Design Critique
Use design-taste for the project's visual and product standards. Review the
actual surface at the user's viewport, not a component screenshot alone.
- Name the user decision the surface should improve and what evidence makes that decision better. If the surface is a graph, trace a visible relationship to its sources, confidence, competing explanations, and an actionable workflow. A decorative graph without this path is not complete.
- Walk the primary task, its failure state, settings, navigation, and return path. Test keyboard access, focus order, contrast, motion preferences, and small screens.
- Rank findings by user consequence and cite the exact screen or interaction. Separate observed defects from taste judgments and unknowns.
- Implement the smallest coherent correction in the intended repository. Revisit the live surface after the change; capture evidence for each fixed high-severity finding.
Do not label static animation as capability. Motion should show state or causality and stop or simplify when reduced motion is requested.