Franklin Decision Ledger Skill
In a 1772 letter to Joseph Priestley, Franklin laid out why hard decisions feel
impossible: the reasons for and against are never "present to the mind at the same
time" — whichever set you thought about most recently feels decisive. His fix, which
he called moral or prudential algebra, is a ledger kept over days, with weights,
where reasons of equal weight are struck out in pairs until one column visibly
outweighs. This skill runs the full method — not the flattened pros-and-cons list it
degenerated into.
What This Skill Produces
- A two-column decision ledger with every motive the user can surface, weighted
- The cancellation pass: equal weights struck out in pairs, remainder shown
- The leaning the algebra produces, its strongest surviving counter-reason, and
what evidence would flip it
- A sit-on-it plan: what to add to the ledger over the next 1–2 days before
committing (Franklin's "farther consideration" step)
Required Inputs
Ask for (if not already provided):
- The two options, stated as the user would say them (if there are three, split the
decision or run twice — the algebra is pairwise)
- Everything currently pulling them each way, however small or embarrassing
- The deadline, and what happens if they decide nothing
- Who else the decision lands on (family, team) — their motives belong in the ledger
Framework: the algebra, as Franklin described it
- Divide the paper — one column Pro, one Con, for Option A over Option B.
- Collect over time, not in one sitting — Franklin's instruction is to gather
motives "during three or four days consideration" as they occur. In one session:
do three passes — practical, emotional, reputational — because different passes
surface different motives. Then schedule the real-time additions (see output).
- Weight each motive — the user assigns weights (1–5 works), not the assistant.
Probe the suspicious ones: a 5 that can't survive one "why?" is a 2 wearing fear.
- Strike out equals — the step that makes it algebra: one Pro-3 cancels one
Con-3; two Con-2s cancel a Pro-4. Cross them out visibly. What remains after
cancellation is the actual decision surface — usually two or three motives, which
is why the method clears heads.
- Find where the balance lies, then wait — if a day or two of further thought
adds nothing new to either column, decide accordingly. Franklin's claim was
modest and right: the weights aren't precise, but with each motive considered
comparatively, "I think I can judge better, and am less liable to make a rash
step."
Output Format
## The decision
[Option A vs Option B, one line each, deadline]
## The ledger — A over B
| Pro | w | Con | w |
[every motive, user-weighted]
## Cancellation pass
[struck pairs listed: "quiet team (3) cancels commute (3)" …]
Remaining: Pro [names + total] · Con [names + total]
## The leaning
[Which way the remainder points · the strongest SURVIVING counter-reason, stated
better than the user stated it · what single piece of evidence would flip this]
## Before you commit (Franklin's waiting step)
[2-3 motives likely to surface late — prompts, not inventions: "you haven't priced
X yet" · a revisit date within the deadline]
Quality Checks
Anti-Patterns
Related
Log the final call in [[decision-journal]] with its falsifiable predictions — the
ledger decides, the journal keeps you honest later.
Example Trigger Phrases
- "Help me decide between these two options."
- "Weigh the pros and cons properly."
- "Run Franklin's pro and con method on this choice."
- "I can't decide whether to take the job."
1---2name: franklin-decision-ledger3description: "Run a hard two-option decision through Benjamin Franklin's 'moral or prudential algebra' — the weighted pro/con method he described to Joseph Priestley in 1772 — including the part everyone skips: striking out reasons that cancel, and letting the ledger sit before deciding. Use when weighing job offers, relocations, build-vs-buy, take-the-promotion, shut-it-down decisions, or any 'I keep going back and forth'. Produces a completed decision ledger with a leaning, its strongest counter, and a revisit date."4disable-model-invocation: true # skill-optimizer5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/slipcast-dev/franklin-decision-ledger7---89# Franklin Decision Ledger Skill1011In a 1772 letter to Joseph Priestley, Franklin laid out why hard decisions feel12impossible: the reasons for and against are never "present to the mind at the same13time" — whichever set you thought about most recently feels decisive. His fix, which14he called **moral or prudential algebra**, is a ledger kept over days, with weights,15where reasons of equal weight are struck out in pairs until one column visibly16outweighs. This skill runs the full method — not the flattened pros-and-cons list it17degenerated into.1819## What This Skill Produces2021- A two-column **decision ledger** with every motive the user can surface, weighted22- The **cancellation pass**: equal weights struck out in pairs, remainder shown23- The **leaning** the algebra produces, its strongest surviving counter-reason, and24 what evidence would flip it25- A **sit-on-it plan**: what to add to the ledger over the next 1–2 days before26 committing (Franklin's "farther consideration" step)2728## Required Inputs2930Ask for (if not already provided):31- The two options, stated as the user would say them (if there are three, split the32 decision or run twice — the algebra is pairwise)33- Everything currently pulling them each way, however small or embarrassing34- The deadline, and what happens if they decide nothing35- Who else the decision lands on (family, team) — their motives belong in the ledger3637## Framework: the algebra, as Franklin described it38391. **Divide the paper** — one column *Pro*, one *Con*, for Option A over Option B.402. **Collect over time, not in one sitting** — Franklin's instruction is to gather41 motives "during three or four days consideration" as they occur. In one session:42 do three passes — practical, emotional, reputational — because different passes43 surface different motives. Then schedule the real-time additions (see output).443. **Weight each motive** — the user assigns weights (1–5 works), not the assistant.45 Probe the suspicious ones: a 5 that can't survive one "why?" is a 2 wearing fear.464. **Strike out equals** — the step that makes it algebra: one Pro-3 cancels one47 Con-3; two Con-2s cancel a Pro-4. Cross them out visibly. What remains after48 cancellation is the actual decision surface — usually two or three motives, which49 is why the method clears heads.505. **Find where the balance lies, then wait** — if a day or two of further thought51 adds nothing new to either column, decide accordingly. Franklin's claim was52 modest and right: the weights aren't precise, but with each motive considered53 *comparatively*, "I think I can judge better, and am less liable to make a rash54 step."5556## Output Format5758```59## The decision60[Option A vs Option B, one line each, deadline]6162## The ledger — A over B63| Pro | w | Con | w |64[every motive, user-weighted]6566## Cancellation pass67[struck pairs listed: "quiet team (3) cancels commute (3)" …]68Remaining: Pro [names + total] · Con [names + total]6970## The leaning71[Which way the remainder points · the strongest SURVIVING counter-reason, stated72better than the user stated it · what single piece of evidence would flip this]7374## Before you commit (Franklin's waiting step)75[2-3 motives likely to surface late — prompts, not inventions: "you haven't priced76X yet" · a revisit date within the deadline]77```7879## Quality Checks8081- [ ] Weights came from the user — the assistant proposed none, but challenged at82 least one83- [ ] The cancellation pass actually happened, pairs named — without it this is an84 ordinary pros/cons list and the skill has failed85- [ ] The strongest counter-reason is presented in its best form (steelman), not86 its dismissible form87- [ ] Motives affecting other people appear in the ledger, attributed88- [ ] The output ends with a revisit date, not just a verdict — the waiting period89 is part of the method9091## Anti-Patterns9293- [ ] Do not decide for the user — the algebra's output is a *leaning* plus its94 strongest counter; the user decides95- [ ] Do not fill the ledger with invented motives to look thorough; every entry96 traces to something the user said or confirmed97- [ ] Do not let weights masquerade as objectivity — surface that a 5-point fear98 and a 5-point salary bump were made commensurable by feel, and say so99- [ ] Do not skip the emotional pass because the decision "should be rational";100 Franklin put prudence *and* inclination in the same ledger on purpose101102## Related103104Log the final call in [[decision-journal]] with its falsifiable predictions — the105ledger decides, the journal keeps you honest later.106107## Example Trigger Phrases108109- "Help me decide between these two options."110- "Weigh the pros and cons properly."111- "Run Franklin's pro and con method on this choice."112- "I can't decide whether to take the job."