Tune

Tune

Every RAG system has a distribution where it breaks. The only way to know whether gnosis-mcp's defaults are right for your corpus is to measure them against your queries. This skill runs that measurement.

Usage

/gnosis:tune                       # Quick sweep (5 chunk sizes, keyword mode)
/gnosis:tune full                  # Extended sweep (keyword + hybrid + rerank on/off)
/gnosis:tune --golden ./q.jsonl    # Use a specific golden-query file

Mode: $ARGUMENTS

Prerequisites

You need:

1. A corpus — anywhere on disk. Will be passed to gnosis-mcp ingest.

2. A golden-query file — one JSON object per line:

   {"query": "how does our auth work", "expected_paths": ["docs/auth", "architecture/auth"]}
   {"query": "stripe webhook failure runbook", "expected_paths": ["runbooks/stripe"]}
   

   expected_paths uses substring match against the returned file_path, case-insensitive. Generous enough that you don't need exact path memorization.

20 hand-written queries is enough to get signal. 50 is plenty.

Quick sweep (default)

Runs gnosis-mcp ingest 5 times with different chunk sizes, scoring each with your golden set. Keyword mode only (fast, no embedding cost).

# Default path if none given: ./docs + ./golden.jsonl
CORPUS=${CORPUS:-./docs}
GOLDEN=${GOLDEN:-./golden.jsonl}

for size in 1000 1500 2000 2500 3000; do
  uv run --with 'gnosis-mcp[embeddings] @ gnosis-mcp' \
    python tests/bench/bench_real_corpus.py \
      --corpus "$CORPUS" --golden "$GOLDEN" \
      --modes keyword --chunk-size $size \
      --out bench-results/tune-chunk${size}.json
done

(If gnosis-mcp was installed via pip rather than from source, invoke bench_real_corpus.py from the repo you cloned, and drop the uv run --with '... @ .' prefix.)

Expected runtime: 5–10 minutes per size on a typical laptop (ingest is the dominant cost; scoring itself is sub-second).

Output table:

chunk  chars │ nDCG@10 │ MRR    │ Hit@5  │ p95      │ ingest
────────────┼─────────┼────────┼────────┼──────────┼────────
       1000 │ 0.8557  │ 0.8067 │ 0.92   │ 30 ms    │ 592 s
       1500 │ 0.8529  │ 0.7967 │ 0.92   │  7 ms    │ 234 s
       2000 │ 0.8702  │ 0.7933 │ 0.92   │  7 ms    │ 210 s   ← peak
       2500 │ 0.8602  │ 0.7880 │ 0.92   │  7 ms    │ 195 s
       3000 │ 0.8459  │ 0.7880 │ 0.92   │  7 ms    │ 182 s

Pick the chunk size with the best nDCG@10 that doesn't blow your ingest-time budget. Persist it:

# In your shell profile / .env
export GNOSIS_MCP_CHUNK_SIZE=2000

If multiple sizes tie at the top (plateau), pick the larger one — same quality, fewer chunks, faster ingest.

Full sweep (full)

Adds hybrid mode and optional reranker A/B — ~30-40 minutes depending on corpus size and whether [reranking] is installed.

for size in 1500 2000 3000; do
  for mode in keyword hybrid hybrid+rerank; do
    uv run --with 'gnosis-mcp[embeddings,reranking] @ gnosis-mcp' \
      python tests/bench/bench_real_corpus.py \
        --corpus "$CORPUS" --golden "$GOLDEN" \
        --modes "$mode" --chunk-size $size \
        --out "bench-results/tune-${mode//+/_}-${size}.json"
  done
done

What to read from the output

1. nDCG delta between keyword and hybrid: if < 0.02, your corpus is vocabulary-matched (queries share exact terms with docs). Dense retrieval adds latency without lift — leave hybrid off.

2. nDCG delta when reranker is added: on dev docs specifically, we measure -27 nDCG (!). If you see a similar drop, your corpus has the same distribution problem — disable GNOSIS_MCP_RERANK_ENABLED. If it's +3-10 on your corpus, keep it on.

3. Chunk-size peak location: tells you the typical topic-coherent block length in your corpus. API-reference-heavy corpora peak lower (1000-1500 chars). Long-form prose peaks higher (2500-3000).

Programmatic golden-set from existing access logs

If you've been using gnosis-mcp for a while, real queries are already logged. Generate a seed golden file from them:

sqlite3 ~/.local/share/gnosis-mcp/docs.db \
  "SELECT DISTINCT query FROM search_access_log
   WHERE timestamp > date('now', '-30 days')
   ORDER BY count(*) DESC LIMIT 30;" \
  | awk '{print "{\"query\":\""$0"\", \"expected_paths\": []}"}' > golden-seed.jsonl

Then fill in expected_paths by hand — 5 minutes of work, gives you a golden set grounded in how you actually use the system.

Automate the winner

After picking a chunk size and reranker/hybrid choice, persist it so every gnosis-mcp ingest (manual or via --watch) uses the tuned settings:

# Persistent across processes
export GNOSIS_MCP_CHUNK_SIZE=2000
export GNOSIS_MCP_RERANK_ENABLED=false  # if tune showed it hurts

# Re-ingest with the new config
gnosis-mcp ingest ./docs --embed --wipe

When to re-tune

• Corpus grows 2× or more
• You add a fundamentally different content type (e.g., API references added to a prose-only corpus, or vice versa)
• You switch embedder (GNOSIS_MCP_EMBED_MODEL) — the semantic side of hybrid now behaves differently
• After a new release of gnosis-mcp that touched chunking or fusion

Otherwise: tune once per year. It's not free but it's not frequent.

See also

• bench-experiments-2026-04-18 — our own tune results with the methodology that informed these defaults
• how-we-measure-search — what these metrics mean, in plain English
• /gnosis:ingest — re-ingest after you've picked the winner