Est Submission

Submission Preflight (est-submission)

The last check before pressing submit on the ACS Publishing Center (peer-review environment: ACS Paragon Plus). The most common avoidable failures at ES&T are a missing TOC graphic, an over-limit word count, or an absent data-availability statement. Verify volatile specifics on the official page before relying on them.

When to trigger

• "Submitting tomorrow" — last pass before upload
• Unsure which files/metadata the ACS submission system expects
• Confirming the article type's caps are met and the TOC graphic + SI are ready

Process facts (verify volatile items on the official page)

• Publisher: American Chemical Society (ACS).
• Portal: ACS Publishing Center / ACS Paragon Plus (confirm current entry URL — 待核实).
• Article types & caps (待核实 on exact numbers): Research Article 7,000; Feature ~5,000; Review (Critical Review) ~10,000; Perspective ~4,000; Policy Analysis ~7,000; Viewpoint ~1,000 (+≤5 refs); Letter to the Editor ~500. Figures/tables may count as word-equivalents (300/600 — 待核实).
• TOC graphic: required for Research Articles, Critical Reviews, Features, Perspectives, and Policy Analysis; not for Viewpoints/Spotlights/Letters.
• Supporting Information: submitted simultaneously as separate file(s), with an SI paragraph describing contents and file type.
• Data availability: a data-availability statement plus deposition of data/materials/protocols in public databases (see est-reporting-and-reproducibility).
• Style: ACS (numbered citations); SI units; ACS chemical conventions.
• Ethics: COI disclosure; coauthor consent; iThenticate screening; safety hazards in Methods; AI-use disclosed in Acknowledgments; ORCID for the corresponding author (待核实 on exact requirement).

Preflight checklist

Type & length

• Article type chosen; word count within its cap (counting figure/table word-equivalents)
• Abstract present and within type norms
• TOC graphic prepared (required for this type) and meeting ACS size/format specs

Files & content

• Main manuscript + separate Supporting Information file(s); SI paragraph written
• Data-availability statement with accession/DOI; data/code deposited
• Figures/tables self-contained, accessible (see est-figures-and-tables)

Style & metadata

• ACS numbered citation style; SI units; consistent nomenclature
• Corresponding-author ORCID ready (待核实)
• Suggested reviewers (≥4, non-conflicted) and cover letter ready (see est-cover-letter)

Compliance

• COI disclosure; coauthor consent; ethics/IRB or animal (ARRIVE) statements if relevant
• Safety/hazard reporting in Methods; AI-use disclosure if applicable
• Plagiarism self-check; preprint status checked against ACS policy

Avoidable rejection-at-upload table

These are the failures that bounce a manuscript at or just after upload — before science is judged. Each line is a hard gate; confirm the volatile specifics on the live ACS page (待核实):

Worked micro-example (illustrative — final preflight on an emissions-inventory paper)

A Research Article on basin methane attribution, the night before upload (illustrative):

• Type & length: Research Article; body 6,200 words + two figures counted as word-equivalents (~600 illustrative) → ~6,800, under the ~7,000 cap. Pass.
• TOC graphic: a basin schematic with super-emitter sites highlighted — a concept, not a clone of the flux map. Pass.
• SI + data: aircraft flux retrievals, the inversion configuration, and uncertainty budget in the SI; processed fluxes and inversion code on Zenodo with a DOI; data-availability statement written.
• Declarations: COI none; all coauthors consented; no human/animal subjects; AI-use disclosed in Acknowledgments; corresponding-author ORCID linked (待核实 on exact requirement).
• The one easy miss: the two figures' word-equivalents were nearly forgotten — counting them is what keeps the paper under cap. This is the single most common avoidable over-limit failure.

Anti-patterns

• Submitting without the required TOC graphic
• Over the word cap because exhibits' word-equivalents were not counted
• No data-availability statement or undeposited data
• SI uploaded with no SI paragraph describing its contents
• Non-ACS citation style; missing COI/coauthor-consent declarations

Output format

【Type】Research Article / Critical Review / Feature / Perspective / Policy Analysis (cap met? Y/N)
【TOC graphic】required + present + spec-compliant? [Y/N]
【SI + data-availability statement】present, with accession/DOI? [Y/N]
【ACS style + ORCID】[Y/N]
【Ethics/COI/safety】declared? [Y/N]
【Cover letter + ≥4 reviewers】ready? [Y/N]
【Next】await decision → est-revision-and-rebuttal

Supplementary resources

• ../../resources/external_tools.md — reference managers, ACS templates, deposition repositories
• ../../resources/official-source-map.md — official ES&T URLs behind every fact in this pack

Source: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills → Environmental-Science-and-Technology-Skills/skills/est-submission/SKILL.md