements, source design coverage, and explicit non-goals.
4. Classify every story with exactly one implementationStatus:
   • fully_implemented
   • partially_implemented
   • not_implemented
   • unverifiable
5. Rewrite the JSON breakdown in place at storyBreakdownPath with the same top-level structure and story order.
6. Write or update the markdown report at storyBreakdownMarkdownPath when provided.

Classification Rules

• Use fully_implemented only when every in-scope acceptance criterion and requirement has concrete repository evidence and the behavior is testable.
• Use partially_implemented when at least one in-scope criterion is implemented and at least one remains missing or insufficiently validated.
• Use not_implemented when no meaningful in-scope implementation evidence exists.
• Use unverifiable when the requirement is too ambiguous, depends on missing external context, or cannot be checked from the repository state available in this run.
• Be conservative. If evidence is weak, do not mark a story fully implemented.

Story Output Contract

Preserve the original story fields. Add reconciliation fields; do not delete source traceability.

For a fully implemented story:

{
  "implementationStatus": "fully_implemented",
  "implementedEvidence": [
    {
      "requirement": "DESIGN-REQ-001",
      "status": "met",
      "evidence": "tests/unit/example_test.py covers the acceptance path."
    }
  ],
  "issueCreation": {
    "action": "skip",
    "reason": "All acceptance criteria have repository evidence."
  }
}

For a partially implemented story:

{
  "implementationStatus": "partially_implemented",
  "implementedEvidence": [
    {
      "requirement": "DESIGN-REQ-001",
      "status": "met",
      "evidence": "api_service/example.py implements the existing endpoint."
    }
  ],
  "remainingWork": {
    "summary": "Complete remaining behavior for the original story",
    "description": "Only the unmet behavior should be implemented.",
    "acceptanceCriteria": [
      "Unmet acceptance criterion."
    ],
    "requirements": [
      "Unmet requirement."
    ]
  },
  "issueCreation": {
    "action": "create_remaining_work_issue",
    "reason": "Some criteria are already implemented; the provider issue should track only the remaining work."
  }
}

For a not implemented story:

{
  "implementationStatus": "not_implemented",
  "issueCreation": {
    "action": "create_issue",
    "reason": "No implementation evidence found."
  }
}

For an unverifiable story:

{
  "implementationStatus": "unverifiable",
  "issueCreation": {
    "action": "manual_review",
    "reason": "Repository evidence is insufficient to safely create implementation work."
  }
}

issueCreation is the canonical provider-neutral field. jiraCreation may be included only as a temporary compatibility alias when an existing Jira consumer requires it; new GitHub-facing handoffs must not rely on jiraCreation.

Markdown Report

The markdown report must include:

• Source design title or path.
• Story ID, summary, and implementation status for every story.
• Evidence for implemented requirements.
• Remaining work for partially implemented stories.
• Skipped fully implemented stories.
• Unverifiable stories and the exact missing evidence or ambiguity.
• Doc-drift notes: when repository evidence shows the canonical source document itself is stale, wrong, or internally inconsistent (not just a story), record the document path, the contradicted claim, and the evidence. These notes are informational input for doc reconciliation; they do not change Jira actions.
• Confirmation that provider issue creation should consume the reconciled JSON, not the original unreconciled story list.

Key Rules

• Do not create provider issues.
• Do not create downstream workflow executions.
• Do not implement code.
• Do not create or modify spec.md.
• Do not delete original story scope, source references, coverage IDs, dependencies, assumptions, or non-goals.
• Fully implemented stories must use issueCreation.action = "skip".
• Partially implemented stories must preserve original scope and define remainingWork.
• Unverifiable stories must use issueCreation.action = "manual_review" so deterministic issue creation will not create work automatically.