Code Polish

Code Polish

Resolve scope once, make only high-confidence simplifications, fix evidenced defects by risk, and verify the final state.

Modes

• --simplify: simplify only.
• --review: review and fix only.
• Neither or both: simplify, then review the simplified result.
• --with-profile <name> / --skip-profile <name>: add or suppress review profiles; skip wins.

Fixed Scope

1. Require a Git repository.
2. Use explicit paths, patterns, ranges, natural-language targets, or a supplied resolved-scope block when present. Otherwise use only files modified in this session; if session history is unavailable, use all uncommitted tracked and untracked files.
3. Exclude lockfiles, generated outputs, vendored code, minified bundles, and large data snapshots from manual review unless explicitly requested. Validate relevant excluded outputs through their generator, schema, or invariants.
4. Resolve and retain one authoritative scope set and optional exclusions for execution. Do not broaden or recompute scope later. Stop if it is empty.

Simplify

Preserve public contracts, inputs, outputs, side effects, error behavior, performance-sensitive characteristics, telemetry, and operational guards. Apply only changes with a concrete comprehension or defect-risk benefit:

• flatten avoidable control-flow nesting;
• clarify misleading names or dense transforms;
• remove real duplication when the abstraction reduces total complexity;
• tighten local types and contracts without broad churn;
• remove only dead code caused by this session's edits.

Do not split by line count, perform architecture cleanup, convert sync/async APIs, add speculative configurability, or replace readable duplication with a one-use abstraction. A no-op is a valid result.

Review and Fix

Judge the diff against the user's request. Prioritize CRITICAL → HIGH → MEDIUM → LOW:

• CRITICAL: exploitable security, data loss, or critical outage path.
• HIGH: behavior, error-path, boundary, or performance defect affecting core behavior.
• MEDIUM: resource leak, complexity hotspot, test gap, over-scoped change, speculative complexity, or weak success criterion likely to cause defects.
• LOW: localized clarity or style issue with a real maintenance cost.

Every finding must cite a verified location, triggering input/state, failure mode, blast radius, and evidence in the changed code. Merge duplicates and apply the smallest defensible fix. When intent is ambiguous, stop or record the assumption instead of guessing.

Select every applicable profile and read it once:

Profiles live at references/profiles/<name>.md. Missing selected profiles are a stop condition.

Verification and Report

Run the narrowest formatter/lint, targeted tests, typecheck, and invariant checks that prove the final touched behavior. Broaden only for shared contracts. Name skipped checks and why.

Report Scope, Simplifications when run, Review Findings and Fixes when run, Verification, and Residual Risks. Summarize scope with the file count and smallest useful repository-relative roots, globs, ranges, or user-supplied targets. Do not enumerate every file merely to prove scope; name individual paths only for a small explicit scope or to clarify exceptions and findings. Findings include severity, location, impact, evidence, fix, and confidence. A residual risk states the assumption, consequence if wrong, and how to check it. Completion requires fixed scope, traceable edits/findings, and validation evidence.

Render a successful report as ### ✨ Code polish — ✅ complete, a small summary-count table, a compact Scope summary, ### ✨ Simplifications, ### 🔎 Review findings and fixes, ### 🧪 Verification, and ### ⚠️ Residual risks, omitting inapplicable sections. When review is clean, state ✅ No verified review findings. If a stop condition below prevents completion, lead with ### ✨ Code polish — ⛔ blocked and report the evidence and required decision. Keep severity tokens, profile IDs, commands, locations, reproduction inputs, and security evidence exact and undecorated.

Stop when behavior parity or required high-risk validation cannot be established, or a fix requires an unrequested public-contract change or larger redesign.