Pfandleihi (exact-hold-pass)
Exact Hold Pass (product holds + dup loans)
Distilled from haotang1995's hold_pass (ecdsa.fail record submission e5f4dddc,
2026-10-29): 17,919 dup loans + 53 product holds, −53 T exact (dλ 0.000,
identical failing shots), implemented as the last pass before the nonce tail.
Reusable on any reversible op stream with repeated products or idle live wires.
The two primitives
- Product hold. If an unconditional
CCX(a,b -> t)is recomputed later and the product still lives on a held copy, replace the repeat with aCXfrom the copy. Place a hold only if (live count + already-placed holds) ≤ width cap over the whole hold interval, and the copy sits on a wire provably |0⟩ at placement. - Dup loan. If a live wire is idle over an interval and another live wire holds
the same value (or its complement) at both interval ends, clear the wire with
CXat the start and rebuild it withCXat the end. Clifford-only; frees width that product holds can spend.
Why it is exact — the correctness machinery
- Track every wire's value symbolically as an affine form over atoms: inputs, measurement outcomes, and products of affine forms.
- Fingerprint forms with a 128-bit random linear hash; equal hash ⇒ identical function up to collision probability ~2^-128. "Provably |0⟩" means form 0.
- No measurement is added and no RNG draw changes — the random-coin schedule stays aligned, so the nonce machinery upstream is untouched.
- Fail closed: if any relocation step cannot prove its precondition, the pass returns the stream unchanged, not a best-effort edit.
Operating rules
- Run it last, after every statistical pass, before the nonce tail — earlier passes change the stream and invalidate the intervals.
- Verify with a paired exact evaluation against the parent: expected signature is dT < 0 with dλ = 0.000 and byte-identical failing-shot sets. Any λ movement means the symbolic model leaked; revert and autopsy.
- The exactness caveat is the hash, nothing else: exact up to ~2^-128. Say so in the note.
Where to hunt for holds
- Repeated unconditional products emitted by template bodies (compute/inverse pairs that re-derive the same intermediate).
- Long idle intervals on live wires near the width peak — a dup loan there converts dead width into hold capacity exactly where holds need it.
- Do not confuse with measured-lifetime elimination at fixed width: their worker logged 38,665 such attempts with 0 committed. Loans and holds pay because they are value-equality driven, not liveness driven.