Contradiction search
Deliberately hunt for the case against a claim: limitations, criticism,
failures, and counter-evidence.
When to use
- A claim, tool, or approach looks too good to trust flatly.
- A balanced write-up requires the "what breaks / what people dispute" side.
- Pressure-testing evidence before a verdict in
claim-verification /
fact-checking.
Tools used
find_contradictions — from a claim, optional angles (which kinds of
criticism to hunt), limit_per_query (default 6).
Workflow
- State the claim; list the angles worth attacking (performance, security,
cost, support, validity…).
find_contradictions with those angles.- Weigh hits: real reproducible failures vs. noise/confusion.
- Fold the strongest counter-evidence into the final assessment.
Input schema
{ "claim": "str", "angles": "list[str]", "limit_per_query": "int" }
Output schema
{ "claim": "str", "contradictions": "list[{angle,source,url,quote}]" }
Security
Criticism is evidence to weigh with the same discipline as support. Do not
manufacture doubt — only surface what sources genuinely say.
Related skills
evidence-extraction, claim-verification, fact-checking,
community-research, deep-research
1---2name: contradiction-search3description: Seek criticisms, limits, and failures — hunt angles, dissenting evidence, and conditions under which a claim breaks. Use to stress-test anything being relied on.4---56# Contradiction search78Deliberately hunt for the case against a claim: limitations, criticism,9failures, and counter-evidence.1011## When to use1213- A claim, tool, or approach looks too good to trust flatly.14- A balanced write-up requires the "what breaks / what people dispute" side.15- Pressure-testing evidence before a verdict in `claim-verification` /16 `fact-checking`.1718## Tools used1920- `find_contradictions` — from a `claim`, optional `angles` (which kinds of21 criticism to hunt), `limit_per_query` (default 6).2223## Workflow24251. State the claim; list the angles worth attacking (performance, security,26 cost, support, validity…).272. `find_contradictions` with those angles.283. Weigh hits: real reproducible failures vs. noise/confusion.294. Fold the strongest counter-evidence into the final assessment.3031## Input schema3233```json34{ "claim": "str", "angles": "list[str]", "limit_per_query": "int" }35```3637## Output schema3839```json40{ "claim": "str", "contradictions": "list[{angle,source,url,quote}]" }41```4243## Security4445Criticism is evidence to weigh with the same discipline as support. Do not46manufacture doubt — only surface what sources genuinely say.4748## Related skills4950`evidence-extraction`, `claim-verification`, `fact-checking`,51`community-research`, `deep-research`
SAMRADDHASHRIVASTAVATECH