Feature Critic

Use after an ExecPlan exists and before implementation starts. Critique the plan from failure-oriented lenses such as security, UX, reliability, privacy, abuse, and eval coverage, then produce the minimum set of plan changes needed before coding.

moorage Updated 0 repo stars

File contents

Use this skill after an ExecPlan has been drafted for non-trivial feature work.

Good fits:

  • user-facing product features
  • agent or tool-calling workflows
  • work involving auth, messaging, integrations, or sensitive data
  • plans with staged rollout, monitoring, or rollback requirements

Goal

Stress-test the ExecPlan before implementation starts.

The output is a concise critique memo, not a rewrite of the whole plan.

Required workflow

  1. Read the current ExecPlan and relevant repo guidance.
  2. Restate the feature and implementation intent in one short paragraph.
  3. Select 3 to 5 critics and explain why each matters.
  4. For each critic, identify:
    • the fragile assumption
    • the missing risk or validation
    • the required ExecPlan change
  5. Prioritize findings into:
    • must fix before implementation
    • should fix if low-cost
    • monitor during implementation

moorage/fullwell commit e28ce664bc

Frequently asked questions

npx get-skill add moorage/feature-critic