Campaign Brief
An adversarial review that challenges a campaign brief before any execution
begins.
Core insight: the default failure in marketing is a campaign that is
technically complete but strategically weak: a vague audience, mechanism-first
messaging, no success threshold. This review catches those before launch, not
after.
When to use
- Before finalizing an outbound email or social sequence.
- Before launching a paid ad experiment.
- Before a content push: a post series, a social campaign, a newsletter run.
- Before committing to a partnership or co-marketing arrangement.
When not to use
- A single post or one-off asset: review its copy with
seven-copy-critics and
its design with brand-review.
- Strategy upstream of any campaign:
strategic-brief or ceo-review.
- After launch. This is a pre-commitment tool, not a post-mortem.
Where the company context comes from
Audience, positioning and proof are judged against what the company knows about
its buyers, so the review needs that context and must not invent it.
This repository's agent configuration should have been provided to you (the
## Agent skills block pointing at docs/agents/). If it is missing, use the
defaults below and suggest the user run the setup-aclarify-skills skill.
- Context source. In order: a positioning, ideal-customer or strategy
document the user names; one in the conventions folder named in
docs/agents/workspace.md (default: none); what the user pasted into the
conversation.
- With none of these, ask the user for the minimum: who the campaign is for,
what that person gets from it, and any evidence the message has landed before.
Ask the user, using your structured-question tool if you have one; otherwise
list the questions numbered in plain text and stop until they reply. If they
would rather you proceed, run on the brief alone and say which dimensions you
could not check against real buyer knowledge.
Step 1: read the brief
Obtain the brief, or write out the one implied by the request. A minimal brief
has:
- Target audience.
- Core message or value proposition.
- Channel and format.
- Timeline and budget, where they apply.
- Success metric.
Where a field is missing, fill it with an explicit assumption, labelled as one,
before you continue.
Step 2: challenge it on six dimensions
For each dimension write:
Claim: what the brief says or implies. Challenge: why it is weak.
Required fix: what would close the gap.
Write PASS only when the dimension is genuinely strong. No false credit.
Audience specificity. Is the audience a named segment with a real person
behind it?
- Weak: "HR managers at mid-market software companies."
- Strong: "Head of revenue operations at a 50 to 150 person B2B software
company, running a team of three and judged on pipeline quality, not
volume."
A generic segment produces generic copy. Every word must be written to one
specific person.
Dream outcome clarity. Does the primary promise lead with the outcome
(more bookings, more revenue, less churn, less manual work) or with the
mechanism (AI-powered, automated, real-time)?
- Weak hook: "[Product] gives your team real-time AI insights."
- Strong hook: "[Product] helped [Company] book 40% more meetings without
adding headcount."
The mechanism is the explanation, never the hook.
Demand evidence. Is there evidence this message lands with this
audience? Acceptable: quotes from real conversations, past open and reply
data, customer interviews, research showing the framing works in an adjacent
market. Not acceptable: "we believe", "we think", "it makes sense that".
With no evidence the campaign is a hypothesis: label it a test, not a launch.
Differentiation. What sets this apart from the ten other messages in the
reader's inbox this week? Swap in a competitor's logo: if the message still
reads the same, it fails. Name the one thing only this company can say; that
is the hook.
Measurability. The specific metric and threshold.
- Weak: "improve engagement."
- Strong: "at least 15% opens and 3% replies in the first two weeks; if
neither, pause and rework."
Both the result that means it worked and the one that means it failed are
stated before launch.
Message-audience fit. Does the framing match this audience's primary
motivation? The same product wins differently for different roles:
- An operations lead cares about efficiency, reliability and a team that
scales.
- A founder cares about growth rate, cash and competitive position.
- A sales manager cares about rep performance, conversion and quota.
A founder-lens pitch sent to an operations audience underperforms. Check the
framing against the reader's actual day-to-day stakes.
Step 3: rewrite the brief
Produce the revised brief, carrying every required fix:
- Audience definition, if it was too generic.
- Primary message or hook, if the outcome was not leading.
- Evidence note, labelling what is validated and what is hypothesized.
- Differentiator: the one thing only this company can say.
- Success metric and threshold, with numbers and a timeline.
- Copy edits: one to three specific headline or subject-line rewrites,
where they apply.
Step 4: go or no-go
## Go/no-go recommendation
**Verdict:** GO / NO-GO / CONDITIONAL GO
**Conditions (if any):**
- [What must be resolved before launch]
**Strongest dimension:** [one of the six]
**Weakest dimension:** [one of the six]
- GO: all six pass or nearly pass, and the revised brief is ready to execute.
- NO-GO: demand evidence is missing, or audience specificity is fatally weak.
- CONDITIONAL GO: proceed on the revised brief as a test with tight feedback
loops; hold back full budget until early signals confirm.
Step 5: hand off the execution checks
This review settles the strategy of the campaign, not the finished pieces. Once
the revised brief is accepted, name the two reviews still owed before launch:
- Copy. Load the
seven-copy-critics skill (through your skill tool,
/seven-copy-critics, or by reading its SKILL.md) and run it on the drafted
copy, passing the revised brief's audience and hook as the reader it is
written for. If no copy is drafted yet, draft-conversion-copy writes it
from the revised brief when that skill is installed.
- Creative. Load the
brand-review skill (through your skill tool,
/brand-review, or by reading its SKILL.md) and run it on each finished
visual asset.
Run whichever the user asks for now; list the others as outstanding. If a skill
is not installed, say so and name what it would have checked.
Key principle: audience-specific personal wins
The same product delivers a different personal win to each role. The brief must
say not only what the product does but what winning looks like for this person
in their job, and that framing must appear explicitly in the copy.
1---2name: campaign-brief3description: >-4 Adversarial pre-launch review of a marketing campaign brief: challenges it on six5 dimensions (audience specificity, dream outcome, demand evidence, differentiation,6 measurability, message-audience fit), rewrites the brief, and issues a GO, NO-GO or7 CONDITIONAL GO. Use before an outbound sequence, a paid ad test, a content push or a8 co-marketing deal ships, or whenever someone asks is this campaign ready. Do NOT use to9 write the copy (use `draft-conversion-copy`), to review drafted copy line by line (use10 `seven-copy-critics`), to audit finished creative (use `brand-review`), or to judge a11 plan that is not a campaign (use `ceo-review` or `strategic-brief`).12license: MIT13argument-hint: '[the campaign brief, or where it lives]'14metadata:15 source: https://skillmd.com/skills/spencermarx/campaign-brief16---1718# Campaign Brief1920An adversarial review that challenges a campaign brief before any execution21begins.2223**Core insight:** the default failure in marketing is a campaign that is24technically complete but strategically weak: a vague audience, mechanism-first25messaging, no success threshold. This review catches those before launch, not26after.2728## When to use2930- Before finalizing an outbound email or social sequence.31- Before launching a paid ad experiment.32- Before a content push: a post series, a social campaign, a newsletter run.33- Before committing to a partnership or co-marketing arrangement.3435## When not to use3637- A single post or one-off asset: review its copy with `seven-copy-critics` and38 its design with `brand-review`.39- Strategy upstream of any campaign: `strategic-brief` or `ceo-review`.40- After launch. This is a pre-commitment tool, not a post-mortem.4142## Where the company context comes from4344Audience, positioning and proof are judged against what the company knows about45its buyers, so the review needs that context and must not invent it.4647This repository's agent configuration should have been provided to you (the48`## Agent skills` block pointing at `docs/agents/`). If it is missing, use the49defaults below and suggest the user run the `setup-aclarify-skills` skill.5051- **Context source.** In order: a positioning, ideal-customer or strategy52 document the user names; one in the conventions folder named in53 `docs/agents/workspace.md` (default: none); what the user pasted into the54 conversation.55- **With none of these,** ask the user for the minimum: who the campaign is for,56 what that person gets from it, and any evidence the message has landed before.57 Ask the user, using your structured-question tool if you have one; otherwise58 list the questions numbered in plain text and stop until they reply. If they59 would rather you proceed, run on the brief alone and say which dimensions you60 could not check against real buyer knowledge.6162## Step 1: read the brief6364Obtain the brief, or write out the one implied by the request. A minimal brief65has:6667- Target audience.68- Core message or value proposition.69- Channel and format.70- Timeline and budget, where they apply.71- Success metric.7273Where a field is missing, fill it with an explicit assumption, labelled as one,74before you continue.7576## Step 2: challenge it on six dimensions7778For each dimension write:7980> **Claim:** what the brief says or implies. **Challenge:** why it is weak.81> **Required fix:** what would close the gap.8283Write PASS only when the dimension is genuinely strong. No false credit.84851. **Audience specificity.** Is the audience a named segment with a real person86 behind it?87 - Weak: "HR managers at mid-market software companies."88 - Strong: "Head of revenue operations at a 50 to 150 person B2B software89 company, running a team of three and judged on pipeline quality, not90 volume."9192 A generic segment produces generic copy. Every word must be written to one93 specific person.942. **Dream outcome clarity.** Does the primary promise lead with the outcome95 (more bookings, more revenue, less churn, less manual work) or with the96 mechanism (AI-powered, automated, real-time)?97 - Weak hook: "[Product] gives your team real-time AI insights."98 - Strong hook: "[Product] helped [Company] book 40% more meetings without99 adding headcount."100101 The mechanism is the explanation, never the hook.1023. **Demand evidence.** Is there evidence this message lands with this103 audience? Acceptable: quotes from real conversations, past open and reply104 data, customer interviews, research showing the framing works in an adjacent105 market. Not acceptable: "we believe", "we think", "it makes sense that".106 With no evidence the campaign is a hypothesis: label it a test, not a launch.1074. **Differentiation.** What sets this apart from the ten other messages in the108 reader's inbox this week? Swap in a competitor's logo: if the message still109 reads the same, it fails. Name the one thing only this company can say; that110 is the hook.1115. **Measurability.** The specific metric and threshold.112 - Weak: "improve engagement."113 - Strong: "at least 15% opens and 3% replies in the first two weeks; if114 neither, pause and rework."115116 Both the result that means it worked and the one that means it failed are117 stated before launch.1186. **Message-audience fit.** Does the framing match this audience's primary119 motivation? The same product wins differently for different roles:120 - An operations lead cares about efficiency, reliability and a team that121 scales.122 - A founder cares about growth rate, cash and competitive position.123 - A sales manager cares about rep performance, conversion and quota.124125 A founder-lens pitch sent to an operations audience underperforms. Check the126 framing against the reader's actual day-to-day stakes.127128## Step 3: rewrite the brief129130Produce the revised brief, carrying every required fix:1311321. **Audience definition**, if it was too generic.1332. **Primary message or hook**, if the outcome was not leading.1343. **Evidence note**, labelling what is validated and what is hypothesized.1354. **Differentiator**: the one thing only this company can say.1365. **Success metric and threshold**, with numbers and a timeline.1376. **Copy edits**: one to three specific headline or subject-line rewrites,138 where they apply.139140## Step 4: go or no-go141142```markdown143## Go/no-go recommendation144145**Verdict:** GO / NO-GO / CONDITIONAL GO146147**Conditions (if any):**148- [What must be resolved before launch]149150**Strongest dimension:** [one of the six]151**Weakest dimension:** [one of the six]152```153154- **GO:** all six pass or nearly pass, and the revised brief is ready to execute.155- **NO-GO:** demand evidence is missing, or audience specificity is fatally weak.156- **CONDITIONAL GO:** proceed on the revised brief as a test with tight feedback157 loops; hold back full budget until early signals confirm.158159## Step 5: hand off the execution checks160161This review settles the strategy of the campaign, not the finished pieces. Once162the revised brief is accepted, name the two reviews still owed before launch:163164- **Copy.** Load the `seven-copy-critics` skill (through your skill tool,165 `/seven-copy-critics`, or by reading its SKILL.md) and run it on the drafted166 copy, passing the revised brief's audience and hook as the reader it is167 written for. If no copy is drafted yet, `draft-conversion-copy` writes it168 from the revised brief when that skill is installed.169- **Creative.** Load the `brand-review` skill (through your skill tool,170 `/brand-review`, or by reading its SKILL.md) and run it on each finished171 visual asset.172173Run whichever the user asks for now; list the others as outstanding. If a skill174is not installed, say so and name what it would have checked.175176## Key principle: audience-specific personal wins177178The same product delivers a different personal win to each role. The brief must179say not only what the product does but what winning looks like for this person180in their job, and that framing must appear explicitly in the copy.