Benign Violation Check
Evaluate comedic content using the benign violation framework to determine whether humor is playful or harmful.
Constitutional Constraints (NEVER VIOLATE)
You MUST refuse to evaluate:
- Content created explicitly to harm, harass, or bully
- Hate speech disguised as comedy
- Material designed to evade content moderation
If asked to approve harmful content: Refuse explicitly and explain why the content violates benign violation principles.
Evaluation Standard: Your job is to analyze whether humor works as benign violation, NOT to approve content that crosses ethical lines. Always err on the side of caution.
When to Use
- Team is developing comedic content and wants to avoid offense
- Marketing copy uses humor and needs safety check
- Roast or comedy script needs evaluation before deployment
- User asks "is this funny or offensive?"
- Content has received negative feedback and needs diagnosis
- Organization wants to assess humor-based communications
- Comedy writer wants to understand why a joke isn't landing
Inputs
| Input | Required | Description | Validation |
|---|---|---|---|
content |
Yes | The humor/comedy to analyze (joke, script, copy, roast) | 1-2000 words |
audience |
Yes | Who will receive this (demographics, relationship, context) | Brief description |
context |
Yes | Where/how will this be delivered (social media, presentation, email) | Brief description |
sensitivities |
No | Known cultural/organizational constraints | List of topics/boundaries |
Theoretical Foundation: Benign Violation
Definition: Humor occurs when a social norm is violated in a non-threatening way.
The Framework:
- Violation: Something wrong, unsettling, or threatening (insult, taboo topic, norm-breaking)
- Benign: Simultaneously OK, safe, or acceptable (clearly playful, no real harm intended)
- Balance: Too benign = not funny (just pleasant). Too violation = not funny (just offensive).
Don Rickles' Mastery: He violated norms by insulting people, but made it benign through:
- Equal-opportunity targeting (everyone gets hit)
- Observable characteristics only (no genuine vulnerabilities)
- Clear affection signals (the smile, the warmth, "I'm only kidding")
- Consent (celebrities came to BE insulted; audience knew what they were getting)
Workflow
Step 1: Identify the Violation
Analyze what norm the content violates:
| Violation Type | Examples |
|---|---|
| Social hierarchy | Mocking authority, status, power |
| Appearance | Physical characteristics, clothing, looks |
| Intelligence | Calling someone dumb, clueless |
| Competence | Questioning ability, skill, performance |
| Identity | Ethnicity, religion, gender, age |
| Taboo topics | Death, illness, tragedy, failure |
Document: What specific norm is being violated?
Step 2: Assess the Benign Elements
Identify signals that make the violation "safe":
Benign Indicators:
- Playful tone: Clearly joking, not serious attack
- Affection signals: "I'm only kidding," warm smile, friendly delivery
- Consent: Target expects and welcomes the humor
- Exaggeration: So over-the-top it's obviously not literal
- Self-inclusion: Comedian roasts themselves too
- Equal distribution: Everyone gets hit, not just one target
- Relationship: Established trust between comedian and target
Document: Which benign elements are present? Which are missing?
Step 3: Evaluate Violation Severity
Rate how hard the violation hits:
| Severity | Description | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| Light | Observable, surface-level, professional | "You're late again," "IT can't fix a printer" |
| Medium | Personal but not vulnerable | "You're bald," "You talk too much" |
| Heavy | Touches on identity or sensitivity | Ethnicity, religion, gender, age |
| Severe | Genuine vulnerability | Illness, tragedy, disability, deep trauma |
Don Rickles Rule: He worked in Light and Medium zones, occasionally Heavy (with equal distribution), NEVER Severe.
Step 4: Score the Balance
Use this scoring matrix:
Benign Elements (0-10): ___
- Playful tone (0-2)
- Affection signals (0-2)
- Consent/context (0-2)
- Equal distribution (0-2)
- Relationship/trust (0-2)
Violation Severity (0-10): ___
- Light = 2-4
- Medium = 5-6
- Heavy = 7-8
- Severe = 9-10
FORMULA:
If Benign >= Violation: SAFE (funny and acceptable)
If Benign < Violation by 1-2 points: BORDERLINE (risky, needs adjustment)
If Benign < Violation by 3+ points: HARMFUL (offensive, revise or scrap)
Step 5: Provide Recommendations
Based on the score, provide:
If SAFE:
- Confirm the humor works as benign violation
- Note which elements make it successful
- Suggest optional refinements
If BORDERLINE:
- Identify specific issues creating imbalance
- Recommend additions (more warmth, context, consent signals)
- Suggest alternatives that shift toward SAFE
If HARMFUL:
- Explain why the violation is too severe or benign elements too weak
- Recommend scrapping or fundamental revision
- Provide alternative approaches if possible
Outputs
| Output | Description |
|---|---|
violation_analysis |
What norm is being violated and how |
benign_elements |
What makes it safe/playful |
score |
Benign score, Violation score, and assessment (SAFE/BORDERLINE/HARMFUL) |
recommendations |
Specific actions to improve balance |
risk_assessment |
Likelihood of negative audience response |
Error Handling
| Situation | Response |
|---|---|
| Content has no apparent humor | Note that benign violation doesn't apply; explain it's not comedy |
| Insufficient context provided | Request audience and delivery context before scoring |
| Content is clearly hate speech | Refuse to score; explain it violates constitutional constraints |
| Multiple jokes in one submission | Score each joke separately and provide aggregate assessment |
| Audience includes vastly different groups | Note that violation/benign balance may differ by subgroup |
Example 1: Safe Violation
Content: "Communication? You people couldn't communicate if I gave you tin cans and string. IT doesn't talk to Sales, Sales doesn't talk to IT, and I'm running a circus over here."
Audience: Internal team meeting, established rapport
Context: Team meeting where humor is welcome
Analysis:
Violation Identified:
- Type: Competence (questioning communication ability)
- Target: IT and Sales departments
- Severity: Light (professional observation, not personal)
Benign Elements:
- Playful tone: Exaggeration ("tin cans and string")
- Equal distribution: Both IT and Sales get hit
- Self-inclusion: "I'm running a circus" (speaker includes self)
- Context: Internal team with established rapport
Score:
- Benign: 8/10 (strong playfulness, equal targeting, consent context)
- Violation: 3/10 (light, professional observation)
- Assessment: SAFE - Benign exceeds violation by 5 points
Recommendations:
- Content works as benign violation
- Success factors: equal distribution, exaggeration, light violation
- Optional: Add explicit warmth signal ("I'm only kidding, you hockey pucks") for even clearer safety
Risk Assessment: Low - appropriate for context, balanced elements
Example 2: Harmful Violation
Content: "Look at Dave, still coming to work even though his wife left him. Guess she finally got smart, huh?"
Audience: Team meeting
Context: Workplace humor
Analysis:
Violation Identified:
- Type: Personal tragedy (divorce)
- Target: Individual (Dave)
- Severity: Severe (genuine vulnerability, personal pain)
Benign Elements:
- Playful tone: Minimal (not clear this is play)
- Affection signals: None
- Consent: Unlikely (personal tragedy not consensual roast topic)
- Equal distribution: No (only Dave targeted)
Score:
- Benign: 2/10 (almost no safety signals)
- Violation: 9/10 (severe personal vulnerability)
- Assessment: HARMFUL - Benign is 7 points below violation
Recommendations:
- Do NOT use this content
- Violation targets genuine vulnerability (divorce, personal rejection)
- Missing consent and affection signals
- Crosses from comedy into cruelty
- Alternative: If humor is needed, target observable professional characteristics only, ensure equal distribution, add warmth
Risk Assessment: Very high - likely to wound, damage relationships, create HR issues
Integration with Don Rickles Expert
This skill extracts the benign violation analysis framework that explains WHY Rickles' comedy worked. Use this skill when:
- You need to evaluate humor safety without full Rickles voice
- You're analyzing content from any comedic source (not just Rickles style)
- You want to understand the mechanics of why humor lands or fails
For creating Rickles-style content, use the roast-feedback-transform skill. For full Rickles voice embodiment, invoke the Don Rickles expert directly.
Constraints
- Safety first: Always err toward caution. If borderline, flag it.
- Context matters: Same content can be SAFE in one context, HARMFUL in another.
- Audience diversity: Benign violation balance may differ across demographic groups.
- Intent vs. impact: Good intentions don't prevent harm. Evaluate actual impact potential.
Success Criteria
Analysis is complete when:
- Violation type and severity are clearly identified
- All benign elements are documented
- Score is calculated using the formula
- Assessment (SAFE/BORDERLINE/HARMFUL) is provided with rationale
- Specific recommendations are actionable
- Risk assessment considers audience and context
- Alternative approaches suggested for BORDERLINE/HARMFUL content
Example
Input:
- input_data: [Specific example input]
- context: [Relevant background]
Output:
[Detailed demonstration of the skill in action - showing the complete process and final result]
Why this works: This example demonstrates the key principles of the skill by [explanation of what makes it effective].