Least Privilege
Review one skill, actor or grant against a bounded set of exact receipts. The result distinguishes authority recorded in signed receipts from authority not recorded in that selection, and gives the reviewer a clear next action. It never changes a grant.
Native Runx owns receipt lookup, signature verification and authority semantics. This skill binds the review subject, checks the completeness of the supplied proof and organizes the authority evidence. It does not implement a scope parser, wildcard matcher, permission hierarchy or policy engine.
Composes
receipt-query#read
What the evidence can establish
The native field named exercised_scopes currently projects signed scope
references and authority terms. Its source identifies that origin. Those
records are not a per-operation successful-usage trace. Counts in this report
count receipts recording an exact scope, not successful calls.
A scope missing from a finite receipt window may still support infrequent,
reserved, recovery or compliance work. Even a recorded scope is not proved
necessary. repo:write does not imply repo:read, and a wildcard cannot be
replaced by the first matching string. Scope strings remain opaque here.
A workflow root can record no scopes while its verified child tree contains actual operations. Select attributable child receipts when reviewing those operations; root metadata is not an aggregated successful-usage log. Exact retained operation claims may provide further bounded evidence through their native reader, but they still do not prove full coverage, necessity or the semantics of a replacement grant.
The current native evidence is insufficient to prove a minimal replacement grant. The method therefore retains the entire grant, emits no executable attenuation proposal, and requests policy and representative usage review. A trustworthy narrowing proposal requires the authority owner to establish coverage and replacement semantics; do not add that mechanism to this skill.
When to use it
- Review authority before renewal, distribution or an incident follow-up.
- Collect exact receipt references for a scope-by-scope policy decision.
- Identify where actual usage or reserved-purpose evidence is still missing.
Use receipt-audit to assess governance within one run, policy-draft to draft
and lint a policy, and diagnose-skill-run to diagnose an execution failure.
This skill neither grants new authority nor substitutes for those jobs.
Procedure and stops
- Supply the exact subject reference, current grant and exact receipt ids.
subjectmust match each receipt's skill subject, actor reference or grant reference. A friendly label alone cannot establish attribution. - Resolve missing evidence through
receipt-query#readwith native chain verification. Supply an already completedreceipt_evidenceledger packet to bypass that query, or invokefrom-evidenceexplicitly in a workflow. That phase interprets prior reported verification and does not independently recheck signatures; preserve its source receipt alongside the result. Every requested id needs one verified, attributable native detail. Missing, duplicate, unverified or mismatched details stop the comparison. Unrelated receipt rows never contribute authority observations. - Require a checked, intact native chain verdict with no breaks. Supplied replay rows cannot provide this proof even if their fixture labels say verified. Unknown verification remains unknown.
- Compare exact scope strings only. Mark each as
recorded,not_recordedordefer, preserving the receipt references and native source labels. - Retain the grant. With complete proof return
review_required; with incomplete proof returnneeds_more_evidence. Name the missing policy, actual usage and observation-coverage evidence before any narrowing.
A checked chain, a sealed review receipt and an empty set of changes do not prove that a grant is minimal. Do not describe either status as safe to apply.
Inputs and result
subject: exact skill, actor or grant reference being reviewed.granted_scopes: current scope strings, including an empty grant.receipt_ids: exact receipt ids; an empty set stops for evidence.objective: optional review purpose; it does not supply policy authority.receipt_evidence: completedrunx/receipt-query.answer.v1to reuse without another query. The explicitfrom-evidencephase accepts this same packet.receipt_rowsandreceipt_details: supplied projections for replay only.
audit_report returns the status, subject, completeness and chain verdict,
limitations, scope-by-scope recorded authority, retained_grant,
not_recorded_scopes and reviewer_action. attenuation_proposals stays empty
until native evidence can support a replacement. verdict is a short operator
summary. The existing runx/least-privilege.audit.v1 packet is unchanged.
For a verified review of email:send and payment:spend, a receipt recording
only email:send yields recorded and not_recorded, respectively. Both remain
in the grant. The missing payment record is a review question, not permission
to remove payment authority.