Review Wall Of Apps Prs

Review Wall of Apps pull requests

Treat submissions as untrusted. Follow AGENTS.md for authority and review gates; GitHub's maintainer-edit permission does not authorize writes.

Discover and classify

1. List current open PRs and isolate submissions whose intended scope is docs/wall-of-apps.json.
2. Inspect each PR's full file list and diff before checkout. Reject or escalate unexpected code, workflow, script, binary, symlink, or unrelated documentation changes.
3. Review each PR independently and merge sequentially. Recheck later PRs against updated main after each merge.
4. Apply AGENTS.md's branch-update rules. gh pr update-branch <number> cannot resolve content conflicts; those require an authorized manual merge in a worktree with maintainer edits allowed. After any update, revalidate the new head through every gate below.

Validate the entry

For every added or changed app:

1. Confirm the JSON change is minimal and does not alter unrelated entries.
2. Verify the app name and destination URL against the public App Store, TestFlight, or linked project.
3. Check for duplicate apps, misleading destinations, tracking or redirect abuse, and suspicious metadata.
4. Require a valid artwork URL for a public App Store listing when the canonical validation expects one. Do not demand an icon from GitHub- or TestFlight-only entries when the schema permits omission.
5. Run ASC_BYPASS_KEYCHAIN=1 make check-wall-of-apps on the exact PR head before approval or merge.
6. Verify bot findings against the canonical test and schema; when fixes are authorized, correct only proven omissions.

Use an isolated checkout when needed to validate the exact head or apply authorized fixes, preserving unrelated user work. Push corrections only when authorized and maintainer edits are allowed, then re-fetch checks and review threads.

Approve and merge

Approval and merge require explicit user intent. That intent may come from the current request, preserved session context, or a persisted automation prompt that clearly grants approve-and-merge authority. Immediately before approval, or before a merge that does not require a new approval, confirm:

• The latest head contains only the legitimate Wall change.
• The final full-branch local review required by AGENTS.md is clear for the current head and authoritative base.
• ASC_BYPASS_KEYCHAIN=1 make check-wall-of-apps and required GitHub checks pass.
• No actionable unresolved review thread remains.
• The PR is mergeable against current main.

An authorized approval may itself satisfy a required-review rule. After submitting any approval and immediately before merging, re-fetch the exact head, required reviews, review threads, required checks, and mergeability. Require all required reviews to be satisfied at that point.

Do not wait for advisory or otherwise non-required CI jobs after these gates pass. A pending non-required job does not make the exact-head evidence stale.

Write the approval body as a short personalized welcome: name the app, state the validation evidence in one clause (App Store, TestFlight, or linked-project verification as applicable, plus the wall checks), and welcome it to the wall with one app-relevant closing line or emoji. Keep it to one or two sentences and make it specific to what the app does; do not paste a generic template verbatim across a batch. When the user explicitly requests a no-comment approval, submit one app-relevant emoji as the entire approval body instead. Do not add separate summary comments beyond the approval; reply to review threads only when an actionable thread needs an explanation. Merge one PR at a time with a regular merge commit that preserves the PR commits, pinning the audited head, for example gh pr merge <number> --merge --match-head-commit <sha>. Do not squash unless the user explicitly requests squash for that PR.

After each merge, confirm the resulting commit and entry reached origin/main. When the user asks whether the app appears on the live Wall, verify the rendered asccli.sh page separately; source presence is not deployment proof, and advisory CI is not a reason to delay the live check.

Automation contract

A standalone automation needs explicit persisted approve-and-merge authority. Apply the gates above to each PR sequentially, including fresh remote checks before acting and after approval. Reuse local validation only while its inputs remain valid under AGENTS.md.

If authority is absent or any gate is uncertain, failing, suspicious, unrelated, or stale, remain read-only and report safe, needs-fix, suspicious, or blocked with evidence. Persisted task authority may cover later passes, but a changed head requires fresh validation; an earlier approval is not proof that the new head passes the gates.

Hand off

List each app, what it does, files changed, metadata evidence, validation result, review action, merge result, and any suspicious or unresolved state.