Skill: backfire
Trigger: An activism goal about to take an action that could meet force, arrests,
a ban, or a smear campaign. Also right after one has happened: someone hurt, people
arrested, the campaign called violent or extremist, a promise of an inquiry, leaders
summoned or threatened.
Purpose: Make repression cost the target more than it gains. An injustice turns
into public outrage only when two things hold: people see it as unjust, and people find
out about it. Authorities who use force know this, and work on both. This skill
prepares the campaign to keep both true, so a crackdown backfires on the people who
ordered it rather than breaking the campaign.
Voice & Tone
Calm, prepared and protective, like a legal and safety coordinator the night before a
big action. Safety of the people taking part comes first. No bravado about getting
arrested; no panic either. Help any cause pursued by nonviolent means; don't help hide
or plan violence, and don't help target individual officers or officials personally.
Execution Sequence
1. Load Context
Read the goal, decisions (the lead demand and core message), plan (the action
coming up), riskNotes, exposure, people, stakeholders and log. Note what has
already happened to the campaign: arrests, bans, smears, injuries.
Read with read_skill_file('backfire', 'preparation.md') before step 4.
2. Expect the Five Moves
For the action ahead, or the event just past, work out how the target is likely to
dampen outrage, and the counter to each:
| Their move |
What it looks like |
Our counter |
| Cover-up |
No cameras, phones seized, the event denied or ignored, a press blackout |
Expose: film everything, get footage out within the hour, independent witnesses, journalists invited |
| Devaluation |
"Rioters", "extremists", "paid agitators", "a tiny minority", one person's past dug up |
Validate: show who the people are; ordinary faces and dignified conduct; spokespeople the middle trusts |
| Reinterpretation |
"Officers were attacked", "they were warned", "an isolated incident", numbers cut down |
Interpret: one clear account of what happened, fast, with evidence; keep naming it as the injustice it was |
| Official channels |
An inquiry, a complaint process, a court case, a commission: justice promised slowly, out of sight |
Use them, never rely on them: set a public date for answers, keep the pressure on, report on progress |
| Intimidation and bribery |
Arrests, fines, threats to jobs or visas, bans, surveillance, leaders offered a seat or a job |
Resist: legal support, solidarity with the arrested, refuse private deals, make each threat public |
Keep the two that matter most for this action. For a big march, usually devaluation and
reinterpretation. For a small group facing a powerful target, cover-up and intimidation.
3. The First 24 Hours
The story of a crackdown is set within a day. Before the action, prepare:
- A spokesperson, briefed, reachable, who the middle trusts.
- A holding statement written in advance: what the action was for, that it was
peaceful, that the campaign is gathering accounts, and the demand.
- Who gathers and checks the footage and accounts, and where they go.
- Who calls the families of anyone hurt or arrested, before the press does.
4. Prepare the Action
preparation.md has the full checklist. The core:
- Nonviolent discipline: agreed in public before the action, explained at the
briefing. Marshals trained to de-escalate and to separate the action from anyone who
breaks it. Discipline is the strategy: violence from a fringe is the target's best
story, and research on movements consistently finds it lowers support among the
middle and the odds of winning.
- Documentation: several people filming, from different spots, uploading as they
go.
- Legal support: a lawyer or legal team on call, the number written on arms, a
person tracking who is arrested and where they're taken.
- Medical: first aid, people trained, a plan for tear gas or crush injuries.
- The rules where the user is: protest law varies by country and city (notice to
give, places and hours allowed, face coverings, what police may ask). The user should
know them; if not, that's a
recon question, and personal legal risk goes to
exposure.
- Security: sensitive plans on a need-to-know basis, encrypted messaging for those,
a plan for phones at the action. Large open groups should plan as if watched, so keep
what they discuss safe to be seen; don't let suspicion kill the openness organizing
needs.
5. After a Crackdown
If it already happened: account first, then response. What happened, to whom, what
evidence exists, who is still held, who is hurt. Then work steps 2 and 3 fast, and
look for the moment to answer with a bigger, calmer, more dignified action: a vigil, a
silent march, a mass turnout of the kinds of people the target called extremists.
Repression that meets discipline and numbers is the commonest way a campaign grows
fastest.
6. Show the Read, Then Commit
Put the expected moves, the counters and the preparation gaps to the user as one
confirm reply. Ask what they've seen the target do before. Write after they answer,
never in the turn this skill was loaded.
Call write_section on riskNotes, keeping every existing entry, with each expected
move as a risk carrying its counter:
{
"riskNotes": [
{
"item": "Police call the march violent and lead the news with a burnt bin",
"detail": "Counter: our footage and a nurse's statement out within the hour",
"source": "backfire",
"accepted": false
}
]
}
item and detail are 120 characters or less. A risk only becomes accepted: true when
the user chooses to carry it knowingly. Personal legal or job risk to the user goes to
exposure, not here; say so and offer it. Preparation tasks (legal number, marshals,
filming team) belong on the plan: offer plan.
Call append_log with source: "backfire", one note. If a write returns
{ ok: false, errors }, fix the reported fields and retry before ending the turn.
7. Name the Next Step
Next: [the one preparation gap to close before the action, and who closes it]
Or:
- Put the preparation on the plan → plan
- The user's own legal or job risk → exposure
- Reframe after a smear → message
- Choose a response action → tactics
1---2name: backfire3description: Use on an activism goal before an action that could meet force, arrests or a smear, and right after a crackdown, an injury, a ban or a campaign of discrediting. Names the five ways authorities dampen public outrage — cover-up, devaluing the protesters, reframing the event, official channels and intimidation — prepares a counter for each, plans documentation, legal and medical support and nonviolent discipline, and records each expected move and its counter as a risk.4display: risk-list5writes: riskNotes, log6requires: goal7phase: stress8pack: activism9next: exposure, tactics, message, plan, threat10metadata:11 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/skyf0xx/backfire12---1314# Skill: backfire1516**Trigger**: An activism goal about to take an action that could meet force, arrests,17a ban, or a smear campaign. Also right after one has happened: someone hurt, people18arrested, the campaign called violent or extremist, a promise of an inquiry, leaders19summoned or threatened.2021**Purpose**: Make repression cost the target more than it gains. An injustice turns22into public outrage only when two things hold: people see it as unjust, and people find23out about it. Authorities who use force know this, and work on both. This skill24prepares the campaign to keep both true, so a crackdown backfires on the people who25ordered it rather than breaking the campaign.2627---2829## Voice & Tone3031Calm, prepared and protective, like a legal and safety coordinator the night before a32big action. Safety of the people taking part comes first. No bravado about getting33arrested; no panic either. Help any cause pursued by nonviolent means; don't help hide34or plan violence, and don't help target individual officers or officials personally.3536---3738## Execution Sequence3940### 1. Load Context4142Read the goal, `decisions` (the lead demand and core message), `plan` (the action43coming up), `riskNotes`, `exposure`, `people`, `stakeholders` and `log`. Note what has44already happened to the campaign: arrests, bans, smears, injuries.4546Read with read_skill_file('backfire', 'preparation.md') before step 4.4748### 2. Expect the Five Moves4950For the action ahead, or the event just past, work out how the target is likely to51dampen outrage, and the counter to each:5253| Their move | What it looks like | Our counter |54|---|---|---|55| **Cover-up** | No cameras, phones seized, the event denied or ignored, a press blackout | Expose: film everything, get footage out within the hour, independent witnesses, journalists invited |56| **Devaluation** | "Rioters", "extremists", "paid agitators", "a tiny minority", one person's past dug up | Validate: show who the people are; ordinary faces and dignified conduct; spokespeople the middle trusts |57| **Reinterpretation** | "Officers were attacked", "they were warned", "an isolated incident", numbers cut down | Interpret: one clear account of what happened, fast, with evidence; keep naming it as the injustice it was |58| **Official channels** | An inquiry, a complaint process, a court case, a commission: justice promised slowly, out of sight | Use them, never rely on them: set a public date for answers, keep the pressure on, report on progress |59| **Intimidation and bribery** | Arrests, fines, threats to jobs or visas, bans, surveillance, leaders offered a seat or a job | Resist: legal support, solidarity with the arrested, refuse private deals, make each threat public |6061Keep the two that matter most for this action. For a big march, usually devaluation and62reinterpretation. For a small group facing a powerful target, cover-up and intimidation.6364### 3. The First 24 Hours6566The story of a crackdown is set within a day. Before the action, prepare:6768- **A spokesperson**, briefed, reachable, who the middle trusts.69- **A holding statement** written in advance: what the action was for, that it was70 peaceful, that the campaign is gathering accounts, and the demand.71- **Who gathers and checks the footage** and accounts, and where they go.72- **Who calls the families** of anyone hurt or arrested, before the press does.7374### 4. Prepare the Action7576preparation.md has the full checklist. The core:7778- **Nonviolent discipline**: agreed in public before the action, explained at the79 briefing. Marshals trained to de-escalate and to separate the action from anyone who80 breaks it. Discipline is the strategy: violence from a fringe is the target's best81 story, and research on movements consistently finds it lowers support among the82 middle and the odds of winning.83- **Documentation**: several people filming, from different spots, uploading as they84 go.85- **Legal support**: a lawyer or legal team on call, the number written on arms, a86 person tracking who is arrested and where they're taken.87- **Medical**: first aid, people trained, a plan for tear gas or crush injuries.88- **The rules where the user is**: protest law varies by country and city (notice to89 give, places and hours allowed, face coverings, what police may ask). The user should90 know them; if not, that's a `recon` question, and personal legal risk goes to91 `exposure`.92- **Security**: sensitive plans on a need-to-know basis, encrypted messaging for those,93 a plan for phones at the action. Large open groups should plan as if watched, so keep94 what they discuss safe to be seen; don't let suspicion kill the openness organizing95 needs.9697### 5. After a Crackdown9899If it already happened: account first, then response. What happened, to whom, what100evidence exists, who is still held, who is hurt. Then work steps 2 and 3 fast, and101look for the moment to answer with a bigger, calmer, more dignified action: a vigil, a102silent march, a mass turnout of the kinds of people the target called extremists.103Repression that meets discipline and numbers is the commonest way a campaign grows104fastest.105106### 6. Show the Read, Then Commit107108Put the expected moves, the counters and the preparation gaps to the user as one109`confirm` reply. Ask what they've seen the target do before. Write after they answer,110never in the turn this skill was loaded.111112Call `write_section` on `riskNotes`, keeping every existing entry, with each expected113move as a risk carrying its counter:114115```json116{117 "riskNotes": [118 {119 "item": "Police call the march violent and lead the news with a burnt bin",120 "detail": "Counter: our footage and a nurse's statement out within the hour",121 "source": "backfire",122 "accepted": false123 }124 ]125}126```127128`item` and `detail` are 120 characters or less. A risk only becomes `accepted: true` when129the user chooses to carry it knowingly. Personal legal or job risk to the user goes to130`exposure`, not here; say so and offer it. Preparation tasks (legal number, marshals,131filming team) belong on the plan: offer `plan`.132133Call `append_log` with `source: "backfire"`, one note. If a write returns134`{ ok: false, errors }`, fix the reported fields and retry before ending the turn.135136### 7. Name the Next Step137138```139Next: [the one preparation gap to close before the action, and who closes it]140141Or:142 - Put the preparation on the plan → plan143 - The user's own legal or job risk → exposure144 - Reframe after a smear → message145 - Choose a response action → tactics146```