Migrate V2 To V3

Migrate kube-hetzner v2 to v3

Purpose

Safely migrate an existing kube-hetzner cluster from v2.x to v3.x.

This skill is for real user Terraform roots, not for brand-new clusters. It prioritizes preserving infrastructure and making Terraform validation failures actionable.

Canonical References

Read these before editing:

1. docs/v2-to-v3-migration.md - operational migration playbook
2. docs/v3-release-evidence.md - live v2.21 -> v3 upgrade evidence
3. MIGRATION.md - canonical old-to-new variable map
4. CHANGELOG.md - v3 upgrade notes and release context
5. variables.tf - exact v3 input contract and validation rules
6. kube.tf.example - current v3 configuration example
7. scripts/v2_to_v3_migration_assistant.py - static config and plan audit
8. docs/selinux.md - SELinux policy, AVC evidence, and per-pool fallback
9. scripts/destroy.sh and scripts/cleanup.sh - teardown and orphan cleanup

Safety Rules

• Never run terraform apply unless the user explicitly asks after plan review.
• Always back up state before changing the module version.
• Never ignore destroy, replace, or forces replacement in a v3 upgrade plan.
• Do not allow a silent K3s channel policy change. MIGRATION.md documents that v2 defaulted k3s_channel to v1.33; v3 defaults it to stable while automatic Kubernetes upgrades remain default-on. The user must choose before the first v3 apply.
• Treat replacements for hcloud_network, hcloud_network_subnet, hcloud_server, hcloud_load_balancer, hcloud_primary_ip, hcloud_placement_group, hcloud_volume, or hcloud_firewall as blockers until explained.
• For production in-place upgrades, MIGRATION.md is the operator-facing safety contract. Its no-destroy jq gate is canonical; do not weaken or abbreviate it.
• Never reorder or insert control-plane or agent nodepools mid-list during or after migration. Node resource addresses are index-keyed; append only unless the user is intentionally planning a state migration or blue/green rebuild.
• Do not "fix" a v3 validation error by bypassing validation. Fix the configuration.
• For custom network, private-only, Robot/vSwitch, or multinetwork clusters, prefer recommending blue/green if the in-place plan is not clearly safe.

Required Inputs

Determine:

• Terraform root path.
• Current module source/version.
• Target v3 tag.
• Kubernetes distribution intent: keep k3s, or explicitly plan an RKE2 rebuild/ migration separately from the base v2 -> v3 module upgrade.
• K3s version/channel intent: pin k3s_version, set k3s_channel = "v1.33", or consciously accept v3 stable.
• Whether nodes have out-of-band root SSH keys outside ssh_public_key/ssh_additional_public_keys.
• Whether Terraform can SSH to every existing node for terraform_data.initial_readiness, including private-only, NAT, and bastion topologies.
• Whether this is a live production cluster.
• Whether it uses NAT router, private-only nodes, Robot/vSwitch, autoscaler, Cilium, Longhorn, or external networks.
• Whether SELinux workload denials are currently part of the incident. If yes, collect AVC evidence and follow docs/selinux.md rather than disabling SELinux globally.

Workflow

1. Inspect Current Root

From the user's Terraform root:

terraform version
terraform providers
rg -n 'module "kube-hetzner"|source\\s*=|version\\s*=' .

Find v2-only inputs:

uv run python /path/to/kube-hetzner/scripts/v2_to_v3_migration_assistant.py --root .
rg -n 'kubernetes_distribution_type|k3s_token|secrets_encryption|initial_k3s_channel|install_k3s_version|initial_rke2_channel|install_rke2_version|automatically_upgrade_k3s|sys_upgrade_controller_version|additional_k3s_environment|kubeapi_port|k3s_registries|k3s_kubelet_config|k3s_audit_policy_config|k3s_audit_log_path|k3s_audit_log_maxage|k3s_audit_log_maxbackup|k3s_audit_log_maxsize|k3s_exec_server_args|k3s_exec_agent_args|k3s_global_kubelet_args|k3s_control_plane_kubelet_args|k3s_agent_kubelet_args|k3s_autoscaler_kubelet_args|subnet_amount|placement_group_disable|block_icmp_ping_in|disable_hetzner_csi|load_balancer_disable_ipv6|load_balancer_disable_public_network|use_control_plane_lb|combine_load_balancers|control_plane_lb_type|control_plane_lb_enable_public_interface|control_plane_lb_enable_public_network|lb_hostname|robot_ccm_enabled|hetzner_ccm_use_helm|enable_hetzner_ccm_helm|cilium_loadbalancer_acceleration_mode|enable_wireguard|k8s_config_updates_use_kured_sentinel|keep_disk_agents|keep_disk_cp|use_private_bastion|disable_kube_proxy|disable_network_policy|disable_selinux|k3s_prefer_bundled_bin|placement_group_compat_idx|disable_ipv4|disable_ipv6|autoscaler_disable_ipv4|autoscaler_disable_ipv6|existing_network_id|enable_x86|enable_arm|k3s_encryption_at_rest|autoscaler_labels|autoscaler_taints|extra_kustomize_' .

The assistant is the primary first-pass report. The rg command is a manual cross-check when a root uses unusual formatting, Terragrunt, generated HCL, or split tfvars.

2. Back Up

terraform state pull > "terraform-state-before-kube-hetzner-v3-$(date +%Y%m%d%H%M%S).json"
find . -maxdepth 1 -name '*.tf' -print

If editing user config directly, preserve a copy of touched .tf files.

3. Rewrite Configuration

Use MIGRATION.md for the complete map. Critical transformations:

• Rename distribution-neutral inputs, e.g. k3s_token -> cluster_token and kubernetes_distribution_type -> kubernetes_distribution.
• Invert negative booleans:
  • disable_kube_proxy -> enable_kube_proxy
  • disable_network_policy -> enable_network_policy
  • disable_selinux -> enable_selinux
  • nodepool disable_ipv4/disable_ipv6 -> enable_public_ipv4/enable_public_ipv6
  • autoscaler_disable_ipv4/disable_ipv6 -> autoscaler_enable_public_ipv4/autoscaler_enable_public_ipv6
• Replace existing_network_id = ["123"] with existing_network = { id = 123 }.
• Replace enable_x86/enable_arm with enabled_architectures.
• Remove control-plane network_id; control planes are primary-network only.
• Remove network_id = 0; primary network is omitted/null in v3.
• Keep the default network_subnet_mode = "per_nodepool" for normal in-place v2 upgrades; this matches released v2 subnet resources. Use network_subnet_mode = "shared" only for new clusters or intentional subnet topology changes.
• Replace placement_group_compat_idx with placement_group_index.
• Replace extra_kustomize_* with user_kustomizations.
• Remove enable_iscsid, k3s_encryption_at_rest, autoscaler_labels, and autoscaler_taints.
• Remove hetzner_ccm_use_helm / enable_hetzner_ccm_helm; v3 always installs Hetzner CCM through the HelmChart manifest.
• Do not reorder or insert existing nodepools while rewriting. Append new nodepools only. If the user wants to change list order, stop and treat that as a separate state-migration or blue/green design problem.

4. Decide First-Apply Intent

Resolve these before the first v3 apply:

• Kubernetes channel policy. MIGRATION.md documents the silent default change: v2 used k3s_channel = "v1.33", v3 uses k3s_channel = "stable", and automatically_upgrade_kubernetes remains default-on. Make the user choose exactly one:
  • pin k3s_version
  • set k3s_channel = "v1.33" to preserve the v2 minor channel
  • consciously accept following stable
• Addon version policy. v2 unset/floating addon versions resolved upstream-latest. v3 unset addon versions use kube-hetzner's reviewed deterministic default matrix. The upgrade plan may show one-time addon version changes. Keeping floating behavior requires explicitly setting latest.
• SSH authorized keys policy. On the first v3 apply, terraform_data.ssh_authorized_keys reconciles /root/.ssh/authorized_keys. The default preserves unknown out-of-band keys while revoking module-managed keys removed from ssh_public_key or ssh_additional_public_keys. Set ssh_authorized_keys_exclusive = true only when the user wants strict replacement with exactly the module-managed keys.
• Node reachability. terraform_data.initial_readiness SSHes to every existing control-plane and agent node. Private-only, NAT, and bastion-only operators must have Terraform reachability to all nodes before applying.

The proven 2026-07-04/05 standard live upgrade needed only the module source switch plus k3s_channel = "v1.33" for the first v3 plan.

5. Initialize And Validate

terraform fmt -recursive
terraform init -upgrade
terraform validate -no-color
tmpdir="$(mktemp -d)"
rsync -a --exclude .git --exclude .terraform --exclude .terraform-tofu ./ "$tmpdir"/
(cd "$tmpdir" && tofu init -backend=false -input=false && tofu validate -no-color)
rm -rf "$tmpdir"

terraform validate checks that the module loads. v3 cross-variable migration guards are enforced by terraform_data.validation_contract, so the saved terraform plan is the required proof for invalid combinations and replacement risk.

If validation fails, read the variable and validation block in variables.tf before changing config.

6. Plan

terraform plan -out=v3-upgrade.tfplan
terraform show v3-upgrade.tfplan
terraform show -json v3-upgrade.tfplan > v3-upgrade-plan.json
uv run python /path/to/kube-hetzner/scripts/v2_to_v3_migration_assistant.py --root . --plan-json v3-upgrade-plan.json --strict

The strict auditor also blocks standalone server-network detachment and flags changed or unknown inline private/public networking. No server replacements does not prove IP/MAC preservation, persistent guest routing, or quorum-safe rollout. Follow MIGRATION.md#network-and-ssh-transition-limits; preserve the existing SSH port and compare effective Cilium values before migration.

If jq is available, list destructive actions:

terraform show -json v3-upgrade.tfplan \
  | jq -r '.resource_changes[]? | select(.change.actions | index("delete")) | "\(.address): \(.change.actions | join(","))"'

For live v2 -> v3 migrations, run the protected-infrastructure gate. Terraform replacements show up as action lists containing delete. The gate prints only blocking resources; any output is a stop condition:

terraform show -json v3-upgrade.tfplan \
  | jq -r '
      .resource_changes[]?
      | select(.type as $type | [
          "hcloud_server",
          "hcloud_network",
          "hcloud_network_subnet",
          "hcloud_load_balancer",
          "hcloud_volume",
          "hcloud_primary_ip",
          "hcloud_placement_group",
          "hcloud_firewall"
        ] | index($type))
      | select(.change.actions | index("delete"))
      | "\(.address): \(.type) \(.change.actions | join(","))"
    '

After the v2 renames, the plan must show zero destroy/replace actions for hcloud_server, hcloud_network, hcloud_network_subnet, hcloud_load_balancer, hcloud_volume, hcloud_primary_ip, hcloud_placement_group, and hcloud_firewall. Stop and diagnose before apply if any of those types are listed.

Do not panic-abort a healthy first v3 plan for these expected actions:

• one idempotent k3s/RKE2 kustomization re-run from trigger-key additions
• new terraform_data resources for readiness, SSH authorized-key reconcile, validators, and destroy cleanup
• in-place server label updates such as kube-hetzner/os
• firewall rule updates

7. Interpret Special Cases

• NAT router primary IP replacement from pre-v2.19 clusters may require state migration before apply.
• existing_network plus vswitch_id cannot have module-managed expose_routes_to_vswitch; set it false or enable route exposure manually.
• Private-only clusters need a working NAT/bastion/control-plane join path.
• Multinetwork public overlay is a lab-only preview. It requires multinetwork_mode = "cilium_public_overlay", enable_experimental_cilium_public_overlay = true, and cni_plugin = "cilium"; do not recommend it for production upgrades until the live datapath E2E passes.
• Tailscale node transport is statically validated and plan-matrix covered, but live Hetzner/Tailscale E2E remains pending. Use node_transport_mode = "tailscale" for evaluation and separate audited plans; do not certify production topologies from static checks alone.
• Tailscale mode keeps Kubernetes node IPs on Hetzner private addresses and can advertise node-private /32 routes with Tailscale subnet-route SNAT disabled. Single-network clusters may disable route advertisement; external network_scope = "external" nodepools require route advertisement and Tailnet auto-approval.
• External agent/autoscaler Network IDs must be positive Hetzner Network IDs. Omit/null means the primary Network. In Tailscale mode, active agent/autoscaler nodepools must also set network_scope = "primary" or network_scope = "external" so same-root external Network IDs validate during terraform plan.
• Do not add new optional v3 features such as cilium_gateway_api_enabled, embedded_registry_mirror, new Tailscale multinetwork shards, or external Cloudflare Access/Tunnel routing during the same first in-place v2-to-v3 apply unless the operator explicitly accepts a blue/green/topology-change migration. Upgrade cleanly first, then add those features in a separate reviewed plan.
• Cloudflare Access/Tunnel is an external access pattern only. Do not invent Cloudflare provider inputs, and do not recommend Cloudflare Mesh/WARP as kube-hetzner node transport during a migration.
• SELinux remains enabled by default in v3. For workload denials, use docs/selinux.md: collect AVC lines, try udica-generated workload policy first, propose upstream module policy only with reproducible AVC evidence, and use per-pool selinux = false only as the last resort.
• If the user later destroys the cluster, use scripts/destroy.sh from the Terraform root. It auto-retries only the known benign ingress-LB detach race (resource_already_detaching/422 from dual CCM and Terraform ownership) and then prints a read-only orphan report for unlabeled primary IPs, out-of-state autoscaled nodes, and exact managed LB names. Use scripts/cleanup.sh only as the forceful fallback after the report shows leftovers or state is already wrecked. It treats the token's entire HCloud project as cluster-dedicated; review the dry run and include persistent data only deliberately.
• Autoscaler-created servers are not in Terraform state and can pin network/subnet deletion. Delete those orphans only after the control plane is dead, or first scale the autoscaler pool to min_nodes = 0; deleting them earlier while Cluster Autoscaler is alive can recreate them.
• If adding Cilium Gateway API after migration, require cni_plugin = "cilium" and enable_kube_proxy = false.
• If adding embedded registry mirror after migration, warn that nodes are equal-trust registry peers and critical images should use digests.

8. Report

Return a migration report:

## kube-hetzner v2 -> v3 migration report

- Terraform root:
- Source version:
- Target version:
- Terraform/OpenTofu version:
- hcloud provider version:
- K3s channel/version intent:
- Kubernetes distribution intent:
- Addon version intent:
- SSH authorized_keys policy:
- SELinux intent and AVC evidence, if relevant:
- Inputs changed:
- Inputs removed:
- Manual state actions:
- Validation result:
- Plan result:
- Protected hcloud delete/replace gate:
- Replacements/destroys:
- Expected first-apply actions:
- Blockers:
- Recommendation:

Apply Policy

Only run:

terraform apply v3-upgrade.tfplan

after explicit user approval and after the plan report has no unexplained destructive actions.