Messaging — Compliance Checker
When this applies
Every piece of customer-facing copy — written by a human, drafted by an AI, or generated by a contractor or agency — must pass this compliance check before publication. "Customer-facing" includes:
- All digital advertising (search, display, social)
- Website copy (homepage, product pages, landing pages, pricing)
- Email campaigns (waitlist, onboarding, product, retention)
- In-app notifications, tooltips, and system messages
- Press releases and media statements
- Influencer briefs and sponsored content scripts
- Sales decks, product one-pagers, and partnership proposals
- Conference presentations and booth materials
This checker is blocking: any copy that fails a hard-rule check cannot ship until revised and re-reviewed.
Inputs
| Input |
Description |
| Copy text |
The full text, headline, CTA, and any disclaimers of the asset being reviewed |
| Surface / channel |
Which surface the copy will appear on (homepage, Instagram ad, sales deck, press release, etc.) |
| Primary audience |
Consumer (B2C), lawyer (B2B), or mixed |
| New claim flag |
Whether any claim in the copy is being used for the first time (triggers bible signoff requirement) |
Review Methodology — Four-Pass Check
Pass 1 — Hard Rules
Check against [[messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required]] and [[messaging-hard-rule-preapproved-press-quotes-only]].
| Rule |
Check question |
| Bible signoff |
Does the copy contain any claim not previously approved in the messaging bible? If yes → block until signoff obtained |
| Press quotes |
Does the copy contain a quote from a third party (media, client, influencer)? If yes → verify pre-approval on file; if not on file → block |
Pass 2 — Banned Outcome Claims
Check against [[messaging-outcome-claims-banned]].
Scan for any of the following or their semantic equivalents:
- "Will win your case" or any case-outcome guarantee
- "Guaranteed to save money"
- "Replaces your lawyer" (in any form)
- Any specific dollar amount recovered or damages claimed
- Any outcome expressed as a certainty rather than a possibility
Action on fail: Flag exact phrase → require replacement with [[messaging-outcome-claims-allowed]] equivalent.
Pass 3 — Audience-Specific Banned Claims
If consumer audience: Check against [[messaging-banned-claims-consumer]].
If lawyer audience: Check against [[messaging-banned-claims-lawyer]].
If mixed: Apply both.
Scan for:
- UPL-triggering language (consumer surfaces)
- Displacement / commodification framing (lawyer surfaces)
- Consumer framing on professional surfaces
- Professional jargon on consumer surfaces (accessibility failure, not compliance failure)
Action on fail: Flag exact phrase → reference allowed alternative from the corresponding allowed-claims skill.
Pass 4 — Bridge Line Test
Is the overall copy consistent with the bridge line ("legal understanding accessible to everyone; legal work faster for professionals")?
Ask:
- Does it stay within the "understanding / accessibility / faster / professional primacy" frame?
- Does it imply replacement, disruption, or commodification of the legal profession?
- Does it make any claim the bridge line rules out?
Action on fail: Flag the conflicting claim → require rewrite to bring within bridge line territory.
Output Format
Return a structured compliance verdict for each piece of copy reviewed:
COMPLIANCE REVIEW — [Asset name / surface]
Audience: [Consumer / Lawyer / Mixed]
Reviewer: [Name / AI]
Date: [YYYY-MM-DD]
VERDICT: [PASS / FAIL / CONDITIONAL PASS]
---
PASS 1 — Hard Rules
[ ] Bible signoff: [PASS / BLOCK — reason]
[ ] Press quotes: [PASS / BLOCK — reason]
PASS 2 — Outcome Claims
[ ] Banned outcomes: [PASS / FLAG — quote the flagged phrase]
Required edit: [replacement suggestion]
PASS 3 — Audience Claims
[ ] Banned consumer claims: [PASS / FLAG — quote]
[ ] Banned lawyer claims: [PASS / FLAG — quote]
Required edit: [replacement suggestion]
PASS 4 — Bridge Line
[ ] Bridge line consistency: [PASS / FAIL — explain]
Required edit: [rewrite direction]
---
SUMMARY
Flagged items: [N]
Blocked items: [N]
Next step: [Revise and resubmit / Obtain signoff / Ready to publish]
A CONDITIONAL PASS means no hard blocks exist but minor revisions are recommended before publication.
Escalation
| Situation |
Action |
| New claim type not in the bible |
Block → refer to legal/brand for bible signoff per [[messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required]] |
| Jurisdiction-specific claim (e.g., KSA bar advertising rules) |
Block → refer to local bar compliance review |
| Influencer or partner copy using banned phrasing |
Block → return to influencer for revision per [[messaging-surface-rule-influencer-brief]] |
| Crisis communication copy |
Fast-track review — still apply all four passes but same-day turnaround |
| AI-generated copy |
Same process; AI authorship does not reduce the compliance bar |
Automation
This checker is designed to run as an automated pre-publish gate in the content workflow. Implementation steps:
- Copywriter submits draft to the compliance system (CMS field, Slack workflow, or review tool)
- System runs the four-pass check against the current versions of the linked skills
- Output verdict is returned to copywriter with flagged items
- Blocked items cannot be scheduled for publication until re-checked and passed
- Conditional passes may be published after copywriter acknowledges recommendations
Related skills
- [[messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required]]
- [[messaging-hard-rule-preapproved-press-quotes-only]]
- [[messaging-outcome-claims-banned]]
- [[messaging-outcome-claims-allowed]]
- [[messaging-banned-claims-consumer]]
- [[messaging-banned-claims-lawyer]]
- [[messaging-bridge-line]]
1---2name: messaging-compliance-checker3description: Use to run any customer-facing copy through a systematic pre-publication compliance review for a legal AI assistant. Checks copy against hard rules (bible signoff, banned outcome claims, surface-specific rules), allowed/banned claim lists for both consumer and lawyer audiences, and the bridge line. Outputs a structured pass/fail verdict with flagged phrases and required edits. Apply before any marketing, in-app, social, or PR content ships.4license: MIT5metadata:6 id: messaging.compliance-checker7 category: messaging8 jurisdictions: [__multi__]9 priority: P210 intent: [messaging, compliance, copy-review, pre-publication, marketing-review]11 related: [messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required, messaging-outcome-claims-banned, messaging-outcome-claims-allowed, messaging-banned-claims-consumer, messaging-banned-claims-lawyer, messaging-bridge-line]12 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/sboghossian-mini-claude-for-legal/messaging-compliance-checker13 upstream: Louis — HAQQ Legal AI (github.com/sboghossian/mini-claude-for-legal)14 version: "1.0"15---1617# Messaging — Compliance Checker1819## When this applies2021Every piece of customer-facing copy — written by a human, drafted by an AI, or generated by a contractor or agency — must pass this compliance check before publication. "Customer-facing" includes:2223- All digital advertising (search, display, social)24- Website copy (homepage, product pages, landing pages, pricing)25- Email campaigns (waitlist, onboarding, product, retention)26- In-app notifications, tooltips, and system messages27- Press releases and media statements28- Influencer briefs and sponsored content scripts29- Sales decks, product one-pagers, and partnership proposals30- Conference presentations and booth materials3132This checker is **blocking**: any copy that fails a hard-rule check cannot ship until revised and re-reviewed.3334---3536## Inputs3738| Input | Description |39|-------|-------------|40| Copy text | The full text, headline, CTA, and any disclaimers of the asset being reviewed |41| Surface / channel | Which surface the copy will appear on (homepage, Instagram ad, sales deck, press release, etc.) |42| Primary audience | Consumer (B2C), lawyer (B2B), or mixed |43| New claim flag | Whether any claim in the copy is being used for the first time (triggers bible signoff requirement) |4445---4647## Review Methodology — Four-Pass Check4849### Pass 1 — Hard Rules5051Check against [[messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required]] and [[messaging-hard-rule-preapproved-press-quotes-only]].5253| Rule | Check question |54|------|----------------|55| Bible signoff | Does the copy contain any claim not previously approved in the messaging bible? If yes → block until signoff obtained |56| Press quotes | Does the copy contain a quote from a third party (media, client, influencer)? If yes → verify pre-approval on file; if not on file → block |5758### Pass 2 — Banned Outcome Claims5960Check against [[messaging-outcome-claims-banned]].6162Scan for any of the following or their semantic equivalents:6364- "Will win your case" or any case-outcome guarantee65- "Guaranteed to save money"66- "Replaces your lawyer" (in any form)67- Any specific dollar amount recovered or damages claimed68- Any outcome expressed as a certainty rather than a possibility6970**Action on fail:** Flag exact phrase → require replacement with [[messaging-outcome-claims-allowed]] equivalent.7172### Pass 3 — Audience-Specific Banned Claims7374**If consumer audience:** Check against [[messaging-banned-claims-consumer]].75**If lawyer audience:** Check against [[messaging-banned-claims-lawyer]].76**If mixed:** Apply both.7778Scan for:79- UPL-triggering language (consumer surfaces)80- Displacement / commodification framing (lawyer surfaces)81- Consumer framing on professional surfaces82- Professional jargon on consumer surfaces (accessibility failure, not compliance failure)8384**Action on fail:** Flag exact phrase → reference allowed alternative from the corresponding allowed-claims skill.8586### Pass 4 — Bridge Line Test8788Is the overall copy consistent with the bridge line ("legal understanding accessible to everyone; legal work faster for professionals")?8990Ask:911. Does it stay within the "understanding / accessibility / faster / professional primacy" frame?922. Does it imply replacement, disruption, or commodification of the legal profession?933. Does it make any claim the bridge line rules out?9495**Action on fail:** Flag the conflicting claim → require rewrite to bring within bridge line territory.9697---9899## Output Format100101Return a structured compliance verdict for each piece of copy reviewed:102103```104COMPLIANCE REVIEW — [Asset name / surface]105Audience: [Consumer / Lawyer / Mixed]106Reviewer: [Name / AI]107Date: [YYYY-MM-DD]108109VERDICT: [PASS / FAIL / CONDITIONAL PASS]110111---112PASS 1 — Hard Rules113[ ] Bible signoff: [PASS / BLOCK — reason]114[ ] Press quotes: [PASS / BLOCK — reason]115116PASS 2 — Outcome Claims117[ ] Banned outcomes: [PASS / FLAG — quote the flagged phrase]118 Required edit: [replacement suggestion]119120PASS 3 — Audience Claims121[ ] Banned consumer claims: [PASS / FLAG — quote]122[ ] Banned lawyer claims: [PASS / FLAG — quote]123 Required edit: [replacement suggestion]124125PASS 4 — Bridge Line126[ ] Bridge line consistency: [PASS / FAIL — explain]127 Required edit: [rewrite direction]128129---130SUMMARY131Flagged items: [N]132Blocked items: [N]133Next step: [Revise and resubmit / Obtain signoff / Ready to publish]134```135136A **CONDITIONAL PASS** means no hard blocks exist but minor revisions are recommended before publication.137138---139140## Escalation141142| Situation | Action |143|-----------|--------|144| New claim type not in the bible | Block → refer to legal/brand for bible signoff per [[messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required]] |145| Jurisdiction-specific claim (e.g., KSA bar advertising rules) | Block → refer to local bar compliance review |146| Influencer or partner copy using banned phrasing | Block → return to influencer for revision per [[messaging-surface-rule-influencer-brief]] |147| Crisis communication copy | Fast-track review — still apply all four passes but same-day turnaround |148| AI-generated copy | Same process; AI authorship does not reduce the compliance bar |149150---151152## Automation153154This checker is designed to run as an automated pre-publish gate in the content workflow. Implementation steps:1551. Copywriter submits draft to the compliance system (CMS field, Slack workflow, or review tool)1562. System runs the four-pass check against the current versions of the linked skills1573. Output verdict is returned to copywriter with flagged items1584. Blocked items cannot be scheduled for publication until re-checked and passed1595. Conditional passes may be published after copywriter acknowledges recommendations160161---162163## Related skills164165- [[messaging-hard-rule-bible-signoff-required]]166- [[messaging-hard-rule-preapproved-press-quotes-only]]167- [[messaging-outcome-claims-banned]]168- [[messaging-outcome-claims-allowed]]169- [[messaging-banned-claims-consumer]]170- [[messaging-banned-claims-lawyer]]171- [[messaging-bridge-line]]