Derive Theoretical Result
Rigorous step-by-step derivation from axioms/first principles/theorems. Every step justified. Limiting cases checked. Final result + notation glossary.
Use When
- Formula/theorem from first principles (e.g., Euler-Lagrange from action)
- Math proof by logic from axioms
- Re-derive textbook → verify/adapt
- Extend known → more general (flat → curved spacetime)
- Self-contained → paper/thesis/report
In
- Required: Target result (equation, inequality, theorem, relation)
- Required: Starting point (axioms, postulates, prior results, Lagrangian/Hamiltonian)
- Optional: Proof technique (direct, contradiction, induction, variational, constructive)
- Optional: Notation conventions
- Optional: Known intermediate results citable w/o re-deriving
Do
Step 1: State assumptions + target
Contract before calc:
- Axioms + postulates: Every assumption listed. Physics: symmetry group, action principle, QM postulates. Math: axiom sys + prior lemmas.
- Target: Precise notation. Equation → both sides. Inequality → direction + equality conds.
- Scope: Domain of validity (e.g., "non-relativistic, spinless, 3D"). State what not covered.
- Notation: Define every symbol. Self-contained.
## Derivation Contract
- **Starting from**: [axioms, postulates, or established results]
- **Target**: [precise mathematical statement]
- **Domain of validity**: [restrictions and assumptions]
- **Notation**:
- [symbol]: [meaning and units]
- ...
→ Complete unambiguous statement. Notation up front.
If err: Target ambiguous/assumptions incomplete → clarify before proceed. Hidden assumptions → unreliable.
Step 2: Math toolkit
Tools + applicability:
- Algebra: Tensor, commutator, matrix, series. Verify prereqs (convergence, invertibility).
- Calc/analysis: ODE/PDE, integration + domain, functional derivs, contour, distributions. Verify regularity (differentiability, integrability, analyticity).
- Symmetry/group theory: Irreps, Clebsch-Gordan, character orthogonality, Wigner-Eckart.
- Topology/geometry (if applicable): Manifolds, bundles, connections + topo constraints (boundary terms, winding, index).
- Identities/lemmas: Specific ones invoked (Jacobi, Bianchi, integration by parts, Stokes). State explicitly, cite by name.
## Mathematical Toolkit
- **Algebra**: [techniques and prerequisites]
- **Analysis**: [calculus tools and regularity conditions]
- **Symmetry**: [group theory tools]
- **Identities to invoke**: [list with precise statements]
→ Checklist w/ applicability verified.
If err: Unverified prereqs (e.g., term-by-term diff w/o uniform convergence) → flag gap. Prove or state as additional assumption.
Step 3: Execute w/ justification
Every step labeled + justified:
- One op per step: No combining.
- Justification labels:
[by assumption] — stated axiom/assumption
[by definition] — prior definition
[by {identity name}] — named identity (e.g., "by Jacobi identity")
[by Step N] — prior step
[by {theorem name}] — external theorem (Step 2)
- Checkpoints (every 5-10 steps):
- Units/dimensions consistent
- Symmetries preserved
- Correct transformation props
- Branches: Case analysis → each branch labeled sub-derivation, merge.
## Derivation
**Step 1.** [Starting expression]
*Justification*: [by assumption / definition]
**Step 2.** [Result of operation on Step 1]
*Justification*: [specific reason]
...
**Checkpoint (after Step N).** Verify:
- Dimensions: [check]
- Symmetry: [check]
...
**Step M.** [Final expression = Target result]
*Justification*: [final operation] QED
→ Linear sequence, no logic gaps. Every step verifiable.
If err: Step doesn't follow → gap. Insert intermediates or identify new assumption. No "it can be shown" unless well-known identity listed Step 2.
Step 4: Limiting cases + special values
Validate vs known:
Limits (≥3): Simpler prior formula (non-rel limit), trivial case (coupling=0), extreme regime (high/low T).
Special values: Known independent (n=1 hydrogen, d=3).
Symmetry: Correct under group. Scalar → invariant. Vector → transforms right.
Consistency: Ward identities, sum rules, reciprocity.
## Limiting Case Verification
| Case | Condition | Expected Result | Derived Result | Match |
|------|-----------|----------------|----------------|-------|
| [name] | [parameter limit] | [known result] | [substitution] | [Yes/No] |
| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |
→ All limits + special values match. Internally consistent.
If err: Failed limit → err in derivation. Trace to first step producing fail. Common: sign, missing 2/π, wrong combinatorial coeff, wrong order of limits.
Step 5: Final w/ notation glossary
Polished:
- Narrative: Intro para → motivation, approach, main result.
- Body: Steps from Step 3 cleaned. Group → logical blocks w/ headings.
- Result box: Highlighted, separated.
- Glossary: Every symbol + meaning + units + first occurrence.
- Assumptions summary: All in one place, postulates vs technical (smoothness, convergence).
## Final Result
> **Theorem/Result**: [precise statement with equation number]
## Notation Glossary
| Symbol | Meaning | Units | First appears |
|--------|---------|-------|---------------|
| [sym] | [meaning] | [units or dimensionless] | [Step N] |
| ... | ... | ... | ... |
## Assumptions
1. [Fundamental postulate 1]
2. [Technical assumption 1]
3. ...
→ Self-contained doc, followable start to finish w/o external refs (except cited identities + theorems).
If err: Too long (>~50 steps) → break into lemmas. Derive each, assemble main result citing lemmas.
Check
Traps
- Hidden assumptions: Analyticity, convergence, integral existence w/o stating. Every regularity cond = assumption, declare.
- Sign errs: Most common mech err. Track at every step. Cross-check dim analysis (sign err → dim inconsistent).
- Dropped boundary terms: Integration by parts / Stokes → boundary terms vanish only under conds. State why (e.g., "field decays > 1/r at infinity").
- Order of limits: Wrong order → diff results (thermodynamic before zero-T). State order explicit + justify.
- Circular reasoning: Using result as intermediate. Subtle for "obvious" formulas. Every step from stated start, not answer familiarity.
- Notation collisions: Same symbol for diff quantities (E = energy + E-field). Glossary prevents — IF written before derivation.
→
formulate-quantum-problem — formulate QM framework before deriving
survey-theoretical-literature — find prior derivations for comparison
1---2name: derive-theoretical-result-103description: Derive a theoretical result step-by-step from first principles or established theorems, with every step explicitly justified and special cases checked. Use when deriving a formula or theorem from first principles, proving a mathematical statement by logical deduction, re-deriving a textbook result for verification or adaptation, extending a known result to a more general setting, or producing a self-contained derivation for a paper or thesis.4license: MIT5---67# Derive Theoretical Result89Rigorous step-by-step derivation from axioms/first principles/theorems. Every step justified. Limiting cases checked. Final result + notation glossary.1011## Use When1213- Formula/theorem from first principles (e.g., Euler-Lagrange from action)14- Math proof by logic from axioms15- Re-derive textbook → verify/adapt16- Extend known → more general (flat → curved spacetime)17- Self-contained → paper/thesis/report1819## In2021- **Required**: Target result (equation, inequality, theorem, relation)22- **Required**: Starting point (axioms, postulates, prior results, Lagrangian/Hamiltonian)23- **Optional**: Proof technique (direct, contradiction, induction, variational, constructive)24- **Optional**: Notation conventions25- **Optional**: Known intermediate results citable w/o re-deriving2627## Do2829### Step 1: State assumptions + target3031Contract before calc:32331. **Axioms + postulates**: Every assumption listed. Physics: symmetry group, action principle, QM postulates. Math: axiom sys + prior lemmas.342. **Target**: Precise notation. Equation → both sides. Inequality → direction + equality conds.353. **Scope**: Domain of validity (e.g., "non-relativistic, spinless, 3D"). State what not covered.364. **Notation**: Define every symbol. Self-contained.3738```markdown39## Derivation Contract40- **Starting from**: [axioms, postulates, or established results]41- **Target**: [precise mathematical statement]42- **Domain of validity**: [restrictions and assumptions]43- **Notation**:44 - [symbol]: [meaning and units]45 - ...46```4748→ Complete unambiguous statement. Notation up front.4950If err: Target ambiguous/assumptions incomplete → clarify before proceed. Hidden assumptions → unreliable.5152### Step 2: Math toolkit5354Tools + applicability:55561. **Algebra**: Tensor, commutator, matrix, series. Verify prereqs (convergence, invertibility).572. **Calc/analysis**: ODE/PDE, integration + domain, functional derivs, contour, distributions. Verify regularity (differentiability, integrability, analyticity).583. **Symmetry/group theory**: Irreps, Clebsch-Gordan, character orthogonality, Wigner-Eckart.594. **Topology/geometry** (if applicable): Manifolds, bundles, connections + topo constraints (boundary terms, winding, index).605. **Identities/lemmas**: Specific ones invoked (Jacobi, Bianchi, integration by parts, Stokes). State explicitly, cite by name.6162```markdown63## Mathematical Toolkit64- **Algebra**: [techniques and prerequisites]65- **Analysis**: [calculus tools and regularity conditions]66- **Symmetry**: [group theory tools]67- **Identities to invoke**: [list with precise statements]68```6970→ Checklist w/ applicability verified.7172If err: Unverified prereqs (e.g., term-by-term diff w/o uniform convergence) → flag gap. Prove or state as additional assumption.7374### Step 3: Execute w/ justification7576Every step labeled + justified:77781. **One op per step**: No combining.792. **Justification labels**:80 - `[by assumption]` — stated axiom/assumption81 - `[by definition]` — prior definition82 - `[by {identity name}]` — named identity (e.g., "by Jacobi identity")83 - `[by Step N]` — prior step84 - `[by {theorem name}]` — external theorem (Step 2)853. **Checkpoints** (every 5-10 steps):86 - Units/dimensions consistent87 - Symmetries preserved88 - Correct transformation props894. **Branches**: Case analysis → each branch labeled sub-derivation, merge.9091```markdown92## Derivation9394**Step 1.** [Starting expression]95*Justification*: [by assumption / definition]9697**Step 2.** [Result of operation on Step 1]98*Justification*: [specific reason]99100...101102**Checkpoint (after Step N).** Verify:103- Dimensions: [check]104- Symmetry: [check]105106...107108**Step M.** [Final expression = Target result]109*Justification*: [final operation] QED110```111112→ Linear sequence, no logic gaps. Every step verifiable.113114If err: Step doesn't follow → gap. Insert intermediates or identify new assumption. No "it can be shown" unless well-known identity listed Step 2.115116### Step 4: Limiting cases + special values117118Validate vs known:1191201. **Limits** (≥3): Simpler prior formula (non-rel limit), trivial case (coupling=0), extreme regime (high/low T).1211222. **Special values**: Known independent (n=1 hydrogen, d=3).1231243. **Symmetry**: Correct under group. Scalar → invariant. Vector → transforms right.1251264. **Consistency**: Ward identities, sum rules, reciprocity.127128```markdown129## Limiting Case Verification130| Case | Condition | Expected Result | Derived Result | Match |131|------|-----------|----------------|----------------|-------|132| [name] | [parameter limit] | [known result] | [substitution] | [Yes/No] |133| ... | ... | ... | ... | ... |134```135136→ All limits + special values match. Internally consistent.137138If err: Failed limit → err in derivation. Trace to first step producing fail. Common: sign, missing 2/π, wrong combinatorial coeff, wrong order of limits.139140### Step 5: Final w/ notation glossary141142Polished:1431441. **Narrative**: Intro para → motivation, approach, main result.1452. **Body**: Steps from Step 3 cleaned. Group → logical blocks w/ headings.1463. **Result box**: Highlighted, separated.1474. **Glossary**: Every symbol + meaning + units + first occurrence.1485. **Assumptions summary**: All in one place, postulates vs technical (smoothness, convergence).149150```markdown151## Final Result152153> **Theorem/Result**: [precise statement with equation number]154155## Notation Glossary156| Symbol | Meaning | Units | First appears |157|--------|---------|-------|---------------|158| [sym] | [meaning] | [units or dimensionless] | [Step N] |159| ... | ... | ... | ... |160161## Assumptions1621. [Fundamental postulate 1]1632. [Technical assumption 1]1643. ...165```166167→ Self-contained doc, followable start to finish w/o external refs (except cited identities + theorems).168169If err: Too long (>~50 steps) → break into lemmas. Derive each, assemble main result citing lemmas.170171## Check172173- [ ] All starting assumptions stated before first calc174- [ ] Every step labeled justification (no unjustified leaps)175- [ ] Units/dimensions consistent at every checkpoint176- [ ] ≥3 limiting cases checked + match177- [ ] Special values match known178- [ ] Result transforms correctly under stated symmetry179- [ ] Glossary defines every symbol180- [ ] No deferred "it can be shown"181- [ ] Domain of validity stated w/ result182183## Traps184185- **Hidden assumptions**: Analyticity, convergence, integral existence w/o stating. Every regularity cond = assumption, declare.186- **Sign errs**: Most common mech err. Track at every step. Cross-check dim analysis (sign err → dim inconsistent).187- **Dropped boundary terms**: Integration by parts / Stokes → boundary terms vanish only under conds. State why (e.g., "field decays > 1/r at infinity").188- **Order of limits**: Wrong order → diff results (thermodynamic before zero-T). State order explicit + justify.189- **Circular reasoning**: Using result as intermediate. Subtle for "obvious" formulas. Every step from stated start, not answer familiarity.190- **Notation collisions**: Same symbol for diff quantities (E = energy + E-field). Glossary prevents — IF written before derivation.191192## →193194- `formulate-quantum-problem` — formulate QM framework before deriving195- `survey-theoretical-literature` — find prior derivations for comparison