API and interface design
Contract
| Field |
Bound contract |
| Trigger |
Designing or changing a public API, route, CLI flag, or module boundary. |
| Authority |
Reversible local: writes only named local interface definitions and contract docs, edits consumer files onto the new contract, and deletes legacy paths (old signatures, aliases, re-exports, deprecated entry points) during cutover; rollback is undo (discard the uncommitted draft) or version control. No remote mutation. No credential, paid, published, or deployed change, and no VCS history rewrite. |
| Side effect |
Interface definitions and contract docs written before implementation; consumer files edited onto the new contract and legacy paths (old signatures, aliases, re-exports, deprecated entry points) deleted during cutover; no build, publish, or remote mutation. |
| Done |
Contract is documented with semantics and errors, every consumer is migrated, and no legacy path remains. |
Inputs
The interface being designed or changed: its name and kind (API endpoint, route, CLI flag, or module boundary), and whether it is new or a change to an existing interface. The current contract text, when changing an existing interface. The list of known consumers, found by search over the codebase. Optional: target language or runtime conventions for type and error spelling.
Procedure
- Bound scope before any mutation: name the exact interface and whether it is new or a change. Search the codebase for every consumer and record the list; record any consumer that cannot be inspected as an unmigrated risk. Done when: every consumer is listed and uninspectable ones are marked as risks.
- Write the contract before implementation. For each operation, field, or flag, document its name, input types, output type, error cases, and side effects. State semantics explicitly: idempotent or not, ordering, nullability, encoding, and concurrency. Done when: every operation, field, and flag has documented semantics and errors.
- For a change to an existing interface, classify it as breaking or non-breaking. If breaking, design the cutover in one change: the new contract, the per-consumer migration, and the removal of the legacy path. Done when: the cutover is designed as one change.
- Validate inputs at the trust boundary per the documented contract: reject malformed input with a documented error; do not silently coerce or default undocumented values. Done when: malformed input is rejected with a documented error.
- Migrate every consumer to the new contract. Update each consumer so it compiles or type-checks against the new signature; record a consumer as migrated only after it is updated. Done when: every consumer is updated and recorded as migrated.
- Remove the legacy path: delete the old signature, alias, re-export, and deprecated entry point. No compatibility shim, alias, or fallback remains. Done when: a search for the old signature returns no live reference.
Failure and recovery
- Unmigrated consumer: if a consumer cannot be inspected or updated, stop. Record it as a blocking risk; the change is not complete and the done predicate does not hold.
- Ambiguous semantics: if a field's semantics cannot be stated concretely, stop and request the missing specification rather than guessing or leaving it implicit.
- Partial-result rule: a partially migrated change is not shippable. Keep the draft uncommitted and report the remaining consumers and unresolved semantics.
- Rollback: discard the uncommitted draft. Consumer edits and legacy-path restores are part of the same draft, so reverting via VCS restores them. No source rollback is required beyond VCS.
- Blocked result: return the unmigrated-consumer list and the unresolved-semantics list. Do not pretend the done predicate holds.
Output
A contract document stating semantics and errors for every operation, field, and flag. The migrated-consumer list. Confirmation that a search for the old signature returns no live reference. For a blocked run, the unmigrated-consumer list and the unresolved-semantics list instead of a done confirmation.
1---2name: api-and-interface-design3description: Use when asked to design or change a public API, route, CLI flag, or module boundary. Not for remote, credential, publish, deploy, or irreversible changes.4---56# API and interface design78## Contract910| Field | Bound contract |11|---|---|12| Trigger | Designing or changing a public API, route, CLI flag, or module boundary. |13| Authority | Reversible local: writes only named local interface definitions and contract docs, edits consumer files onto the new contract, and deletes legacy paths (old signatures, aliases, re-exports, deprecated entry points) during cutover; rollback is undo (discard the uncommitted draft) or version control. No remote mutation. No credential, paid, published, or deployed change, and no VCS history rewrite. |14| Side effect | Interface definitions and contract docs written before implementation; consumer files edited onto the new contract and legacy paths (old signatures, aliases, re-exports, deprecated entry points) deleted during cutover; no build, publish, or remote mutation. |15| Done | Contract is documented with semantics and errors, every consumer is migrated, and no legacy path remains. |1617## Inputs1819The interface being designed or changed: its name and kind (API endpoint, route, CLI flag, or module boundary), and whether it is new or a change to an existing interface. The current contract text, when changing an existing interface. The list of known consumers, found by search over the codebase. Optional: target language or runtime conventions for type and error spelling.2021## Procedure22231. Bound scope before any mutation: name the exact interface and whether it is new or a change. Search the codebase for every consumer and record the list; record any consumer that cannot be inspected as an unmigrated risk. Done when: every consumer is listed and uninspectable ones are marked as risks.242. Write the contract before implementation. For each operation, field, or flag, document its name, input types, output type, error cases, and side effects. State semantics explicitly: idempotent or not, ordering, nullability, encoding, and concurrency. Done when: every operation, field, and flag has documented semantics and errors.253. For a change to an existing interface, classify it as breaking or non-breaking. If breaking, design the cutover in one change: the new contract, the per-consumer migration, and the removal of the legacy path. Done when: the cutover is designed as one change.264. Validate inputs at the trust boundary per the documented contract: reject malformed input with a documented error; do not silently coerce or default undocumented values. Done when: malformed input is rejected with a documented error.275. Migrate every consumer to the new contract. Update each consumer so it compiles or type-checks against the new signature; record a consumer as migrated only after it is updated. Done when: every consumer is updated and recorded as migrated.286. Remove the legacy path: delete the old signature, alias, re-export, and deprecated entry point. No compatibility shim, alias, or fallback remains. Done when: a search for the old signature returns no live reference.2930## Failure and recovery31- Unmigrated consumer: if a consumer cannot be inspected or updated, stop. Record it as a blocking risk; the change is not complete and the done predicate does not hold.32- Ambiguous semantics: if a field's semantics cannot be stated concretely, stop and request the missing specification rather than guessing or leaving it implicit.33- Partial-result rule: a partially migrated change is not shippable. Keep the draft uncommitted and report the remaining consumers and unresolved semantics.34- Rollback: discard the uncommitted draft. Consumer edits and legacy-path restores are part of the same draft, so reverting via VCS restores them. No source rollback is required beyond VCS.35- Blocked result: return the unmigrated-consumer list and the unresolved-semantics list. Do not pretend the done predicate holds.3637## Output38A contract document stating semantics and errors for every operation, field, and flag. The migrated-consumer list. Confirmation that a search for the old signature returns no live reference. For a blocked run, the unmigrated-consumer list and the unresolved-semantics list instead of a done confirmation.
OutlineDriven