pproenca Decide a gate
A gate is the point where a human decides whether the pipeline has understood the work. Only the main session, acting on an explicit human answer, records a decision. A subagent never approves its own artifact, and neither does an agent acting on the human's behalf without asking.
Procedure
1. Find the gate
With a story id, read its state.json and take the pending gate. Without one,
list every story with a pending gate and ask which. If nothing is pending, say so
and report the board instead.
2. Present the artifact
Read the artifact the gate owns — plan.md, the .feature file, or
qa-procedure.md with implementer-notes.md. Present it for a decision:
- What it commits the story to, in a few lines.
- The specific things worth checking for that gate:
- plan — is the story buildable alone? Are the ports and dummy state named? Is the acceptance observable? Are the other backlog items listed as non-goals?
- gherkin — do the scenarios describe behaviour rather than implementation? Is every scenario checkable by the project's tests? Is anything in scope missing?
- qa_procedure — can a human follow it without reading the code? Do the implementer notes name the seams, the runnable entry point, and the flags?
- Anything that looks wrong, stated plainly.
Then ask for the decision. Do not assume approval from silence or from a vague affirmative about something else.
3. Record it
Write .squad/approvals/<story-id>-<gate>.json per
../squad-pipeline/references/state.md, and set the gate in state.json to
approved or rejected.
On rejection, also write .squad/blockers/<story-id>-<nn>.md with the reason, and
set blocked. A rejected gate does not advance: the owning stage runs again with
the reason as input, or the story goes back to the backlog to be re-sliced.
4. Continue
After an approval, offer to continue with /swarmforge:squad-start. After a
rejection, offer to re-run the stage that produced the artifact, with the rejection
note included in its packet.
Gates that are off
When config.json.gates has a gate false, squad-start records an auto
decision and never pauses. Do not record an auto decision here — this skill only
runs when a human is deciding.