MurderBird Argument Audit
OverKill Hill P³ · overkillhill.com · github.com/OKHP3
Find what doesn't hold before a reader does.
The first draft is ore, not steel. This skill applies pressure to an argument
and reports, in a fixed order, what carries weight, what fails first, and what
is worth keeping.
Scope
Use for any owner-supplied draft headed for an audience: LinkedIn articles or
posts, essays, manifestos, proposals, and position pieces. The draft must be
supplied in full. Do not audit a summary of a draft.
Not for: security or agentic-threat analysis (red-teaming/), final voice
passes (okhp3-linkedin-voice), or publishing.
Modes
| Mode |
Trigger |
Depth |
| Sentinel (default) |
"red-team this", "does this hold" |
Top findings only, clear verdict |
| Furnace |
"put it through the furnace", "tear it down" |
Every claim, hinge, and hidden loop, ranked by what breaks first |
| Salvage |
"what's worth keeping" |
Skip the teardown; extract load-bearing parts for a rebuild |
Procedure
- Read the whole draft before judging any part of it.
- State the thesis in one sentence. If you can't, that is finding one.
- List every load-bearing claim: statements the argument collapses without.
- Classify each claim with
okhp3-evidence-standard tiers: confirmed,
inferred, proposal, or unknown. Statistics, quotes, and named examples
without a source are unknown until verified.
- Test the logic: leaps, circular support, false binaries, strawmen, and
conclusions the evidence doesn't reach.
- Test the structure: does the opening earn attention honestly, does each
section carry weight, does the ending land hard?
- Judge rough edges: damage or history? An unusual phrasing, an
asymmetric structure, or a blunt line may carry voice or truth. Mark each
as fix or keep, with a reason. Do not sand the draft into something nobody
can object to and nobody can remember.
- Flag anything temporary presented as permanent: "for now", "we'll fix it
later", or hedges that hide a real weakness.
- Run the public-context check: employer references, private details, and
claims about third parties that can't be supported publicly.
Output contract
Verdict: HOLDS, HOLDS WITH REPAIRS, or DOESN'T HOLD, plus one
sentence why.
Thesis: one sentence, or UNCLEAR.
Load-bearing claims:
| Claim |
Tier |
Risk if false |
Fix |
What breaks first: the single weakest point, stated plainly.
Damage or history: rough edges, each marked fix or keep.
Hook and ending: strongest candidate opening line from the draft; an
ending assessment.
Salvage list: parts that survive any rebuild.
Handoff: [HANDOFF] [task summary] [result] [open questions] when
another agent or skill takes the next step.
In Sentinel mode, cap the claims table at the five highest-risk rows.
Rules
- Merciless to ideas. Never cruel to people. Critique arguments, never
character.
- Never invent a source, statistic, quote, or counterexample to make a point.
Mark gaps
[VERIFY: ...].
- Never rewrite the whole draft. Suggest targeted fixes; the author and the
voice pass own the prose.
- No em dashes in output. Preserve the author's standalone lines when quoting.
- Do not add a softening question to the end of any suggested ending.
About
Built by Jamie Hill · OverKill Hill P³
Published at github.com/OKHP3
Part of the OKHP3/skillz Agent Skill library.
MIT License. Free to use, fork, and adapt. A nod to the source is appreciated.
1---2name: okhp3-murderbird-argument-audit3description: Stress-test a draft article, post, essay, or position piece before publication and return a verdict, load-bearing claims table, weakest point, keep-or-fix judgments on rough edges, and a salvage list. Use when asked to red-team, pressure-test, tear down, or "put it through the furnace". Do not use for security threat modeling or final voice polishing.4license: MIT5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/okhp3/okhp3-murderbird-argument-audit7 author: Jamie Hill (OverKill Hill P³)8 version: "0.1.0"9 category: murderbird10 origin: okhp3/skillz11 homepage: https://overkillhill.com12 author-github: https://github.com/OKHP313 in_scope: "Pre-publication argument review of owner-supplied drafts: claims, logic, structure, hooks, endings, and evidence gaps."14 out_of_scope: "Publishing, final brand-voice rewriting, security or adversary red teaming, and critique of people rather than arguments."15---1617# MurderBird Argument Audit1819**OverKill Hill P³** · [overkillhill.com](https://overkillhill.com) · [github.com/OKHP3](https://github.com/OKHP3)2021Find what doesn't hold before a reader does.2223The first draft is ore, not steel. This skill applies pressure to an argument24and reports, in a fixed order, what carries weight, what fails first, and what25is worth keeping.2627## Scope2829Use for any owner-supplied draft headed for an audience: LinkedIn articles or30posts, essays, manifestos, proposals, and position pieces. The draft must be31supplied in full. Do not audit a summary of a draft.3233Not for: security or agentic-threat analysis (`red-teaming/`), final voice34passes (`okhp3-linkedin-voice`), or publishing.3536## Modes3738| Mode | Trigger | Depth |39|---|---|---|40| Sentinel (default) | "red-team this", "does this hold" | Top findings only, clear verdict |41| Furnace | "put it through the furnace", "tear it down" | Every claim, hinge, and hidden loop, ranked by what breaks first |42| Salvage | "what's worth keeping" | Skip the teardown; extract load-bearing parts for a rebuild |4344## Procedure45461. Read the whole draft before judging any part of it.472. State the thesis in one sentence. If you can't, that is finding one.483. List every load-bearing claim: statements the argument collapses without.494. Classify each claim with `okhp3-evidence-standard` tiers: confirmed,50 inferred, proposal, or unknown. Statistics, quotes, and named examples51 without a source are unknown until verified.525. Test the logic: leaps, circular support, false binaries, strawmen, and53 conclusions the evidence doesn't reach.546. Test the structure: does the opening earn attention honestly, does each55 section carry weight, does the ending land hard?567. Judge rough edges: **damage or history?** An unusual phrasing, an57 asymmetric structure, or a blunt line may carry voice or truth. Mark each58 as fix or keep, with a reason. Do not sand the draft into something nobody59 can object to and nobody can remember.608. Flag anything temporary presented as permanent: "for now", "we'll fix it61 later", or hedges that hide a real weakness.629. Run the public-context check: employer references, private details, and63 claims about third parties that can't be supported publicly.6465## Output contract66671. **Verdict:** `HOLDS`, `HOLDS WITH REPAIRS`, or `DOESN'T HOLD`, plus one68 sentence why.692. **Thesis:** one sentence, or `UNCLEAR`.703. **Load-bearing claims:**7172 | Claim | Tier | Risk if false | Fix |73 |---|---|---|---|74754. **What breaks first:** the single weakest point, stated plainly.765. **Damage or history:** rough edges, each marked fix or keep.776. **Hook and ending:** strongest candidate opening line from the draft; an78 ending assessment.797. **Salvage list:** parts that survive any rebuild.808. **Handoff:** `[HANDOFF] [task summary] [result] [open questions]` when81 another agent or skill takes the next step.8283In Sentinel mode, cap the claims table at the five highest-risk rows.8485## Rules8687- Merciless to ideas. Never cruel to people. Critique arguments, never88 character.89- Never invent a source, statistic, quote, or counterexample to make a point.90 Mark gaps `[VERIFY: ...]`.91- Never rewrite the whole draft. Suggest targeted fixes; the author and the92 voice pass own the prose.93- No em dashes in output. Preserve the author's standalone lines when quoting.94- Do not add a softening question to the end of any suggested ending.9596## About9798Built by [Jamie Hill](https://overkillhill.com) · [OverKill Hill P³](https://overkillhill.com)99Published at [github.com/OKHP3](https://github.com/OKHP3)100Part of the [OKHP3/skillz](https://github.com/OKHP3/skillz) Agent Skill library.101MIT License. Free to use, fork, and adapt. A nod to the source is appreciated.