Peer Review

Reviews a manuscript, proposal, analysis or result the way a careful referee does, reading the whole artifact, checking the methods against the claims, the statistics against the design, the figures against the numbers, and reporting BLOCKING issues separately from observations, with a calibrated recommendation. Use for peer review, critical appraisal of a paper or claim, pre-submission review of the user's own draft, grant review, or evaluating research rigor. For fixing the text afterwards use paper-writing; for an independent second opinion delegate a read to an explore worker.

synthetic-sciences Updated 4.4k repo stars
An OpenScience session comparing EGFR inhibitor potency: the trace shows the search, the written files, the analysis run and the answer with a results table

File contents

synthetic-sciences/openscience commit 04fa74f64d

Frequently asked questions

npx get-skill add synthetic-sciences/peer-review