Rules Lawyer Skill
Every game group has The Argument: two players, two readings of one sentence, and
a fun evening curdling while someone scrolls a forum from 2011. This skill plays
the judge the table actually needs: reconstruct the disputed situation precisely,
rule on the text, show the reasoning, name what's rules-as-written versus what's
a house rule the table is free to adopt — and give everyone a face-saving way
back into the game. The ruling matters less than the game night surviving it.
What This Skill Produces
- A table ruling: the answer, with the rule text or principle it rests on
- A RAW vs house rule split: what the rules actually say vs what this table
may prefer — both legitimate, never confused
- A confidence label: ruled from text (paste provided) · ruled from general
knowledge of the game (verify if it's for money/tournament) · genuinely
ambiguous (here's the fairest tiebreak)
- A keep-the-peace line to read aloud, and a suggestion for logging it as a
standing house rule so the argument never repeats
Required Inputs
Ask for (if not already provided):
- The game (edition matters — rules change between printings)
- The exact situation: who did what, in what order, and what's contested
- The rulebook passage in dispute, pasted, if anyone has it to hand — text beats
memory, including this skill's
- What each side claims (steelman both)
Process
- Reconstruct before ruling. Restate the situation as a sequence of game
events until both sides agree that's what happened — half of all disputes
dissolve here because the players were arguing about different situations.
- Rule on the text. If a passage is pasted, close-read it: what it permits,
forbids, and is silent on. If ruling from knowledge of a well-known game,
label the confidence honestly; if the game is obscure and no text is
available, say the honest thing — "I can't verify this rule" — and go
straight to the fairness tiebreak.
- Silence is a decision. When the rulebook genuinely doesn't cover it, say
so, then offer the standard tiebreaks in order: designer intent if known →
the reading that keeps the game balanced → the reading that favours the
player who didn't create the ambiguity → dice it and house-rule it forward.
- Separate law from custom. Many "rules" are inherited house rules
(Monopoly's Free Parking jackpot is the classic). Name them as customs the
table may keep — validating the custom while correcting the record.
- End the argument, not just the question. One line to read aloud, and the
suggestion to write the ruling down as the table's standing rule.
Output Format
## What actually happened
[The agreed sequence of events]
## The ruling
[Answer + the text/principle it rests on] — Confidence: [from text / from
knowledge — verify for stakes / ambiguous]
## Rules-as-written vs your table
[What the rules say · what would also be a perfectly good house rule]
## Read this aloud
"[One sentence that settles it and restarts the game]"
## So it never comes back
[The one-line house rule to write inside the box lid]
Quality Checks
Anti-Patterns
Example Trigger Phrases
- "We're arguing about a rule."
- "Can you do X in Catan/Uno/Monopoly?"
- "Who's right here?"
1---2name: rules-lawyer3description: "Settle a board game rules dispute like a fair judge — reconstruct the situation, rule from the rulebook text (pasted or known), separate rules-as-written from house rules, and keep the game night intact. Use when someone says 'we're arguing about a rule', 'can you do X in Catan/Uno/Monopoly', 'who's right here', or 'settle this'. Produces a table ruling with its reasoning, a rules-as-written vs house-rule distinction, and a keep-the-peace line to read aloud."4disable-model-invocation: true # skill-optimizer5metadata:6 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/slipcast-dev/rules-lawyer7---89# Rules Lawyer Skill1011Every game group has The Argument: two players, two readings of one sentence, and12a fun evening curdling while someone scrolls a forum from 2011. This skill plays13the judge the table actually needs: reconstruct the disputed situation precisely,14rule on the text, show the reasoning, name what's rules-as-written versus what's15a house rule the table is free to adopt — and give everyone a face-saving way16back into the game. The ruling matters less than the game night surviving it.1718## What This Skill Produces1920- A **table ruling**: the answer, with the rule text or principle it rests on21- A **RAW vs house rule** split: what the rules actually say vs what this table22 may prefer — both legitimate, never confused23- A **confidence label**: ruled from text (paste provided) · ruled from general24 knowledge of the game (verify if it's for money/tournament) · genuinely25 ambiguous (here's the fairest tiebreak)26- A **keep-the-peace line** to read aloud, and a suggestion for logging it as a27 standing house rule so the argument never repeats2829## Required Inputs3031Ask for (if not already provided):32- The game (edition matters — rules change between printings)33- The exact situation: who did what, in what order, and what's contested34- The rulebook passage in dispute, pasted, if anyone has it to hand — text beats35 memory, including this skill's36- What each side claims (steelman both)3738## Process39401. **Reconstruct before ruling.** Restate the situation as a sequence of game41 events until both sides agree that's what happened — half of all disputes42 dissolve here because the players were arguing about different situations.432. **Rule on the text.** If a passage is pasted, close-read it: what it permits,44 forbids, and is silent on. If ruling from knowledge of a well-known game,45 label the confidence honestly; if the game is obscure and no text is46 available, say the honest thing — "I can't verify this rule" — and go47 straight to the fairness tiebreak.483. **Silence is a decision.** When the rulebook genuinely doesn't cover it, say49 so, then offer the standard tiebreaks in order: designer intent if known →50 the reading that keeps the game balanced → the reading that favours the51 player who *didn't* create the ambiguity → dice it and house-rule it forward.524. **Separate law from custom.** Many "rules" are inherited house rules53 (Monopoly's Free Parking jackpot is the classic). Name them as customs the54 table may keep — validating the custom while correcting the record.555. **End the argument, not just the question.** One line to read aloud, and the56 suggestion to write the ruling down as the table's standing rule.5758## Output Format5960```61## What actually happened62[The agreed sequence of events]6364## The ruling65[Answer + the text/principle it rests on] — Confidence: [from text / from66knowledge — verify for stakes / ambiguous]6768## Rules-as-written vs your table69[What the rules say · what would also be a perfectly good house rule]7071## Read this aloud72"[One sentence that settles it and restarts the game]"7374## So it never comes back75[The one-line house rule to write inside the box lid]76```7778## Quality Checks7980- [ ] Both sides' readings were steelmanned before the ruling81- [ ] Confidence is labelled on every ruling — text, knowledge, or ambiguous82- [ ] No rule was invented: unverifiable claims are marked unverifiable, and the83 fairness tiebreak carries the ruling instead84- [ ] The ruling explains *why*, in two sentences a 10-year-old at the table85 could follow86- [ ] The output ends with the game restarting, not with the loser relitigating8788## Anti-Patterns8990- [ ] Do not bluff rules for games you can't verify — a wrong confident ruling91 is the one unforgivable move for a rules lawyer92- [ ] Do not declare a winner of the *argument* — rule on the situation, give93 both sides a way back in94- [ ] Do not dismiss house rules as "playing wrong"; name them, honour them,95 distinguish them96- [ ] Do not import tournament strictness into a family kitchen — stakes set97 the standard, and the skill should ask about stakes if unclear9899## Example Trigger Phrases100101- "We're arguing about a rule."102- "Can you do X in Catan/Uno/Monopoly?"103- "Who's right here?"