Abap Code Review

ABAP Code Review Skill

Performs pre-release security and quality assessment of SAP ABAP programs, producing a formal Markdown report ready for sign-off and circulation.

Invocation

Any message matching the description above will load this skill. A complete invocation with full context:

Review program [PROGRAM_NAME] for release.
Transport: [DEVKXXXXXX], Change description: [one-line business purpose].
Save the report to the reports/ directory.

To include functional completeness checks ([FUNC] dimension), provide the requirements document path or describe the requirements in the conversation.

Step 0 — Load References First

Before reading any ABAP source code, load the following two files in order. Do not load any other files from the references/ directory:

1. references/REF_ABAP_SECURITY.md — Authority reference for [SEC], [AUTH], and [INTERFACE] dimensions
2. references/REF_CLEAN_ABAP.md — Authority reference for the [STD] dimension

Every [SEC] / [AUTH] / [STD] finding must cite the corresponding rule ID (e.g. SEC-SQL-1, [E-2]). Findings without a rule ID citation are invalid and must be removed.

If reference files are not accessible (e.g., the agent cannot read from the skill directory): proceed using built-in ABAP knowledge. Record under Scope Limitations that reference files were unavailable; rule IDs must still be cited in findings.

Step 1 — Read Source Code

Retrieve the complete source code of the target program using the appropriate method for your environment:

• Tool-equipped agents: Use the available ABAP source-reading capability (ABAP CLI tool, ADT API, MCP tool, or equivalent) to programmatically read the main program and all INCLUDEs.
• Conversation-based agents / manual sessions: Ask the user to paste the source code directly into the conversation, specifying which INCLUDEs, class methods, or function modules are in scope.

Reading order: main program / class definition → INCLUDEs (in order of appearance) → METHODs (one by one).

Objects that cannot be retrieved: record in the report under Scope Limitations, mark as "unreviewed", and do not assume they are safe.

Step 2 — Analyze (9 Dimensions)

Complete all 9 dimensions in the order listed below. No dimension may be skipped (if no issues are found, state "No issues found").

[SEC] Security Vulnerabilities

Reference: REF_ABAP_SECURITY.md. Scan by priority:

Priority 1 (scan immediately):
  EXEC SQL                    → SEC-SQL-2
  GENERATE SUBROUTINE POOL    → SEC-CODE-1
  INSERT REPORT               → SEC-CODE-2
  CALL 'SYSTEM' / SXPG_*     → SEC-OS-1/2/3
  WHERE ( <variable> )        → SEC-SQL-1
  DESTINATION ( <variable> )  → SEC-RFC-1

Priority 2 (important checks):
  cl_sql_statement            → verify set_param parameterization is used
  OPEN DATASET                → path source + SY-SUBRC check
  CALL FUNCTION DESTINATION   → RFC destination source
  literals containing password/key/token → SEC-CRED-1

[AUTH] Authorization & Access Control

Reference: REF_ABAP_SECURITY.md → AUTH-MISS-, AUTH-BYP-

High-risk tables (AUTHORITY-CHECK required before read/write): BKPF/BSEG, MKPF/MSEG, VBAK/VBAP, EKKO/EKPO, PA*/HRP*

Check: ① AUTHORITY-CHECK present before sensitive table operations → ② SY-SUBRC checked immediately after → ③ no SY-UNAME hardcoded bypass → ④ RFC FMs have authorization checks

Special rule: Any HIGH finding in [SEC] or [AUTH] is treated as CRITICAL for the release decision (NO-GO).

[DATA] Data Integrity & Exception Handling

Reference: REF_CLEAN_ABAP.md [E-2] [E-3]

Check: SY-SUBRC after CALL FUNCTION → SY-SUBRC after READ TABLE / SELECT SINGLE → SY-SUBRC after OPEN DATASET → ENQUEUE lock before write operations → COMMIT WORK not inside a loop → ROLLBACK WORK on error paths → no empty CATCH blocks that swallow exceptions

[PERF] Performance Risks

Reference: REF_CLEAN_ABAP.md [T-1] [T-2] [T-3]

Check: SELECT inside LOOP (→ [T-2], CRITICAL for large tables) → SELECT * without projection (→ [T-3]) → full table scan (no WHERE clause) → READ TABLE WITH KEY inside LOOP (→ [T-1], switch to SORTED/HASHED) → high-volume tables (BKPF/BSEG/MKPF/MSEG) without row-count protection

[STD] ABAP Code Standards

Reference: REF_CLEAN_ABAP.md [L-] [C-] [N-] [M-]

Check deprecated statements ([L-3]), hardcoded business values such as bukrs/werks/mandt ([C-3], typically HIGH in enterprise settings), overly long methods ([M-2], flag if > 20 statements), commented-out code blocks ([CM-3]), Unicode compatibility

[INTERFACE] Interface & Integration Risks

Reference: REF_ABAP_SECURITY.md SEC-RFC-, SEC-WEB-

Check: RFC FM contains dialog messages MESSAGE TYPE A/I/W (→ SEC-RFC-3) → RFC FM parameters have type declarations → EXCEPTIONS fully declared → CALL FUNCTION DESTINATION has timeout configured → OData DPC Extension has backend authorization check (→ SEC-WEB-2)

[CHANGE] Change Impact Assessment

Assess: affected database tables (list all read/write/delete operations) → whether SAP standard objects are modified → whether the program shares INCLUDEs or FMs with other programs → Transport prerequisites and cross-system dependencies

[COMP] Compliance & Audit Trail

Check: PII data reads/exports have a compliance basis → FI/CO postings have dual-control → master data changes written to CDHDR/CDPOS → program logs executor/timestamp/parameters → no single person can both initiate and approve (SoD path)

[FUNC] Functional Completeness (Optional)

Execute only when the user provides a requirements specification; otherwise state the reason for skipping in the report.

If executed: verify program entry points cover business scenarios → boundary condition handling (null/zero/oversized datasets) → core business logic matches requirements → calculation logic is accurate → output fields are complete → integration interfaces transmit data completely

Step 3 — Severity Classification

When severity is uncertain, choose the higher level.

Step 4 — Release Decision

CRITICAL finding present                        → NO-GO
HIGH finding in [SEC] or [AUTH]                 → NO-GO (special rule)
HIGH finding in other dimensions                → CONDITIONAL GO (requires tech lead sign-off)
MEDIUM / LOW / INFO findings only               → GO

Step 5 — Generate Report

Load references/REPORT_TEMPLATE.md and generate the report by strictly following the template structure.

Report language: titles and rule references in English; risk descriptions and remediation recommendations in English.

File naming: ABAP_REVIEW_[PROGRAM_NAME]_[YYYYMMDD].md When a CRITICAL finding is present, prefix: CRITICAL_ABAP_REVIEW_[PROGRAM_NAME]_[YYYYMMDD].md

Save to the reports/ directory specified by the user and confirm the file path upon completion.

If file system write access is unavailable: output the complete report as formatted Markdown in the conversation. Inform the user that no file was saved and suggest they copy the output manually.

Behavior Rules