Make Groups

Implementation Group Decomposition Skill

Break a large document — architecture proposal, feature spec, migration plan, or requirements set — into self-contained implementation groups ordered for sequential execution through the make-plan pipeline.

When to Use

• User says "make groups", "group requirements", "sequence groups", "decompose into groups"
• User has a large document with many requirements/features that must be implemented incrementally
• User wants to feed groups one at a time through /autoskillit:make-plan

Core Principles

• Groups are implementation units, not categories. Each group must be independently plannable and implementable. A group produces a working, testable increment.
• Requirements travel with their group. Every requirement from the source document must appear in exactly one group, referenced by its original ID. No requirement is dropped or split.
• Dependency order is the sequencing rule. Group A's output is available when Group B starts. Order by what produces foundations first, consumers last.
• Source material is unverified input. Verify claims about the codebase against subagent findings before incorporating them into grouping decisions.

GitHub Issue Input

If the ARGUMENTS contain a GitHub issue reference, call fetch_github_issue via the MCP tool before beginning any analysis. Use the returned content field as the task description.

Detection — scan ARGUMENTS for any of these patterns:

• Full URL: https://github.com/{owner}/{repo}/issues/{N} (e.g. https://github.com/acme/project/issues/42)
• Shorthand: {owner}/{repo}#{N} (e.g. acme/project#42)
• Bare number with default repo: #N or N when github.default_repo is configured
• Orchestrator hint line: a line containing GitHub Issue: followed by a URL or shorthand

Behavior:

• If the entire ARGUMENTS is an issue reference → call fetch_github_issue and use the returned content as the complete task description.
• If ARGUMENTS contains a trailing GitHub Issue: {url} line (added by the pipeline orchestrator) → call fetch_github_issue for that URL and append the returned content as supplementary context appended after the task description.
• Call with include_comments: true for full context.
• If fetch_github_issue returns success: false, log the failure and proceed with the raw ARGUMENTS as-is.

Critical Constraints

NEVER:

• Modify any source code files
• Create files outside {{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/ directory
• Drop, split, or rewrite requirements — reference them by original ID
• Create groups that cannot be independently planned
• Include implementation steps or technical approach in the group descriptions
• Run subagents in the background (run_in_background: true is prohibited)

ALWAYS:

• Use subagents to verify codebase structure before finalizing groups
• Use model: "sonnet" when spawning all subagents via the Task tool
• Include every requirement from the source document in exactly one group
• Assign each group a sequential suffix: groupA, groupB, ... groupZ
• State dependencies between groups explicitly
• Write to {{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/ directory (relative to the current working directory)
• After writing the groups file and manifest, emit the absolute paths as structured output tokens as your final output. Resolve the relative {{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/... save paths to absolute by prepending the full CWD:

  groups_path = /absolute/cwd/{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/{groups_filename}.md
  manifest_path = /absolute/cwd/{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/{manifest_filename}.json
  group_files = /absolute/cwd/{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/{groups_filename}.md
  

  These tokens are MANDATORY — the pipeline cannot proceed without them.

Workflow

Step 1: Read the Source Document

Read the full document. Inventory every requirement (REQ-*), feature, and deliverable. Build a raw list with original IDs preserved.

Step 2: Verify Against Codebase

Launch parallel Explore subagents to understand:

• What exists today that the requirements relate to
• Module boundaries and dependency directions
• Which components are foundational vs. consumers

Step 3: Form Groups

Cluster requirements into groups. Each group must:

1. Be independently plannable — someone could take this group to /autoskillit:make-plan without needing other groups implemented first (except declared dependencies)
2. Produce a working increment — after implementation, the system is in a valid state
3. Contain all related requirements — no requirement is orphaned or deferred

Name each group with a short descriptive label and assign suffix groupA through groupZ in implementation order.

Step 4: Order by Dependency

Sort groups so that each group's dependencies are satisfied by earlier groups. Document the dependency chain explicitly.

Step 5: Write the Groups Documents

Produce three outputs in {{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/:

5a. Index file (consolidated): groups_{topic}_{YYYY-MM-DD_HHMMSS}.md

# Implementation Groups: {Topic}

**Date:** {YYYY-MM-DD}
**Source:** {Document path or description}
**Groups:** {count}

## Per-Group Files

- `groupA_{topic}_{ts}.md`
- `groupB_{topic}_{ts}.md`
- ...

## Manifest

`manifest_{topic}_{ts}.json`

## Dependency Chain

{group_id} → {group_id} → ... (linear or DAG as needed)

---

## {Group Label} (groupA)

### Purpose
{What this group delivers and why it comes at this position in the sequence}

### Dependencies
{None, or list of group IDs that must be complete first}

### Requirements
- **REQ-XXX-001:** {Original requirement text}
- **REQ-XXX-002:** {Original requirement text}
- ...

### Planning Context
{What make-plan needs to know: affected modules, key interfaces, constraints. Factual only — no prescribed approach.}

---

## {Group Label} (groupB)

{Same structure}

---

{Repeat for each group}

## Traceability

| Requirement | Group |
|-------------|-------|
| REQ-XXX-001 | groupA |
| REQ-XXX-002 | groupA |
| REQ-YYY-001 | groupB |
| ... | ... |

5b. Per-group files: groupA_{topic}_{ts}.md, groupB_{topic}_{ts}.md, etc.

Each per-group file contains the group's section extracted from the index — one self-contained file per group for pipeline consumption:

# {Group Label} (groupA)

## Purpose
{What this group delivers}

## Dependencies
{None, or list of group IDs}

## Requirements
- **REQ-XXX-001:** {text}
- **REQ-XXX-002:** {text}

## Planning Context
{What make-plan needs to know}

5c. Manifest file: manifest_{topic}_{ts}.json

Machine-readable manifest for pipeline orchestration:

{
    "topic": "{topic}",
    "date": "{YYYY-MM-DD}",
    "source": "{document path}",
    "group_count": 7,
    "dependency_chain": ["groupA", "groupB", "groupC"],
    "groups": [
        {
            "id": "groupA",
            "label": "{Group Label}",
            "file": "groupA_{topic}_{ts}.md",
            "dependencies": [],
            "requirements": ["REQ-XXX-001", "REQ-XXX-002"]
        }
    ],
    "index_file": "groups_{topic}_{ts}.md"
}

Step 6: Verify Completeness

Before finalizing, check:

• Every requirement from the source document appears in the traceability table
• No requirement appears in more than one group
• No group depends on a group that comes after it in the sequence
• Each group is self-contained enough to be a /autoskillit:make-plan input
• Per-group file count matches group count in manifest
• All per-group files are written to disk

Report to terminal: index file path, manifest file path, per-group file count, and the dependency chain.

After all group files are written and the prose report is printed, emit the following structured output tokens as the very last lines of your text output:

IMPORTANT: Emit the structured output tokens as literal plain text with no markdown formatting on the token names. Do not wrap token names in **bold**, *italic*, or any other markdown. The adjudicator performs a regex match on the exact token name — decorators cause match failure.

groups_path = {absolute_path_to_index_file}
manifest_path = {absolute_path_to_manifest_file}
group_files = {absolute_path_to_group_1_file}
{absolute_path_to_group_2_file}
{absolute_path_to_group_3_file}

The first path follows the key on the same line; subsequent per-group file paths appear on their own lines (this multi-line list format is consumed by capture_list: in the orchestrating recipe). List every per-group file in implementation order.

Output Location

{{AUTOSKILLIT_TEMP}}/make-groups/
├── groups_{topic}_{ts}.md           # Consolidated index (all groups)
├── manifest_{topic}_{ts}.json       # Machine-readable manifest
├── groupA_{topic}_{ts}.md           # Individual per-group file
├── groupB_{topic}_{ts}.md
└── ...

Feature Branch Recommendation

When implementing multiple groups from this skill's output, always work on a feature branch, not directly on main. Group implementations take multiple plan-implement-merge cycles and should not land on the base branch until the full set is audited.

After make-groups completes, create a feature branch before starting the pipeline:

git checkout -b feature/{topic}

Then run each group through the pipeline using the feature branch as base_branch for all merge_worktree calls. The /autoskillit:audit-impl skill accepts the manifest as input and audits all groups at once as the final gate before merging the feature branch to develop.

Use the group-implementation bundled workflow to automate this — it creates the feature branch, runs the group loop, and gates on audit before signalling merge-ready.

Related Skills

• /autoskillit:make-req — Produces requirements from raw input (this skill groups existing requirements)
• /autoskillit:make-plan — Consumes individual groups as planning input
• /autoskillit:elaborate-phase — Elaborates phases within a plan (this skill creates the groups that become plans)
• /autoskillit:dry-walkthrough — Validates plans produced from groups
• /autoskillit:audit-impl — Audits the full implementation against all group plans