Record Structured Deliberation

Structure a multi-participant deliberation and record a decision-ready result — options, strongest reasons, dissent, and the named owner's next action. Use when several perspectives, competing proposals, or material objections need a fair synthesis. Do not use for a single-analyst critique or a domain go/no-go review.

SylphxAI 71e908c 1.1 KB Updated

File contents

Record Structured Deliberation

Consensus is not a decision. Collect initial positions independently when hierarchy or early anchoring would shrink the option set. Normalize each proposal into claim, assumptions, strongest reasons, and tradeoffs. Run one focused challenge round on the claims that would actually change the action.

Hand selection to the named decision owner. Record stable dissent instead of erasing it. Use the team's existing decision record; do not invent a second ledger.

Use analyze-critically for a single-analyst challenge. Use review-domain for subject-specific assessment criteria. Use optimize-decision-model when the choice is a constrained allocation rather than a reasoned selection.

SylphxAI/skills/tree/main/skills/record-structured-deliberation commit 71e908cc64

Frequently asked questions

npx skillmds@latest add sylphxai/record-structured-deliberation