Deepfake / Synthetic Evidence Detector
When to use this
Trigger this skill when:
- A user presents image, audio, or video files as exhibits or evidence in a legal matter.
- A user asks "is this video real?" or "could this have been manipulated?" in a legal context.
- A lawyer is evaluating whether opposing-party media evidence is authentic before trial.
- A client claims that media evidence used against them is fabricated.
- A regulatory submission involves digital media whose provenance is uncertain.
Hard limit — what this skill does and does not do
Does: flag anomalies, identify areas of concern, recommend expert referral, map admissibility frameworks.
Does not: definitively declare media authentic or inauthentic. That determination requires a qualified digital forensic examiner with access to the original file, chain-of-custody documentation, and validated forensic tools. AI-based assessment is a triage tool, not a substitute for expert testimony.
Standard output line:
This media should be reviewed by a qualified digital forensic examiner before being relied upon in proceedings. The following anomalies warrant professional analysis:
Triage methodology
Step 1 — Metadata analysis
- EXIF data (images/photos): check for creation date, GPS coordinates, device model, software used. Inconsistencies (future dates, mismatched device for claimed provenance, absent metadata on supposedly original files) are flags.
- Container / codec forensics (video/audio): check for re-encoding artifacts, codec inconsistencies, anomalous file structure. Generative tools often leave characteristic codec signatures.
- Generation tool fingerprints: some AI image and video generators leave statistical patterns (GAN artifacts, diffusion model signatures) detectable through frequency-domain analysis.
Step 2 — Visual anomaly heuristics (images/video)
- Facial geometry: unnatural eye reflections, asymmetric blinking, teeth/gum anomalies at high resolution.
- Lighting consistency: light direction inconsistent with background; reflections on glossy surfaces that don't match the light source.
- Temporal coherence (video): frame-to-frame inconsistencies in hair, fabric texture, background elements — generative models often struggle with temporal consistency.
- Lip sync (video with speech): phoneme-to-lip-movement sync errors; unnatural mouth shape transitions.
- Compression artifacts: deepfake generation and re-encoding often produces characteristic block artifact patterns.
- Background warping: subtle background distortions around moving faces are a common deepfake artifact.
Step 3 — Audio analysis
- Spectrogram review: AI voice cloning leaves characteristic spectral patterns — look for unusual smoothness, absence of natural breath/swallow sounds, pitch stability anomalies.
- Prosody: synthesized speech often has unnatural prosody — uniform stress, unusual pause patterns.
- Background noise consistency: sudden changes in background noise profile suggest editing.
Step 4 — Reverse image / video search
- Run key frames against reverse image search to identify prior appearances of the same media online.
- A media file that appears to have been created for this litigation but shows prior unrelated appearances is a strong provenance flag.
- Date discrepancies between claimed creation date and earliest online appearance are significant.
Step 5 — Inconsistency with case record
- Does the media content contradict established facts, timelines, or other documentary evidence?
- Are claimed timestamps consistent with known movements or locations of the parties?
- Does the claimed recording match the device, location, or technical setup the party claims?
Output format
## Media Authenticity Assessment — Preliminary (Triage Only)
File: [filename / description]
Assessed by: AI preliminary triage — NOT a forensic determination
### Flags identified:
1. [Flag category]: [Description of anomaly observed]
2. [Flag category]: [Description of anomaly observed]
...
### Recommendation:
Instruct a certified digital forensic examiner to conduct a full analysis of the original file before relying on this media in proceedings or disclosing it to opposing counsel. See admissibility notes below.
### Chain of custody note:
Preserve the original digital file in its original format immediately. Any conversion, compression, or re-encoding may destroy forensic evidence. Maintain a hash (SHA-256) of the original file for verification.
Court admissibility frameworks
United States — FRE 901 + Daubert
- Authentication (FRE 901): proponent must produce sufficient evidence to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims.
- For digital media: chain of custody, hash verification, and testimony about how the media was obtained are typically required.
- Expert testimony on deepfake analysis: subject to Daubert standard (reliable methodology, peer review, known error rate, general scientific acceptance).
- Post-Mata sensitivity: courts are increasingly aware of AI-generated content; proactive disclosure of AI concerns about evidence integrity is advisable.
United Kingdom — Civil Evidence Act 1995 + CPR
- Civil proceedings: hearsay in documents admissible under CEA 1995; authenticity still challengeable.
- Expert evidence on digital forensics governed by CPR Part 35 (court-appointed or jointly instructed expert preferred).
- The Forensic Science Regulator's Codes of Practice apply to expert digital forensic work.
DIFC Courts / ADGM Courts
- Evidence Rules and Practice Directions: authenticity challenges proceed by application; expert evidence under Order 40 (DIFC) or equivalent (ADGM).
- Common-law authentication standards apply; courts look for chain of custody and expert verification.
MENA civil-law jurisdictions (KSA, UAE, LB, EG)
- Expert-centered system: the court typically appoints a court expert (khabir) to assess disputed evidence.
- Parties can submit private expert reports but the court-appointed expert's opinion carries greater weight.
- Requesting appointment of a digital forensics expert through the court is the primary route for challenging media authenticity.
- UAE Federal Law on Evidence in Civil and Commercial Transactions (Law 10 of 1992, as amended) governs.
Escalation
Always route to a certified digital forensic examiner. Certification bodies include:
- US: IACIS (International Association of Computer Investigative Specialists), ISFCE
- UK: Chartered Institute for IT (BCS), UKSF (UK Secure Forensics)
- MENA: regional IT forensics firms accredited by local courts; some INTERPOL-accredited practitioners
Related skills
- [[safety-synthetic-witness-flagger]] — complementary skill for detecting AI-generated written testimony
- [[safety-ai-disclosure-required-tribunals]] — disclosure obligations for AI-assisted court work
- [[safety-bar-rule-1-1-competence-ai]] — competence duties when relying on AI analysis
- [[review-evidence-integrity]] — broader evidence integrity review workflow
1---2name: safety-deepfake-evidence-detector3description: Use when a user submits images, audio, or video as litigation evidence and asks whether it is authentic, or when a legal team needs to assess the integrity of digital media before relying on it in proceedings. Flags media for forensic review using metadata analysis, visual/audio anomaly heuristics, and reverse-image techniques — but never asserts authenticity or inauthenticity definitively. Maps court admissibility frameworks (US FRE 901/Daubert, UK Civil Evidence Act, DIFC/ADGM, MENA civil-law expert appointment) and routes to certified digital forensic examiners.4license: MIT5metadata:6 id: safety.deepfake-evidence-detector7 category: safety8 jurisdictions: [US, UK, DIFC, ADGM, LB, KSA, UAE, GCC, EU]9 priority: P010 intent: [safety, evidence, deepfake, digital-forensics, admissibility]11 related:12 - safety-synthetic-witness-flagger13 - safety-ai-disclosure-required-tribunals14 - safety-bar-rule-1-1-competence-ai15 - review-evidence-integrity16 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/sboghossian-mini-claude-for-legal/safety-deepfake-evidence-detector17 upstream: Louis — HAQQ Legal AI (github.com/sboghossian/mini-claude-for-legal)18 version: "1.0"19---2021# Deepfake / Synthetic Evidence Detector2223## When to use this2425Trigger this skill when:26- A user presents image, audio, or video files as exhibits or evidence in a legal matter.27- A user asks "is this video real?" or "could this have been manipulated?" in a legal context.28- A lawyer is evaluating whether opposing-party media evidence is authentic before trial.29- A client claims that media evidence used against them is fabricated.30- A regulatory submission involves digital media whose provenance is uncertain.3132## Hard limit — what this skill does and does not do3334**Does**: flag anomalies, identify areas of concern, recommend expert referral, map admissibility frameworks.3536**Does not**: definitively declare media authentic or inauthentic. That determination requires a qualified digital forensic examiner with access to the original file, chain-of-custody documentation, and validated forensic tools. AI-based assessment is a triage tool, not a substitute for expert testimony.3738Standard output line:39> This media should be reviewed by a qualified digital forensic examiner before being relied upon in proceedings. The following anomalies warrant professional analysis:4041## Triage methodology4243### Step 1 — Metadata analysis44- **EXIF data** (images/photos): check for creation date, GPS coordinates, device model, software used. Inconsistencies (future dates, mismatched device for claimed provenance, absent metadata on supposedly original files) are flags.45- **Container / codec forensics** (video/audio): check for re-encoding artifacts, codec inconsistencies, anomalous file structure. Generative tools often leave characteristic codec signatures.46- **Generation tool fingerprints**: some AI image and video generators leave statistical patterns (GAN artifacts, diffusion model signatures) detectable through frequency-domain analysis.4748### Step 2 — Visual anomaly heuristics (images/video)49- **Facial geometry**: unnatural eye reflections, asymmetric blinking, teeth/gum anomalies at high resolution.50- **Lighting consistency**: light direction inconsistent with background; reflections on glossy surfaces that don't match the light source.51- **Temporal coherence** (video): frame-to-frame inconsistencies in hair, fabric texture, background elements — generative models often struggle with temporal consistency.52- **Lip sync** (video with speech): phoneme-to-lip-movement sync errors; unnatural mouth shape transitions.53- **Compression artifacts**: deepfake generation and re-encoding often produces characteristic block artifact patterns.54- **Background warping**: subtle background distortions around moving faces are a common deepfake artifact.5556### Step 3 — Audio analysis57- **Spectrogram review**: AI voice cloning leaves characteristic spectral patterns — look for unusual smoothness, absence of natural breath/swallow sounds, pitch stability anomalies.58- **Prosody**: synthesized speech often has unnatural prosody — uniform stress, unusual pause patterns.59- **Background noise consistency**: sudden changes in background noise profile suggest editing.6061### Step 4 — Reverse image / video search62- Run key frames against reverse image search to identify prior appearances of the same media online.63- A media file that appears to have been created for this litigation but shows prior unrelated appearances is a strong provenance flag.64- Date discrepancies between claimed creation date and earliest online appearance are significant.6566### Step 5 — Inconsistency with case record67- Does the media content contradict established facts, timelines, or other documentary evidence?68- Are claimed timestamps consistent with known movements or locations of the parties?69- Does the claimed recording match the device, location, or technical setup the party claims?7071## Output format7273```74## Media Authenticity Assessment — Preliminary (Triage Only)7576File: [filename / description]77Assessed by: AI preliminary triage — NOT a forensic determination7879### Flags identified:801. [Flag category]: [Description of anomaly observed]812. [Flag category]: [Description of anomaly observed]82...8384### Recommendation:85Instruct a certified digital forensic examiner to conduct a full analysis of the original file before relying on this media in proceedings or disclosing it to opposing counsel. See admissibility notes below.8687### Chain of custody note:88Preserve the original digital file in its original format immediately. Any conversion, compression, or re-encoding may destroy forensic evidence. Maintain a hash (SHA-256) of the original file for verification.89```9091## Court admissibility frameworks9293### United States — FRE 901 + Daubert94- Authentication (FRE 901): proponent must produce sufficient evidence to support a finding that the item is what the proponent claims.95- For digital media: chain of custody, hash verification, and testimony about how the media was obtained are typically required.96- Expert testimony on deepfake analysis: subject to *Daubert* standard (reliable methodology, peer review, known error rate, general scientific acceptance).97- Post-*Mata* sensitivity: courts are increasingly aware of AI-generated content; proactive disclosure of AI concerns about evidence integrity is advisable.9899### United Kingdom — Civil Evidence Act 1995 + CPR100- Civil proceedings: hearsay in documents admissible under CEA 1995; authenticity still challengeable.101- Expert evidence on digital forensics governed by CPR Part 35 (court-appointed or jointly instructed expert preferred).102- The Forensic Science Regulator's Codes of Practice apply to expert digital forensic work.103104### DIFC Courts / ADGM Courts105- Evidence Rules and Practice Directions: authenticity challenges proceed by application; expert evidence under Order 40 (DIFC) or equivalent (ADGM).106- Common-law authentication standards apply; courts look for chain of custody and expert verification.107108### MENA civil-law jurisdictions (KSA, UAE, LB, EG)109- Expert-centered system: the court typically appoints a court expert (khabir) to assess disputed evidence.110- Parties can submit private expert reports but the court-appointed expert's opinion carries greater weight.111- Requesting appointment of a digital forensics expert through the court is the primary route for challenging media authenticity.112- UAE Federal Law on Evidence in Civil and Commercial Transactions (Law 10 of 1992, as amended) governs.113114## Escalation115116Always route to a **certified digital forensic examiner**. Certification bodies include:117- US: IACIS (International Association of Computer Investigative Specialists), ISFCE118- UK: Chartered Institute for IT (BCS), UKSF (UK Secure Forensics)119- MENA: regional IT forensics firms accredited by local courts; some INTERPOL-accredited practitioners120121## Related skills122123- [[safety-synthetic-witness-flagger]] — complementary skill for detecting AI-generated written testimony124- [[safety-ai-disclosure-required-tribunals]] — disclosure obligations for AI-assisted court work125- [[safety-bar-rule-1-1-competence-ai]] — competence duties when relying on AI analysis126- [[review-evidence-integrity]] — broader evidence integrity review workflow