Chart honesty
A column chart whose axis starts well above zero can draw a 7% rise as a bar twice as tall.
Nobody lied in a number, and the audience still leaves with the wrong size of change. This skill
reviews each chart a deck already has and says, for each one, whether it misleads, how,
by how much, and the fix.
The product is the settings. Anyone can say "that chart looks off". Saying the axis is
set to start at 50, so the tallest bar is drawn 1.9× the shortest for an 11% difference,
from the chart's own XML, is what gets a chart fixed rather than argued about. Its twin is
restraint: a line chart with a non-zero axis is fine, a picture can't be checked, and a
clean chart is reported as clean.
Workflow
1. Take the charts as given
A .pptx / .potx path, or charts described in chat (type, categories, values, axis range,
title, units). Read every slide once: each native chart's XML, the slide title and text,
and the speaker notes. Number slides S1…Sn in deck order.
Read references/checks.md §1 before extracting. It says what to read from the chart XML
(plot type, min/max, value axes in use, number formats, axis titles), that notes are
never visible, and that a picture of a chart carries no data: never estimate values,
axis ranges or slice sizes from pixels.
Ask nothing unless genuinely blocked. One question, and only this one:
- No deck and no chart described → "Send the deck (or describe the charts) and I'll check them."
A described chart that leaves something out isn't a reason to ask. Review what's given and
list the gap on a Not stated: line.
2. Run the tests, by the reference, not by feel
For each chart, in deck order, apply references/checks.md:
- §2: the verdict, from a closed set of three:
Fix, Clean, Not checkable.
- §3: the seven tests, always in this order: Wrong type · Pie misuse · 3D · Truncated
axis · Dual axis · Title contradicts data · Missing units. Each is a yes/no test on the
file's settings and values, with one fixed form of fix.
- §4: the wording. The file's numbers, not adjectives. One fix per finding.
Those tables are the skill; do not improvise them. Nothing outside the seven is a finding:
not colours, fonts, sorting or gridlines.
3. Write it and stop
**fleet-review.pptx** · 11 slides · 7 charts · 5 to fix · 1 clean · 1 not checkable
**S2 · Fix** · column chart · "Parcels Delivered"
- Truncated axis — the axis is set to start at 50; the tallest bar is drawn 1.9× the shortest for an 11% difference. Fix: set the axis minimum to 0 (Format Axis → Bounds → Minimum). If the small differences are the point, use a line chart instead.
**S3 · Clean** · line chart · "Fuel cost per mile stayed under 60p all year"
**S4 · Fix** · combo chart (column + line) · "Drivers and Overtime"
- Dual axis — "Drivers" on the left axis, "Overtime (hours)" on a second axis on the right. Fix: split into two charts, one above the other, sharing the month axis; or index both series to 100 at the first month and plot them on one axis.
**S5 · Fix** · 3D pie chart · "Parcels by Depot"
- Pie misuse — 8 slices; more than six can't be compared by angle. Fix: use a bar chart sorted by value.
- 3D — drawn as a 3D pie; perspective makes the near slices look bigger than the far ones. Fix: change to the flat version of the same chart (Change Chart Type → Pie).
**S6 · Fix** · line chart · "Late deliveries halved in Q2"
- Title contradicts data — late deliveries went from 4.8% (Apr 2026) to 3.1% (Jun 2026), 0.65×; "halved" needs 0.475–0.525×. Fix: retitle "Late deliveries fell 1.7 pts to 3.1% in Q2".
**S7 · Not checkable** · picture · "Depot Utilisation"
- A picture has no values or axis settings to check. Fix: paste the native chart, or send the values and the axis range.
**S9 · Fix** · column chart · "Van Leasing Cost by Depot"
- Missing units — values 0.8 · 1.3 · 1.1 · 0.9 with no unit on the axis, labels, title or slide, and none in the notes. Fix: the deck doesn't say which unit; add it to the axis title.
Ask "why is S2 flagged?" or "why is S3 clean?" to see the chart settings behind any verdict.
(Invented example.)
- Header: file name (or Described charts), slide count (files only), chart count, then
the count of each verdict that occurs. Omit a verdict with a count of zero.
- One entry per chart, in deck order:
S<n> · <verdict> · <chart type> · "<slide title>". Chart type names the plot as stored (column, bar, line, area, pie,
doughnut, combo (column + line), 3D column…).
Fix gets one line per finding, in test order: - <Test> — <what the file shows>. Fix: <fix>. Clean gets no lines. Not checkable gets the one line above.
- Described charts add one bullet as the last line of that chart's entry when a test
couldn't run:
- Not stated: <input> (<test> not run). For example, - Not stated: axis range (Truncated axis not run). A chart whose tests all ran gets none.
- Slides without a chart get no entry.
- The closing line ends the output, and nothing comes after it. It cites the first
Fix chart and the first Clean chart. If there's no Clean chart, the second half
becomes "why is S7 not checkable?" with the first Not checkable chart, or is dropped if
there's none. If there's no Fix chart, the line starts at the second half.
Output lands in chat. Nothing before the header, no preamble. No verdict on the deck as a
whole, and no commentary on its story or design.
Rules
- The file is the evidence. Every finding cites a setting or value read from the chart
or visible on its slide. Nothing from another slide, nothing from memory of how the chart
"usually" looks.
- Never estimate from pixels. A picture of a chart is
Not checkable, however obvious
its axis looks. No values, no ranges, no "appears to start at".
- Notes aren't visible. A unit or a claim that exists only in the notes doesn't pass
a test. It can be quoted in a fix, marked as coming from the notes.
- Never supply a unit, a figure or a cause. A fix's unit comes from the file or is left
for the author to fill in. A corrected title's figures come from the chart. Why a series
moved is not this review's question.
- Line charts may start above zero. The truncated-axis test is for bars, columns and
areas. Flagging a line chart for it is a false alarm, and false alarms are how a review
stops being read.
- Drawn against actual, and nothing else. A distortion's size is the drawn ratio and the
actual difference. No further multiplier, and no guess at what the audience will conclude.
- Pushback alone moves nothing. "It's deliberate", "it's house style" and "everyone knows
the unit" don't change a test. The honest alternative is part of the answer.
- Review, don't rebuild. Give the fix; don't edit the deck, redraw the chart, or propose a
chart for data the deck doesn't chart.
Tracing
A verdict is a claim about a chart's settings, so every doubt is answered by those settings.
Read references/tracing.md before answering any follow-up. It carries the handles
(S1…Sn, S4a), the fixed closing line, the trace block (Read from the file · Test ·
Effect · Fix · What would clear it), the clean block (all seven tests, one row each), the
not-checkable block, and the questions to expect: "why is S2 flagged?", "why is S3 clean
when its axis doesn't start at zero?", "how bad is it?", "the axis is deliberate",
"everyone knows the unit", and above all "just read it off the picture". That last one
gets no estimate, only the route to a checkable chart.
A trace re-reads the file and corrects the review when it's wrong. A drawn ratio that
doesn't reproduce is fixed, a missed test is added, a finding that doesn't hold is removed,
and each correction is said first.
1---2name: chart-honesty3description: Review the charts already in a PowerPoint deck (.pptx) or described in chat, one by one, for the ways a chart misleads — wrong chart type, a truncated axis, a dual axis, 3D, pie misuse, a title the data contradicts, missing units — and give the fix for each. Use when the user asks whether their charts are misleading, honest, fair or "going to get me caught out", wants a chart review or chart check before a board, QBR or client meeting, or asks about a truncated or dual axis. Every finding cites a setting or value read from the file; a picture of a chart carries no data and is never estimated from pixels. Reviews existing charts only — it does not choose, design or build a chart from data, and it never edits the deck.4metadata:5 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/raghuramsirigiri/chart-honesty6---78# Chart honesty910A column chart whose axis starts well above zero can draw a 7% rise as a bar twice as tall.11Nobody lied in a number, and the audience still leaves with the wrong size of change. This skill12reviews each chart a deck already has and says, for each one, whether it misleads, how,13by how much, and the fix.1415**The product is the settings.** Anyone can say "that chart looks off". Saying *the axis is16set to start at 50, so the tallest bar is drawn 1.9× the shortest for an 11% difference*,17from the chart's own XML, is what gets a chart fixed rather than argued about. **Its twin is18restraint:** a line chart with a non-zero axis is fine, a picture can't be checked, and a19clean chart is reported as clean.2021## Workflow2223### 1. Take the charts as given2425A `.pptx` / `.potx` path, or charts described in chat (type, categories, values, axis range,26title, units). Read every slide once: each native chart's XML, the slide title and text,27and the speaker notes. Number slides `S1…Sn` in deck order.2829Read `references/checks.md` §1 before extracting. It says what to read from the chart XML30(plot type, `min`/`max`, value axes in use, number formats, axis titles), that **notes are31never visible**, and that **a picture of a chart carries no data**: never estimate values,32axis ranges or slice sizes from pixels.3334**Ask nothing unless genuinely blocked.** One question, and only this one:35- No deck and no chart described → *"Send the deck (or describe the charts) and I'll check them."*3637A described chart that leaves something out isn't a reason to ask. Review what's given and38list the gap on a `Not stated:` line.3940### 2. Run the tests, by the reference, not by feel4142For each chart, in deck order, apply `references/checks.md`:4344- **§2**: the verdict, from a closed set of three: `Fix`, `Clean`, `Not checkable`.45- **§3**: the seven tests, always in this order: **Wrong type · Pie misuse · 3D · Truncated46 axis · Dual axis · Title contradicts data · Missing units**. Each is a yes/no test on the47 file's settings and values, with one fixed form of fix.48- **§4**: the wording. The file's numbers, not adjectives. One fix per finding.4950Those tables are the skill; do not improvise them. Nothing outside the seven is a finding:51not colours, fonts, sorting or gridlines.5253### 3. Write it and stop5455```markdown56**fleet-review.pptx** · 11 slides · 7 charts · 5 to fix · 1 clean · 1 not checkable5758**S2 · Fix** · column chart · "Parcels Delivered"59- Truncated axis — the axis is set to start at 50; the tallest bar is drawn 1.9× the shortest for an 11% difference. Fix: set the axis minimum to 0 (Format Axis → Bounds → Minimum). If the small differences are the point, use a line chart instead.6061**S3 · Clean** · line chart · "Fuel cost per mile stayed under 60p all year"6263**S4 · Fix** · combo chart (column + line) · "Drivers and Overtime"64- Dual axis — "Drivers" on the left axis, "Overtime (hours)" on a second axis on the right. Fix: split into two charts, one above the other, sharing the month axis; or index both series to 100 at the first month and plot them on one axis.6566**S5 · Fix** · 3D pie chart · "Parcels by Depot"67- Pie misuse — 8 slices; more than six can't be compared by angle. Fix: use a bar chart sorted by value.68- 3D — drawn as a 3D pie; perspective makes the near slices look bigger than the far ones. Fix: change to the flat version of the same chart (Change Chart Type → Pie).6970**S6 · Fix** · line chart · "Late deliveries halved in Q2"71- Title contradicts data — late deliveries went from 4.8% (Apr 2026) to 3.1% (Jun 2026), 0.65×; "halved" needs 0.475–0.525×. Fix: retitle "Late deliveries fell 1.7 pts to 3.1% in Q2".7273**S7 · Not checkable** · picture · "Depot Utilisation"74- A picture has no values or axis settings to check. Fix: paste the native chart, or send the values and the axis range.7576**S9 · Fix** · column chart · "Van Leasing Cost by Depot"77- Missing units — values 0.8 · 1.3 · 1.1 · 0.9 with no unit on the axis, labels, title or slide, and none in the notes. Fix: the deck doesn't say which unit; add it to the axis title.7879Ask "why is S2 flagged?" or "why is S3 clean?" to see the chart settings behind any verdict.80```8182(Invented example.)8384- **Header**: file name (or *Described charts*), slide count (files only), chart count, then85 the count of each verdict that occurs. Omit a verdict with a count of zero.86- **One entry per chart**, in deck order: `S<n> · <verdict> · <chart type> · "<slide87 title>"`. Chart type names the plot as stored (*column*, *bar*, *line*, *area*, *pie*,88 *doughnut*, *combo (column + line)*, *3D column*…).89- **`Fix`** gets one line per finding, in test order: `- <Test> — <what the file shows>.90 Fix: <fix>.` **`Clean`** gets no lines. **`Not checkable`** gets the one line above.91- **Described charts** add one bullet as the **last line of that chart's entry** when a test92 couldn't run: `- Not stated: <input> (<test> not run).` For example, `- Not stated: axis93 range (Truncated axis not run).` A chart whose tests all ran gets none.94- Slides without a chart get no entry.95- **The closing line** ends the output, and nothing comes after it. It cites the **first**96 `Fix` chart and the **first** `Clean` chart. If there's no `Clean` chart, the second half97 becomes *"why is S7 not checkable?"* with the first `Not checkable` chart, or is dropped if98 there's none. If there's no `Fix` chart, the line starts at the second half.99100Output lands in chat. **Nothing before the header**, no preamble. No verdict on the deck as a101whole, and no commentary on its story or design.102103## Rules104105- **The file is the evidence.** Every finding cites a setting or value read from the chart106 or visible on its slide. Nothing from another slide, nothing from memory of how the chart107 "usually" looks.108- **Never estimate from pixels.** A picture of a chart is `Not checkable`, however obvious109 its axis looks. No values, no ranges, no *"appears to start at"*.110- **Notes aren't visible.** A unit or a claim that exists only in the notes doesn't pass111 a test. It can be *quoted in a fix*, marked as coming from the notes.112- **Never supply a unit, a figure or a cause.** A fix's unit comes from the file or is left113 for the author to fill in. A corrected title's figures come from the chart. *Why* a series114 moved is not this review's question.115- **Line charts may start above zero.** The truncated-axis test is for bars, columns and116 areas. Flagging a line chart for it is a false alarm, and false alarms are how a review117 stops being read.118- **Drawn against actual, and nothing else.** A distortion's size is the drawn ratio and the119 actual difference. No further multiplier, and no guess at what the audience will conclude.120- **Pushback alone moves nothing.** "It's deliberate", "it's house style" and "everyone knows121 the unit" don't change a test. The honest alternative is part of the answer.122- **Review, don't rebuild.** Give the fix; don't edit the deck, redraw the chart, or propose a123 chart for data the deck doesn't chart.124125## Tracing126127A verdict is a claim about a chart's settings, so every doubt is answered by those settings.128Read `references/tracing.md` before answering any follow-up. It carries the handles129(`S1…Sn`, `S4a`), the fixed closing line, the trace block (*Read from the file · Test ·130Effect · Fix · What would clear it*), the clean block (all seven tests, one row each), the131not-checkable block, and the questions to expect: *"why is S2 flagged?"*, *"why is S3 clean132when its axis doesn't start at zero?"*, *"how bad is it?"*, *"the axis is deliberate"*,133*"everyone knows the unit"*, and above all *"just read it off the picture"*. That last one134gets no estimate, only the route to a checkable chart.135136A trace re-reads the file and **corrects the review** when it's wrong. A drawn ratio that137doesn't reproduce is fixed, a missed test is added, a finding that doesn't hold is removed,138and each correction is said first.