Github Address Comments

Github Address Comments

Overview

Use this skill to turn review comments into prioritized, verified fixes and explicit thread closure evidence.

Scope Boundaries

• Use this skill when the task matches the trigger condition described in description.
• Do not use this skill when the primary task falls outside this skill's domain.

Templates And Assets

• Comment resolution log:
  • assets/comment-resolution-log-template.md

Shared References

• Reviewer reply patterns:
  • references/reply-templates.md

Inputs To Gather

• Target PR information.
• Open review comments and thread status.
• Repository validation requirements.
• Scope agreement for this response pass.

Deliverables

• Prioritized comment-action mapping.
• Code changes scoped to accepted comment threads.
• Thread-by-thread responses with verification evidence.
• Deferred-item log for out-of-scope threads.

Workflow

1. Confirm gh authentication and identify active PR.
2. Fetch comments using scripts/fetch_review_threads.py.
3. Prioritize threads by severity/risk/dependency and log in assets/comment-resolution-log-template.md.
4. Implement focused fixes and run relevant validation.
5. Reply with concrete change references using references/reply-templates.md.

Scripts

• Fetch review threads:
  • python3 scripts/fetch_review_threads.py --repo . --pr <number>
• JSON output for tooling:
  • python3 scripts/fetch_review_threads.py --repo . --pr <number> --json

Quality Standard

• Every addressed comment maps to code changes or explicit rationale.
• High-severity comments are handled before cosmetic threads.
• Behavior-affecting fixes include verification evidence.
• Responses are specific enough for quick reviewer validation.

Failure Conditions

• Stop when comment intent or scope is ambiguous.
• Stop when requested change conflicts with approved product/architecture decisions.
• Escalate when required context is missing from reviewer discussion.