Public Comment Skill
Agencies must review and respond to substantive comments — but only substantive ones move the needle. A
comment that cites the specific provision, brings evidence, and proposes concrete alternative language carries
far more weight than "I support/oppose this." This skill drafts that substantive comment.
Required Inputs
Ask for these only if they aren't already provided:
- The proposal — the rule/regulation/plan, ideally the specific sections or docket number.
- Your position & interest — support, oppose, or amend; and who you are (individual, business, org — it affects standing/weight).
- The substance — your reasons, and any data, expertise, or real-world impact you can cite.
- Desired outcome — the specific change you want (kill it, delay it, amend a provision).
Output Format
Public comment: [rule / docket]
Re / docket line — the proposal and docket/reference number, and your position in one line.
Who I am & my interest — brief; establishes standing and why your input is relevant.
Summary of position — what you support/oppose/want changed, up front.
Substantive comments — the core. Each point:
- Cites the specific provision (section/paragraph) it addresses,
- Makes the argument with evidence (data, expertise, precedent, real-world consequence),
- Proposes a concrete fix — suggested alternative language or a specific change, not just objection.
Number them so the agency can respond point by point.
Impact — the concrete effect (cost, burden, benefit, unintended consequence) on you/your community — this is what agencies weigh.
Conclusion & request — restate the specific action requested; offer to provide more info.
Quality Checks
Anti-Patterns
Based On
Notice-and-comment rulemaking practice (substantive, provision-specific, evidence-based comments with proposed alternatives).
Example Trigger Phrases
- "Comment on this proposed rule."
- "Respond to this consultation."
- "Submit feedback on a proposed regulation."
- "Write a comment to the agency."
1---2name: public-comment3description: "Draft a persuasive public comment on a proposed rule, regulation, or plan. Use when asked to comment on a rulemaking, respond to a consultation, submit feedback on a proposed regulation, or write a comment to an agency. Produces a structured comment: your position, specific evidence-based arguments tied to the proposal's text, suggested edits, and the impact — the kind agencies must consider on the record."4disable-model-invocation: true # skill-optimizer5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/slipcast-dev/public-comment7---89# Public Comment Skill1011Agencies must review and respond to substantive comments — but only *substantive* ones move the needle. A12comment that cites the specific provision, brings evidence, and proposes concrete alternative language carries13far more weight than "I support/oppose this." This skill drafts that substantive comment.1415## Required Inputs1617Ask for these only if they aren't already provided:1819- **The proposal** — the rule/regulation/plan, ideally the specific sections or docket number.20- **Your position & interest** — support, oppose, or amend; and who you are (individual, business, org — it affects standing/weight).21- **The substance** — your reasons, and any data, expertise, or real-world impact you can cite.22- **Desired outcome** — the specific change you want (kill it, delay it, amend a provision).2324## Output Format2526### Public comment: [rule / docket]2728**Re / docket line** — the proposal and docket/reference number, and your position in one line.2930**Who I am & my interest** — brief; establishes standing and why your input is relevant.3132**Summary of position** — what you support/oppose/want changed, up front.3334**Substantive comments** — the core. Each point:35- **Cites the specific provision** (section/paragraph) it addresses,36- **Makes the argument** with evidence (data, expertise, precedent, real-world consequence),37- **Proposes a concrete fix** — suggested alternative language or a specific change, not just objection.3839Number them so the agency can respond point by point.4041**Impact** — the concrete effect (cost, burden, benefit, unintended consequence) on you/your community — this is what agencies weigh.4243**Conclusion & request** — restate the specific action requested; offer to provide more info.4445## Quality Checks4647- [ ] Each point cites the specific provision it addresses and is on-topic for the proposal48- [ ] Arguments are backed by evidence (data, expertise, precedent, concrete impact) — not just opinion49- [ ] It proposes concrete alternative language/changes, not only objections50- [ ] The real-world impact is made specific51- [ ] Position and the exact requested action are stated clearly up front and at the end5253## Anti-Patterns5455- [ ] Do not submit a bare "I support/oppose" — agencies weigh substance, not vote counts56- [ ] Do not argue in generalities — tie every point to the proposal's actual text57- [ ] Do not just object — propose the specific alternative you want instead58- [ ] Do not omit evidence — unsupported assertions are easy to dismiss on the record59- [ ] Do not go off-topic — comments outside the proposal's scope carry no weight6061## Based On6263Notice-and-comment rulemaking practice (substantive, provision-specific, evidence-based comments with proposed alternatives).6465## Example Trigger Phrases6667- "Comment on this proposed rule."68- "Respond to this consultation."69- "Submit feedback on a proposed regulation."70- "Write a comment to the agency."