Critical

Adversarially challenges a proposed plan, code change, or bug diagnosis from a hostile pre-mortem perspective. Walks a fixed taxonomy of failure modes, blast radius, rollback, hidden coupling, and maintainability; every finding must cite a file, line, or named assumption; forces a steelman of at least one alternative. Surfaces concerns only — does not score (delegates to `/confidence`) and does not apply fixes. Use during planning before autonomous execution, before opening a high-stakes PR, or when a fix "feels off". One adversarial pass per run — naïve self-refine loops amplify bias. Modes: plan (default), code, analysis. Triggers on "critical", "challenge this", "pre-mortem", "red-team this", "/critical".

mthines Updated 20 repo stars
aw: one sentence in, a reviewed pull request out. It sizes the job (Micro, Lite, Full); a Full task runs Brief, Build until green, Fresh-eyes review, and Draft

File contents

mthines/agent-skills commit 4b26979516

Frequently asked questions

npx get-skill add mthines/critical