Parallel Polis
A skill for designing authentic structures alongside official ones - creating spaces where people can live as if they were free while official systems persist.
When to Use
- When official institutions cannot be reformed from within
- When spaces for authentic life are needed now, not after revolution
- When preserving culture, knowledge, or practice that systems suppress
- When training people in self-organization outside official channels
Inputs
- The context: What official structure are you paralleling?
- The need: What authentic activity or life is being suppressed?
- Resources: People, spaces, skills, funding available
- Risk assessment: What is the danger of creating parallel structures?
Workflow
Step 1: Determine what official structures fail to provide:
- Truthful discourse (vs. official lies)
- Education in banned or suppressed ideas
- Art that challenges rather than affirms
- Community based on authentic connection
- Practice of skills the system wants controlled
Step 2: Create the alternative:
- What form will it take? (Seminar, publication, gathering, network)
- Where will it exist? (Physical space, digital, distributed)
- Who participates? (Open, curated, invitation-only)
- What does it produce? (Knowledge, community, capability, culture)
- How does it sustain itself?
Step 3: Determine appropriate exposure:
- Fully underground (high security, limited impact)
- Semi-public (some visibility, some protection)
- Openly parallel (maximum impact, maximum risk)
- Different levels for different activities
Output Format
A parallel polis design including:
- What official structure is being paralleled and why
- Structure design (form, location, participants, outputs)
- Visibility strategy with rationale
- Resilience measures
- Connection and replication plans
- How the structure prefigures desired change
Constraints
- Parallel structures require ongoing effort to maintain
- Risk of state response varies dramatically by context
- Can become insular and lose connection to broader change
- May inadvertently become alternative to change rather than path toward it
- Resource intensive - assess sustainability
Outputs
Primary Output: A structured analysis document that identifies and articulates patterns, insights, and actionable recommendations based on the input data.
Format:
## Analysis: [Topic]
### Key Findings
- [Finding 1]
- [Finding 2]
- [Finding 3]
### Recommendations
1. [Action 1]
2. [Action 2]
3. [Action 3]
Example output: See the Example section below for a complete demonstration.
Additional Notes
Best practices:
- Use this skill when the situation clearly matches its intended use cases
- Combine with related skills for comprehensive analysis
- Iterate on outputs if initial results don't fully meet requirements
Common variations:
- Adjust the depth of analysis based on available time and information
- Scale the approach for different levels of complexity
- Adapt the output format to audience needs
When to skip this skill:
- The situation doesn't match the core use cases
- Simpler approaches would be more appropriate
- Time constraints require faster methods
Example
Input: Design parallel structure for authentic discussion in corporate environment that suppresses honest discourse
Output:
"Official structure: Company meetings where dissent is punished and enthusiasm is mandatory. Parallel polis: Off-site, off-hours gathering of employees for honest discussion of company direction - no recordings, no attribution, Chatham House rules. Form: Monthly dinner at changing locations, rotating hosts. Visibility: Semi-public within company, known informally but not announced. Resilience: No single organizer, rotating responsibility, trust network vets new members. Connection: Similar groups exist at peer companies - share insights through informal channels. Prefiguration: The discussions we wish happened at work actually happen - honest, constructive, critical. This is what the company could be."
Integration
Works with:
- living-in-truth: Individual refusal finds community in parallel structures
- collective-action-design: Similar principles of resilient organization
- commons-building: Parallel structures can become permanent commons
1---2name: parallel-polis3description: A skill for designing authentic structures alongside official ones - creating spaces where people can live as if they were free while official systems persist.4license: MIT5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/sethmblack/parallel-polis7 author: sethmblack8 version: 1.0.46379repository: https://github.com/sethmblack/paks-skills10keywords:11- parallel-polis12- writing13---1415# Parallel Polis1617A skill for designing authentic structures alongside official ones - creating spaces where people can live as if they were free while official systems persist.1819## When to Use2021- When official institutions cannot be reformed from within22- When spaces for authentic life are needed now, not after revolution23- When preserving culture, knowledge, or practice that systems suppress24- When training people in self-organization outside official channels2526## Inputs27281. **The context**: What official structure are you paralleling?292. **The need**: What authentic activity or life is being suppressed?303. **Resources**: People, spaces, skills, funding available314. **Risk assessment**: What is the danger of creating parallel structures?3233## Workflow3435### Step 1: Determine what official structures fail to provide:3637- Truthful discourse (vs. official lies)38- Education in banned or suppressed ideas39- Art that challenges rather than affirms40- Community based on authentic connection41- Practice of skills the system wants controlled4243### Step 2: Create the alternative:4445- What form will it take? (Seminar, publication, gathering, network)46- Where will it exist? (Physical space, digital, distributed)47- Who participates? (Open, curated, invitation-only)48- What does it produce? (Knowledge, community, capability, culture)49- How does it sustain itself?5051### Step 3: Determine appropriate exposure:5253- Fully underground (high security, limited impact)54- Semi-public (some visibility, some protection)55- Openly parallel (maximum impact, maximum risk)56- Different levels for different activities57585960## Output Format6162A parallel polis design including:631. What official structure is being paralleled and why642. Structure design (form, location, participants, outputs)653. Visibility strategy with rationale664. Resilience measures675. Connection and replication plans686. How the structure prefigures desired change6970## Constraints7172- Parallel structures require ongoing effort to maintain73- Risk of state response varies dramatically by context74- Can become insular and lose connection to broader change75- May inadvertently become alternative to change rather than path toward it76- Resource intensive - assess sustainability7778## Outputs7980**Primary Output:** A structured analysis document that identifies and articulates patterns, insights, and actionable recommendations based on the input data.8182**Format:**83```markdown84## Analysis: [Topic]8586### Key Findings87- [Finding 1]88- [Finding 2]89- [Finding 3]9091### Recommendations921. [Action 1]932. [Action 2]943. [Action 3]95```9697**Example output:** See the Example section below for a complete demonstration.9899## Additional Notes100101**Best practices:**102- Use this skill when the situation clearly matches its intended use cases103- Combine with related skills for comprehensive analysis104- Iterate on outputs if initial results don't fully meet requirements105106**Common variations:**107- Adjust the depth of analysis based on available time and information108- Scale the approach for different levels of complexity109- Adapt the output format to audience needs110111**When to skip this skill:**112- The situation doesn't match the core use cases113- Simpler approaches would be more appropriate114- Time constraints require faster methods115116## Example117118**Input**: Design parallel structure for authentic discussion in corporate environment that suppresses honest discourse119120**Output**:121"Official structure: Company meetings where dissent is punished and enthusiasm is mandatory. Parallel polis: Off-site, off-hours gathering of employees for honest discussion of company direction - no recordings, no attribution, Chatham House rules. Form: Monthly dinner at changing locations, rotating hosts. Visibility: Semi-public within company, known informally but not announced. Resilience: No single organizer, rotating responsibility, trust network vets new members. Connection: Similar groups exist at peer companies - share insights through informal channels. Prefiguration: The discussions we wish happened at work actually happen - honest, constructive, critical. This is what the company could be."122123## Integration124125Works with:126- **living-in-truth**: Individual refusal finds community in parallel structures127- **collective-action-design**: Similar principles of resilient organization128- **commons-building**: Parallel structures can become permanent commons