thedixitjain English econ / business journal workflow (en-journal-workflow)
Purpose
This is the routing skill. It does not replace a single-journal profile; it first classifies the manuscript by discipline, contribution type, method shape, and audience, then routes into the matching per-journal skill for fit and re-framing.
Resources to Load When Needed
- If the venue is unclear, read
../../resources/worked-examples/venue-routing.mdbefore choosing a target. - If two sibling fields look plausible, read
../../resources/exemplars/selection-patterns.md. - Before submission-ready advice, use
../../resources/official-source-map.mdto open the current official author instructions for the chosen journal.
Ask four things first
- Contribution type: new identification / causal effect, new theory or model, new measurement or method, new fact/anomaly, or integrative review?
- Method shape: reduced-form causal, structural, pure theory/proof, econometric method, lab/field experiment, survey/SEM, qualitative/inductive, optimization/analytics, or design-science?
- Discipline audience: general economics, a specific econ field, finance, accounting, strategy/OB/management, marketing, operations, or information systems?
- Submission goal: swing for a top-5 / top-3 / elite-list venue, or optimize topic–venue fit and review odds at a strong field journal?
Quick routing
| Manuscript signature | Prefer skill |
|---|---|
| General-interest econ, top-5 ambition | american-economic-review / quarterly-journal-of-economics / journal-of-political-economy |
| Theorem / new estimator with proofs | econometrica / journal-of-economic-theory / econometric-theory |
| Strong applied micro, narrower than top-5 | aej-applied-economics / review-of-economics-and-statistics / journal-of-human-resources |
| Macro / growth / dynamics | aej-macroeconomics / journal-of-monetary-economics / review-of-economic-dynamics / journal-of-economic-growth |
| Micro theory / mechanism / games | aej-microeconomics / journal-of-economic-theory / games-and-economic-behavior |
| Policy-facing applied economics | aej-economic-policy / journal-of-public-economics / economic-policy |
| Trade / open economy / development | journal-of-international-economics / journal-of-development-economics / world-development |
| Econometric methods / applied econometrics | journal-of-econometrics / journal-of-applied-econometrics / journal-of-business-and-economic-statistics / quantitative-economics |
| Field econ (labor/health/urban/enviro/law) | journal-of-labor-economics / journal-of-health-economics / journal-of-urban-economics / journal-of-environmental-economics-and-management / journal-of-law-and-economics |
| Finance, top-3 ambition | journal-of-finance / journal-of-financial-economics / review-of-financial-studies |
| Finance, elite field | review-of-finance / journal-of-financial-and-quantitative-analysis / journal-of-financial-intermediation / journal-of-corporate-finance |
| Banking / markets / international finance | journal-of-banking-and-finance / journal-of-financial-markets / journal-of-international-money-and-finance / journal-of-empirical-finance |
| Management theory (no data) | academy-of-management-review / academy-of-management-annals |
| Management empirics, theory-driven | academy-of-management-journal / journal-of-management-en / journal-of-management-studies |
| Strategy / firm performance | strategic-management-journal / organization-science |
| Org theory / sociology of orgs / qualitative | organization-studies / human-relations / administrative-science-quarterly |
| HRM / international business / innovation | human-resource-management / journal-of-international-business-studies / research-policy |
| Entrepreneurship | journal-of-business-venturing / entrepreneurship-theory-and-practice |
| Marketing modeling vs. behavior | marketing-science / journal-of-marketing-research vs journal-of-consumer-research / journal-of-consumer-psychology |
| Marketing strategy / broad | journal-of-marketing / journal-of-the-academy-of-marketing-science |
| Accounting (archival/analytical/markets) | the-accounting-review / journal-of-accounting-research / journal-of-accounting-and-economics / review-of-accounting-studies |
| Accounting (interpretive/critical) | accounting-organizations-and-society / contemporary-accounting-research |
| OM / OR / analytics | management-science / operations-research / manufacturing-and-service-operations-management / production-and-operations-management / journal-of-operations-management |
| Information systems | mis-quarterly / information-systems-research / journal-of-management-information-systems / journal-of-the-association-for-information-systems / informs-journal-on-computing |
Sibling-Journal Disambiguation
| Confusable targets | Decision rule |
|---|---|
| AER/QJE/JPE vs field journals | Use a top-5 only when the paper changes a broad economics conversation; strong identification alone is not enough. |
| JF/JFE/RFS vs finance field journals | Decide whether the contribution is asset pricing, corporate finance, intermediation, microstructure, or international finance before choosing prestige tier. |
| AMR vs AMJ vs ASQ | AMR is theory-only; AMJ is empirical theory-building; ASQ expects organization-theory depth and often sociological leverage. |
| JM vs JMR vs Marketing Science | JM is strategy/managerial broad contribution; JMR is empirical/methodological marketing research; Marketing Science expects modeling, optimization, or quantitative marketing depth. |
| MISQ/ISR vs CS venues | Use IS journals only when the information-systems theory or organizational technology contribution is central; route pure algorithms to CS/AI. |
Decision rules
- Correlation without identification or mechanism: fix the contribution before swinging for a top-5/top-3 venue.
- "First to study X in context Y" is not a contribution at elite venues — name the conceptual or methodological advance, or route to a field journal.
- A new factor / anomaly without multiple-testing and out-of-sample discipline is not a finance top-3 paper.
- Management empirics with no theoretical contribution belong below AMJ/AMR, or need reframing.
- A modeling/optimization paper with no managerial-theory payoff routes to OM/OR/IS analytics venues, not to AMJ.
- Always enter the single-journal skill's official-submission checklist before submitting; never rely on a stale template.
Output format
[Top journal skill] <skill-name>
[Alt 1] <skill-name> (reason)
[Alt 2] <skill-name> (reason)
[Do not submit to] <journal> (one-line mismatch reason)
[Biggest current gap] topic / theory / identification / mechanism / formatting / official requirements
[Next step] invoke <skill-name> for single-venue fit and re-framing
Source: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills → English-SocialScience-Journal-Skills/skills/en-journal-workflow/SKILL.md