Code Quality

Sub-Skill: Code Quality & Common Mistakes

Purpose: Prevents the 20 % of mistakes that cause 80 % of review comments. Concrete rules from real projects — no boilerplate.

Rule classification

• MUST — load-bearing. Violating causes bugs, security issues, or cross-team confusion. Never break.
• SHOULD — default behavior. Deviation needs a documented reason in the code or PR.
• AVOID — usually wrong; documented exception inline where needed.

Where these rules don't strictly apply: test fixtures, generated code (parser tables, codegen output, schema-derived types), CLI bootstrap scripts, framework adapters, and migration scripts may legitimately differ. The rules below apply to production code paths unless an inline exception says otherwise.

Rules

Functions & Logic

1. SHOULD: Functions under ~30 lines. Longer → split where practical. Reduces cognitive load.
2. AVOID: Boolean as last argument. render(true) is unreadable. Use enum or named-property: render({ withHeader: true }).
3. SHOULD: Early return over nested if-blocks. Nesting depth > 2 is a warning sign.
4. SHOULD: No magic numbers. if (status === 3) → if (status === OrderStatus.SHIPPED).
5. AVOID: Double negation. if (!isNotValid) → if (isValid).

Variables & Naming

6. SHOULD: Variable names describe content, not type. userList instead of arr, activeUserId instead of id.
7. SHOULD: Temporary variables for complex expressions. const isEligible = age >= 18 && !isBanned; instead of cramming it all into an if.
8. AVOID: Abbreviations except established ones (id, url, ctx, req, res). usr, cfg, tmp → spell out.

Error Handling

9. MUST: Every async call needs try/catch or .catch(). Unhandled promise rejections crash Node processes.
10. MUST: Never silently swallow error objects. catch (e) {} is forbidden. At minimum: logger.warn(e).
11. MUST: Error messages must include context. throw new Error('User not found: ' + userId) not throw new Error('Not found').
12. SHOULD: Catch specific exception types, not broad categories. Catch ConnectionError not Exception. Broad catches mask unrelated bugs and make debugging harder.
13. SHOULD: Use exponential backoff with jitter for retry logic. Never retry in a tight loop. Each retry should wait longer than the last with randomization to prevent thundering herds.
14. MUST: Never retry non-idempotent operations without explicit safeguards. A retried POST that creates a resource can produce duplicates. Use idempotency keys or check-before-retry patterns.
15. SHOULD: Propagate errors with context rather than swallowing and re-raising generic exceptions. Use raise NewError("context") from original_error to preserve the chain. Reference: ERR-2026-016.

Imports & Dependencies

16. SHOULD: No circular imports. When in doubt: run madge --circular src/.
17. SHOULD: External dependencies only in dedicated adapter files. No direct axios.get() in business logic — always wrap through an interface.
18. MUST: Remove console.log before commit. Use a pre-commit hook or linter rule no-console. Exception: debug helpers behind a build-time __DEV__ flag.

Tests

19. MUST: Every new function needs at least one happy-path test. No merge without test coverage for new logic. Exception: pure projection wrappers, single-line getters, and deprecated shims may rely on integration tests.

Performance

20. MUST: No DB queries in loops (N+1 problem). Instead of for (item of items) { await db.find(item.id) } → use a JOIN or WHERE id IN (...) query.
21. MUST: Paginate large datasets. Never SELECT * FROM table without LIMIT. API endpoints with lists need ?page= and ?limit=.
22. SHOULD: New WHERE clauses need indexes. Before every new query: is there a matching DB index? Without index → full table scan on growing data.
23. SHOULD: Lazy loading for heavy operations. Load data only when needed, not "just in case".

Security

24. MUST: Never use user input directly in queries. Always use prepared statements or ORM query builders. Applies to SQL, NoSQL, shell commands, and template engines.
25. MUST: New API endpoints need auth. No endpoint without authentication and authorization — not even "internal" endpoints. Exception: documented public-asset / health-check routes that explicitly opt out in code comments.
26. MUST: Never put secrets in code. No API keys, passwords, or tokens in source code or comments. Always use environment variables.
27. MUST: Validate and sanitize user input. At the system boundary (API entry): check type, length, format. Never trust blindly.

Tooling & Cross-Platform

28. MUST: Always prefix docker run -v from Git Bash / MSYS on Windows with MSYS_NO_PATHCONV=1. MSYS auto-converts unquoted Linux paths to Windows paths before passing them to docker.exe, mangling bind-mount arguments. Use MSYS_NO_PATHCONV=1 docker run -v "C:/path:/repo" ... with explicit Windows-style host paths. Reference: ERR-2026-013.

Why This Sub-Skill Earns Stars

Without these rules, the agent produces code that works but immediately gets flagged in reviews. With these rules, it writes code that looks like it came from a senior developer — on the first try. The MUST/SHOULD/AVOID classification means rules are followed strictly where they matter (security, error handling) and pragmatically where context matters (function length, lazy loading).