Review History

Review History

Investigate how code evolved over time to understand current behavior or find regressions.

Usage

/review-history src/auth/login.ts
/review-history the authentication flow
/review-history UserProfile component

Gotchas

• git log -S finds commits where the string was added OR removed. A commit that deleted a function surfaces as equally relevant to the one that added it — verify the direction of change.
• Squash merges erase commit-level traceability. git reflog only works locally and expires — if another contributor squashed and force-pushed, the original commits are unrecoverable.

Workflow

Step 1: Identify Target Files

From the provided topic, identify the relevant files:

• If a file path is given, use it directly
• If a feature/function name, locate relevant files using this strategy:
  1. Grep for the exact function/class name to find where it is defined and used
  2. Glob for files with the feature name in the path (e.g., **/*payment*)
  3. Prioritize source files over test files; include tests only if investigating test behavior
  4. Limit to the 5 most relevant files to keep the analysis focused

Step 2: Git History Analysis

Run these in parallel:

Recent commits touching the area:

git log --oneline -20 -- <file_or_directory>

Detailed blame for key sections:

# For files > 200 lines: target the specific function or section under investigation.
# Use Grep to find the line range first, then:
git blame -L <start>,<end> <file>

# For files ≤ 200 lines: blame the entire file:
git blame <file>

Find when specific code was introduced:

git log -S "<search_term>" --oneline -- <file>

Check for recent refactors:

git log --oneline --since="3 months ago" -- <file_or_directory>

Adjust the time window based on context:

• Investigating a recent regression: use --since="2 weeks ago"
• Understanding a feature's evolution: use --since="6 months ago" or omit --since entirely
• If the initial window returns fewer than 3 commits, double the window and retry once

Step 3: Search Past Issue Logs

Check if this problem occurred before:

1. List past issue logs:

   • Glob pattern: docs/log/*.md

2. Search logs for relevant keywords:

   • Grep pattern: {keywords} path: docs/log/

Look for:

• Similar error messages
• Same file/function names
• Related symptoms

Step 4: Synthesize Findings

Populate the report using these methods:

• Recent Changes: List commits from git log, most recent first. Include only commits that touch the target code.
• Key Code Introduction: Use git log -S results to identify when the function/feature first appeared and its last substantive change (skip formatting-only commits).
• Related Past Issues: Direct matches from Step 3. If none found, state "None found in docs/log/".
• Regression Risk: Compare current behavior against commit history. If code worked before a specific commit and broke after, name that commit. If no clear regression point, state "No clear regression identified — behavior may be by design."

Report:

## History Analysis: {target}

### Recent Changes
| Date | Commit | Author | Summary |
|------|--------|--------|---------|
| {date} | {hash} | {author} | {message} |

### Key Code Introduction
- `{function/feature}` introduced in {commit} on {date}
- Last modified: {commit} by {author}

### Related Past Issues
{any matching docs/log entries, or "None found"}

### Regression Risk
{assessment: was this working before? when did it break?}

Examples

Trace when a payment bug was introduced:

/review-history processPayment

Uses git log -S and git blame to trace the payment processing function, identifies the commit that changed the rounding logic three weeks ago, and cross-references with past issue logs to confirm this is when the billing discrepancy started.

Understand why validation works a certain way:

/review-history src/validators/address.ts

Analyzes the git history of the address validator, surfaces the original commit that added the unusual postal code regex along with its commit message explaining a partner API requirement, and checks past issue logs for related context.

Troubleshooting

Relevant commit was squashed or rebased away

Solution: Use git reflog to find the original commit before the squash or rebase. If the reflog has expired, search for the change using git log -S "<code_snippet>" --all to locate it in any branch or dangling commit.

History is too large to analyze effectively

Solution: Narrow the scope by passing a specific file path or function name instead of a broad directory. Use --since with git log to limit the time window, or focus on a single author's contributions with --author.

Notes

• Focus on commits from the last 3-6 months unless investigating older issues
• Pay attention to refactors, dependency updates, and merge commits
• If a past issue log matches, read it fully - it may contain the solution