Author E2e Tests

Positron Playwright E2E Testing

Purpose

Provides specialized knowledge and patterns for writing correct, reliable Playwright e2e tests that follow Positron's established conventions and avoid common mistakes.

Philosophy: What Makes a Good E2E Test

Prefer the smallest test that confidently protects the intended user-visible behavior. Do not add additional scenarios or assertions simply because they are easy to write -- extra setup, incidental checks, and duplicate assertions add maintenance cost and flake surface without adding confidence.

A good e2e test:

• validates observable user behavior, not implementation details
• exercises a complete workflow, not a fragment of one
• minimizes setup to what the regression actually needs
• remains deterministic -- no reliance on fixed waits, execution order, or leftover state
• isolates the single regression it protects, so a failure points at one cause

When to Use This Skill

Load this skill when:

• Creating new e2e test files
• Adding test cases to existing test files
• Debugging flaky or failing tests
• Understanding the test fixture system
• Working with page objects
• Choosing correct selectors and assertions

Start Here: Read a Neighbor Test

Before writing anything, open an existing test in test/e2e/tests/<feature>/ for the area you're working on and skim it. The reference docs below tell you how to verify a method and why a pattern exists; the existing tests show you what a correct test actually looks like, including the flake-avoiding details that live in no doc, such as which panes overlap the view under test, how cell/output values render (numeric grid cells come back as strings, for instance), and which tags a suite in that area carries. Copy the closest neighbor's structure, then adjust it. Use the reference docs to confirm each method name against source and to understand the gotchas.

Critical: Test File Structure

Every test file MUST follow this structure:

import { test, expect, tags } from '../_test.setup';

// REQUIRED: Each test file needs a unique suiteId
test.use({
	suiteId: __filename
});

test.describe('Feature Name', {
	tag: [tags.WEB, tags.WIN, tags.CRITICAL, tags.FEATURE_TAG]
}, () => {

	test.beforeEach(async ({ app }) => {
		// Optional setup for each test
	});

	test.afterEach(async ({ app, hotKeys }) => {
		// Cleanup after each test
		await hotKeys.closeAllEditors();
	});

	test('Test description', async ({ app, python }) => {
		// Test implementation
	});
});

MANDATORY REQUIREMENTS:

1. Import from ../_test.setup - NOT from @playwright/test. Import only what the file uses: test and tags always, expect only if you write raw assertions (a file whose assertions all go through POM methods doesn't import expect, and an unused import fails lint).
2. Set suiteId: __filename - Required for app isolation
3. Add appropriate tags for platform filtering

Quick Reference: Available Fixtures

See references/fixtures.md for complete fixture documentation.

Page Objects

UI interactions go through app.workbench.* page objects, not raw locators. Before writing any interaction: check for an existing method, then consider adding a reusable one, and only fall back to a raw locator when neither fits -- see references/common-mistakes.md #15 for the full workflow, and references/page-objects.md for usage idioms and "Finding the Exact Source" for looking up the exact signature in test/e2e/pages/*.ts. Never guess or paraphrase a method name -- copy it from the source file.

Assertions

Standard Playwright web-first assertions apply, with the project's 15s default timeout covering most checks -- don't add { timeout } reflexively. See references/assertions.md for choosing between toPass, expect.poll, and plain web-first assertions, selector priority, and what makes an assertion worth adding versus redundant.

Test Tags

Tag every test.describe via the tag array. Available tags are the FeatureTags (what the test covers) and PlatformTags (where it runs) enums in test/e2e/infra/test-runner/test-tags.ts. A test with no platform tag runs only on Linux/Electron; add tags.WEB / tags.WIN to broaden. See references/test-structure.md for the full tagging and annotation model.

Performance / Metric Tests

Performance/metric tests live in a performance/ subdirectory under their feature directory (e.g. tests/data-explorer/performance/, tests/console/performance/). They use metric.* timing wrappers (e.g. metric.console.executeCode, metric.dataExplorer.loadData) and must capture only the user-observable action, not test scaffolding.

Recipe: All setup (focus, staging code, pre-checks) happens before the timer. Inside the timer: only the bare trigger (e.g. page.keyboard.press('Enter')) and the wait for completion.

Why not use POM submit methods inside the timer? Many POM methods hide fixed delays. For example, sendEnterKey() contains a waitForTimeout(500) and a focus() call, so wrapping it inside a metric inflates every measurement by ~600ms of synthetic noise. Before using any POM method inside a timer, check its source for waitForTimeout, artificial focus calls, or retry loops. For the trigger keypress, prefer page.keyboard.press() directly.

All performance/metric tests must include tags.PERFORMANCE in their tag list.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Critical (will break tests):

1. Wrong imports - use ../_test.setup, not @playwright/test
2. Missing suiteId - must have test.use({ suiteId: __filename })
3. Missing platform tags - add tags.WEB, tags.WIN for cross-platform

Quality issues: 4. Timeout overrides added reflexively - the 15s default covers most UI checks; only override for a known-slow (or known-fast) operation 5. No test.step() - wrap complex multi-action sequences for better reports 6. Fixed waits - page.waitForTimeout(...) instead of a web-first assertion, expect.poll, toPass, or a POM wait helper

See references/common-mistakes.md for detailed gotchas with code examples.

Running Tests

# Run specific test file
npx playwright test <test-name>.test.ts --project e2e-electron

# Run all tests in a category
npx playwright test test/e2e/tests/<category>/

# Run with specific tags
npx playwright test --grep @:critical

# Run in headed mode (see browser)
npx playwright test --headed

# Run with debug mode
npx playwright test --debug

# Show test report
npx playwright show-report

Progressive Documentation

For detailed information, read the bundled reference docs:

• references/test-setup.md - How to configure the local machine environment to run tests
• references/test-structure.md - Complete test file structure and organization
• references/fixtures.md - All available fixtures and their usage
• references/page-objects.md - Page object usage idioms (curated, not exhaustive)
• references/assertions.md - Retry-mechanism choice and selector priority (Positron-specific; standard Playwright assertions assumed)
• references/common-mistakes.md - Positron-specific gotchas to avoid

Key Architecture Principles

1. Worker-scoped app - One app instance per test file (suite)
2. Test-scoped fixtures - page, sessions, etc. fresh per test
3. Page Object Model - UI interactions wrapped in POMs via app.workbench.*
4. Tag-based filtering - Tests tagged for platform and feature filtering
5. Automatic cleanup - Tracing, screenshots attached on failure

Getting Help

1. Look at existing tests in test/e2e/tests/<feature>/ for patterns
2. Check page object source in test/e2e/pages/ for available methods
3. Read test/e2e/tests/_test.setup.ts for fixture definitions
4. Use --debug flag to step through tests interactively
5. For a flaky/failing test that already has CI history, query test-health directly for a quick read on known failure patterns -- see ../e2e-failure-analyzer/scripts/README.md for the test-key format and how to call e2e-query-history.js. For a full guided root-cause dig through the evidence, hand off to debug-e2e-test.