Hermes Gateway Troubleshooting

Hermes Gateway Troubleshooting

Use this skill when Hermes behaves differently in Telegram/Discord/Slack/etc. than in the CLI, especially after model/provider changes, OAuth refreshes, /model switches, gateway restarts, or session resumes.

Triggers

• User says a selected model "doesn't work", "switches back", "falls back", or shows wrong runtime metadata.
• Gateway responds from a different model/provider than hermes config says.
• CLI test works, but Telegram/gateway session appears stale.
• Logs mention polling conflicts, stale sessions, stream watchdogs, provider/auth errors, or config migration.
• Session rows in state.db disagree with runtime logs.

Investigation sequence

1. Check current config and auth first.

   • hermes status --all — per-provider auth health report (✗ not logged in, No <provider> credentials stored, or ✓ with key hint)
   • hermes auth list — credential pools per provider; empty arrays mean no stored credentials despite provider being selected
   • hermes config check
   • Inspect ~/.hermes/config.yaml model block: model.default, model.provider, model.base_url, fallback_providers, auxiliary provider settings.

2. When status shows a provider as "not logged in" or the user says "OAuth is shady", dig into credential health.

   • cat ~/.hermes/auth.json via terminal (read_file redacts this file) — check credential_pool[<provider>]: empty array = no stored credentials.
   • Check active_provider field — is it pointing at a provider with empty credentials? This causes silent fallback or auth failure every turn.
   • Look for stale backup files: ls ~/.hermes/auth.json.bak-* — previous broken auth attempts.
   • If switching from a broken OAuth provider to a working API-key provider, follow references/oauth-to-apikey-provider-switch.md.

3. Read gateway and agent logs with timestamps.

   • Gateway ingress and delivery: ~/.hermes/logs/gateway.log
   • Model/runtime/tool calls: ~/.hermes/logs/agent.log
   • Warnings/errors: ~/.hermes/logs/errors.log

4. Differentiate runtime truth from metadata truth.

   • Runtime truth: agent.turn_context, OpenAI client created, and API call #... model=... provider=... in agent.log.
   • Metadata truth: sessions table row (model, billing_provider, billing_base_url, model_config) and ~/.hermes/sessions/sessions.json current session mapping.

5. Reproduce with a minimal CLI call using the same default config.

   • Example: hermes chat -q 'Reply exactly: ok' --toolsets safe -Q
   • For provider-specific checks: add --provider <provider> --model <model>.
   • A CLI success proves auth and provider wiring; a gateway-only failure usually points to session state, stale process config, or messaging/gateway lifecycle.

6. Check the active gateway process.

   • Confirm only one gateway owns the bot token/polling stream.
   • Polling conflicts (terminated by other getUpdates request) mean multiple bot instances or recently-stopped polling sessions. Resolve process/service duplication before diagnosing model behavior.

Model/provider switch checklist

When a model switch seems half-applied:

• Verify config: selected model.default, model.provider, and model.base_url.
• Verify auth: provider credential exists and is healthy.
• Verify runtime logs: actual API calls use the intended provider/model.
• Verify session DB: current gateway session row matches intended provider/model.
• Verify fallback chain: remove or reorder fallbacks if they silently mask provider failures.
• Restart gateway only after config changes that are read at process startup; do not assume a running gateway rereads every setting.
• If a session row is stale but runtime is correct, repair or reset the session so future resume/metadata uses the correct model.

Safe remediation patterns

• Run hermes doctor --fix for config migrations and harmless install/link repairs.
• Prefer /reset or a fresh session when the issue is session-scoped and no durable state must be preserved.
• If preserving the chat matters, update only the current session's row and confirm via read-back. Include model_config with model, provider, base_url, reasoning config, and iteration/token settings when applicable.
• Disable unintended fallbacks only when the desired behavior is strict provider use. Otherwise, document the fallback as intentional.
• After changes, run a minimal model call and verify both runtime output and session metadata.

Pitfalls

• Do not conclude "auth works" from config alone. Make a real minimal call.
• Do not conclude "the model is wrong" from sessions.model alone. Compare with agent.log API-call lines.
• Do not leave a stale fallback provider that points at the previous model if the user explicitly wants to know when the selected provider fails.
• Do not save transient missing-package or local setup errors as durable rules. Capture the remediation pattern, not the one-off failure.
• Avoid dumping huge logs into context. Search for targeted timestamps, model names, provider names, session IDs, and error classes.

Verification

A fix is not done until:

• hermes config check is clean enough for the intended provider.
• hermes auth list shows the selected provider credential.
• A minimal hermes chat -q ... returns the expected text from the selected provider/model.
• The active gateway session row, if relevant, reflects the same provider/model.
• The user-facing summary separates actual runtime behavior from stale metadata or fallback behavior.

References

• references/model-switch-metadata-fallback.md — session-derived pattern for Codex/GPT-5.5 switch issues where runtime was correct but session metadata and fallbacks were stale.
• references/oauth-to-apikey-provider-switch.md — diagnosing and fixing a broken OAuth provider (empty credential pool) by switching to a working API-key provider, with exact commands and auth.json cleanup.===ME:hermes-gateway-troubleshooting