Mechanic Quote Decoder Skill
Most garages are honest; the padding problem is structural anyway: you
can't see the car, you can't judge the diagnosis, and the quote arrives
by phone with a "while it's up on the lift" rider. The defense isn't
mechanical knowledge — it's interrogation structure: which lines trace
to the symptom you brought the car in with, which are discoveries
(legitimate but separately decidable), which are maintenance upsells
wearing urgency, and the magic question that dissolves soft lines:
"which of these are safety-critical today, and which can wait until
the next service?" Honest garages answer that cleanly. The answer's
shape tells you which kind you're dealing with.
What This Skill Produces
- A line-by-line decode of the quote: symptom-linked / legitimate
discovery / maintenance-due / soft upsell — with the reasoning per
line and the 🔴🟡🟢 urgency read as claimed vs as evidenced
- The callback questions, scripted: the safety-critical-today
question, the "can I see/keep the old part?" line, the failed-vs-
worn distinction ("is it broken, or wearing?"), labor-hours clarity
- A sort: authorize now / decline politely / defer to next service /
second-opinion — with the decline scripts that keep the relationship
- The second-opinion math: when the quote size justifies the cost
and hassle of another garage's eyes, and how to ask for one without
war
- Price-sanity flags: parts findable at retail (the OEM-vs-
pattern-part question asked, not assumed), labor hours vs book-time
norms — framed as questions to ask, never as asserted local prices
Required Inputs
Ask for (if not already provided):
- The quote/invoice text or the phone-call version as remembered, with
every line and price
- The original symptom: what the car was brought in FOR, in the user's
words
- The car (make/model/year/mileage) and its service history roughness
- The relationship: trusted long-term garage, or first visit? (The
prior changes the read — and the scripts)
Framework
- Anchor every line to the symptom. Three bins: fixes-the-
complaint · discovered-while-in-there (real, but a separate
decision — the lift doesn't obligate you) · unrelated-maintenance
(legitimate as scheduled work, soft as urgency). A quote where
nothing maps to the original symptom is itself a 🔴.
- Interrogate urgency, don't assume bad faith. The load-bearing
question, verbatim: "Which of these are unsafe to drive on today,
and which can wait for the next service?" Follow-ups: "is the part
failed or wearing?" · "what happens if I leave it 3 months?" Honest
answers are specific and mixed; padding answers are uniformly
urgent.
- Ask for the evidence ritual. "Can you show me / photograph the
worn part?" and "I'd like the old parts back" — both normal
professional requests; both change soft-line behavior. On brakes,
the numbers question: "how many millimeters left?" converts
"getting low" into a fact with a timeline.
- Sanity-check the money as questions. Parts: "is that OEM or
pattern, and what's the price difference?" Labor: "how many hours is
that line?" — then the user can compare against book-time sources
themselves; the skill frames the questions and never invents local
rates. Diagnostic fees credited against work done? Ask — often yes.
- Sort and script. Authorize the symptom-fix and true safety
items · defer maintenance-due to its schedule ("let's do that at
the service in March — book me in") · decline the soft lines with
the relationship-keeper: "just the [symptom fix] today, thanks —
I'll plan the rest." Second-opinion trigger: quote is
engine/transmission money, or the urgency answers came back
uniform-and-vague; the ask that isn't war: "I want to think about a
bill this size — can I get the diagnosis in writing?" (The written-
diagnosis request is also the second garage's starting point.)
Output Format
## The quote, decoded
| Line | £ | Bin (symptom / discovery / maintenance / soft) | Urgency
claimed vs evidenced | Verdict |
## Call the garage back with these
[The scripted questions, in order, with what honest vs soft answers
sound like]
## The sort
Authorize: … · Defer (with booking line): … · Decline (script): … ·
Second opinion because: …
## Money sanity questions
[OEM-vs-pattern · labor hours · diagnostic-fee credit — as asks]
⚠ This decodes the quote's structure — it is not a remote diagnosis.
A written diagnosis + a second garage is the tool for engine-money
decisions.
Quality Checks
Anti-Patterns
Related
[[used-car-decoder]] before this car was yours;
[[home-contractor-quote-decoder]] — the same grammar in a different
trade; [[car-tco]] for whether this car is worth fixing at all.
Example Trigger Phrases
- "Is this mechanic quote fair?"
- "Do I really need all this?"
- "Which of these repairs are padding?"
- "Should I get a second opinion on this garage quote?"
1---2name: mechanic-quote-decoder3description: "Read a garage quote or invoice like someone who can't be padded — which line items connect to your actual symptom, which are while-we're-in-there additions, the questions that make soft lines disappear, when a second opinion pays for itself, and the scripts for declining work without souring the relationship. Use when someone says 'is this mechanic quote fair', 'the garage called and now it's £900', 'do I really need all this', or before authorizing repairs. Produces a line-by-line decode, the callback questions, and the authorize/decline/second-opinion sort. Not a diagnosis — it's the interrogation of one."4disable-model-invocation: true # skill-optimizer5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/slipcast-dev/mechanic-quote-decoder7---89# Mechanic Quote Decoder Skill1011Most garages are honest; the padding problem is structural anyway: you12can't see the car, you can't judge the diagnosis, and the quote arrives13by phone with a "while it's up on the lift" rider. The defense isn't14mechanical knowledge — it's *interrogation structure*: which lines trace15to the symptom you brought the car in with, which are discoveries16(legitimate but separately decidable), which are maintenance upsells17wearing urgency, and the magic question that dissolves soft lines:18"which of these are safety-critical *today*, and which can wait until19the next service?" Honest garages answer that cleanly. The answer's20shape tells you which kind you're dealing with.2122## What This Skill Produces2324- A **line-by-line decode** of the quote: symptom-linked / legitimate25 discovery / maintenance-due / soft upsell — with the reasoning per26 line and the 🔴🟡🟢 urgency read *as claimed vs as evidenced*27- The **callback questions**, scripted: the safety-critical-today28 question, the "can I see/keep the old part?" line, the failed-vs-29 worn distinction ("is it broken, or wearing?"), labor-hours clarity30- A **sort**: authorize now / decline politely / defer to next service /31 second-opinion — with the decline scripts that keep the relationship32- The **second-opinion math**: when the quote size justifies the cost33 and hassle of another garage's eyes, and how to ask for one without34 war35- **Price-sanity flags**: parts findable at retail (the OEM-vs-36 pattern-part question asked, not assumed), labor hours vs book-time37 norms — framed as questions to ask, never as asserted local prices3839## Required Inputs4041Ask for (if not already provided):42- The quote/invoice text or the phone-call version as remembered, with43 every line and price44- The original symptom: what the car was brought in FOR, in the user's45 words46- The car (make/model/year/mileage) and its service history roughness47- The relationship: trusted long-term garage, or first visit? (The48 prior changes the read — and the scripts)4950## Framework51521. **Anchor every line to the symptom.** Three bins: fixes-the-53 complaint · discovered-while-in-there (real, but a *separate54 decision* — the lift doesn't obligate you) · unrelated-maintenance55 (legitimate as scheduled work, soft as urgency). A quote where56 nothing maps to the original symptom is itself a 🔴.572. **Interrogate urgency, don't assume bad faith.** The load-bearing58 question, verbatim: "Which of these are unsafe to drive on today,59 and which can wait for the next service?" Follow-ups: "is the part60 failed or wearing?" · "what happens if I leave it 3 months?" Honest61 answers are specific and mixed; padding answers are uniformly62 urgent.633. **Ask for the evidence ritual.** "Can you show me / photograph the64 worn part?" and "I'd like the old parts back" — both normal65 professional requests; both change soft-line behavior. On brakes,66 the numbers question: "how many millimeters left?" converts67 "getting low" into a fact with a timeline.684. **Sanity-check the money as questions.** Parts: "is that OEM or69 pattern, and what's the price difference?" Labor: "how many hours is70 that line?" — then the user can compare against book-time sources71 themselves; the skill frames the questions and never invents local72 rates. Diagnostic fees credited against work done? Ask — often yes.735. **Sort and script.** Authorize the symptom-fix and true safety74 items · defer maintenance-due to its schedule ("let's do that at75 the service in March — book me in") · decline the soft lines with76 the relationship-keeper: "just the [symptom fix] today, thanks —77 I'll plan the rest." Second-opinion trigger: quote is78 engine/transmission money, or the urgency answers came back79 uniform-and-vague; the ask that isn't war: "I want to think about a80 bill this size — can I get the diagnosis in writing?" (The written-81 diagnosis request is also the second garage's starting point.)8283## Output Format8485```86## The quote, decoded87| Line | £ | Bin (symptom / discovery / maintenance / soft) | Urgency88claimed vs evidenced | Verdict |8990## Call the garage back with these91[The scripted questions, in order, with what honest vs soft answers92sound like]9394## The sort95Authorize: … · Defer (with booking line): … · Decline (script): … ·96Second opinion because: …9798## Money sanity questions99[OEM-vs-pattern · labor hours · diagnostic-fee credit — as asks]100101⚠ This decodes the quote's structure — it is not a remote diagnosis.102A written diagnosis + a second garage is the tool for engine-money103decisions.104```105106## Quality Checks107108- [ ] Every line lands in exactly one bin with reasoning tied to the109 stated symptom110- [ ] The safety-critical-today question appears verbatim in the111 callback script112- [ ] Deferrals come with a rebooking line — declining maintenance113 forever is its own future 🔴, and the decode says so114- [ ] No local prices, book-times, or part costs asserted — money115 checks are framed as questions116- [ ] The tone treats the garage as presumed-honest; the structure does117 the protecting118119## Anti-Patterns120121- [ ] Do not diagnose the car — the skill interrogates the quote, and122 says so when asked to do more123- [ ] Do not script accusations — every line is deliverable to a124 mechanic you'll see again125- [ ] Do not dismiss discovered work as scam by default; the lift126 really does reveal things — separate decision ≠ illegitimate127- [ ] Do not let deferred safety items vanish — deferrals get dates128- [ ] Do not invent repair prices or hour norms; the questions put the129 numbers on the garage's side of the table where they belong130131## Related132133[[used-car-decoder]] before this car was yours;134[[home-contractor-quote-decoder]] — the same grammar in a different135trade; [[car-tco]] for whether this car is worth fixing at all.136137## Example Trigger Phrases138139- "Is this mechanic quote fair?"140- "Do I really need all this?"141- "Which of these repairs are padding?"142- "Should I get a second opinion on this garage quote?"