JBF Workflow Router (jbf-workflow)
Use this skill to decide which JBF sub-skill to invoke next for a Journal of
Banking & Finance manuscript. JBF is an Elsevier journal (est. 1977, monthly,
ISSN 0378-4266) for empirical and theoretical research on banking, financial
intermediation, financial institutions, capital markets, investments, corporate
finance, and financial regulation — with a strong empirical, bank-focused
orientation. This pack is tuned to that nature, not to generic finance writing.
Default order
jbf-topic-selection — is the question a fit for a bank/intermediation-focused finance journal?jbf-literature-positioning — stake the contribution against the banking/finance frontier.jbf-identification-strategy — credible causal/empirical design for this field (bank panels, policy shocks, IV, event studies).jbf-data-analysis — sample construction, estimation, and the robustness JBF referees expect.jbf-tables-figures — clear exhibits with self-contained notes.jbf-contribution-framing — make the "so what" land for banking/finance readers and policy audiences.jbf-writing-style — concise, results-forward prose plus numbered-reference readiness.jbf-replication-and-data-policy — Elsevier Option C data statement plus deposit/link-or-explain package.jbf-review-process — what double-anonymized review and the desk screen involve.jbf-submission — Editorial Manager preflight: USD 350 fee, anonymized manuscript + title page, 250-word abstract, keywords, Highlights, AI declaration, data statement.jbf-rebuttal — response-letter strategy for an R&R.
Quick routing
- Brand-new idea →
jbf-topic-selection
- "Why JBF over a top-3 finance journal?" →
jbf-contribution-framing
- Worried about endogeneity in a bank panel →
jbf-identification-strategy
- Submitting this week →
jbf-submission (then jbf-review-process)
- Got an R&R →
jbf-rebuttal
Verify volatile specifics (fee, editor roster, special-issue instructions) on the official
ScienceDirect Guide for Authors — see resources/official-source-map.md.
Router diagnostics
- Scope is generic finance, not banking/intermediation ->
jbf-topic-selection.
- Endogeneity or bank-panel design is weak ->
jbf-identification-strategy.
- Licensed-data path is not reproducible ->
jbf-replication-and-data-policy.
- Tables omit units, clustering, or economic magnitudes ->
jbf-tables-figures.
- Results read as significance-only ->
jbf-writing-style.
Stage gates for a JBF lifecycle
Place the manuscript at a gate before routing; do not advance until the exit condition holds.
| Gate |
Exit condition |
Skill |
| G0 idea |
question names a bank/intermediation/regulation margin, not "finance in country X" |
jbf-topic-selection |
| G1 positioning |
closest intermediation-strand papers named with a stated delta |
jbf-literature-positioning |
| G2 design |
identifying variation survives the "regulation is endogenous" objection |
jbf-identification-strategy |
| G3 pipeline |
bank-panel sample, filters, and clustering documented end to end |
jbf-data-analysis |
| G4 exhibits |
baseline → identification → mechanism tables with self-contained notes |
jbf-tables-figures |
| G5 narrative |
contribution lands in finance units and policy terms without overreach |
jbf-contribution-framing, jbf-writing-style |
| G6 package |
data statement plus Editorial Manager preflight complete |
jbf-replication-and-data-policy, jbf-submission |
| G7 decision |
status interpreted; R&R triaged |
jbf-review-process, jbf-rebuttal |
Illustrative routing pass
A draft asks whether the Basel III liquidity coverage ratio shifted bank lending toward short maturities, using a bank-quarter Call Reports panel.
- The question is squarely bank-regulatory, so G0 passes without rerouting.
- The introduction cites a broad liquidity literature but no closest paper on the LCR and credit supply — route to
jbf-literature-positioning.
- Identification leans on plain TWFE around a single adoption date with no untreated banks;
jbf-identification-strategy flags the missing size-threshold contrast (the rule binds for large banks first) before any table work starts.
- Only after G2 holds does the pipeline-to-exhibit chain (
jbf-data-analysis → jbf-tables-figures) begin; running it earlier wastes a robustness battery on a design that will change.
Common misroutes
- Sending an R&R straight to
jbf-writing-style: triage with jbf-rebuttal first — prose fixes cannot answer identification comments.
- Building exhibits before G2 holds: staggered-DID corrections re-cut every table.
- Treating the data statement as submission-day paperwork: licensed bank-data documentation starts at G3, not G6.
- Pitching breadth ("banking and markets and fintech"): JBF rewards one anchored intermediation margin per paper.
Routing output
[Gate] G0-G7 position
[Blocking symptom] ...
[Route] jbf-... sub-skill
[Re-entry check] which gate to re-test after the fix
[Volatile facts] fee / editor roster / calls — re-verify via official-source-map
Source: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills → Journal-of-Banking-and-Finance-Skills/skills/jbf-workflow/SKILL.md
1---2name: jbf-workflow3description: Use when routing a Journal of Banking & Finance (JBF) manuscript to the right JBF sub-skill across the lifecycle — topic fit, literature positioning, identification, bank-panel data work, exhibits, Elsevier Editorial Manager submission, double-anonymized review, and R&R rebuttal strategy.4---5
6
7# JBF Workflow Router (jbf-workflow)
8
9Use this skill to decide which JBF sub-skill to invoke next for a *Journal of
10Banking & Finance* manuscript. JBF is an Elsevier journal (est. 1977, monthly,
11ISSN 0378-4266) for empirical and theoretical research on banking, financial
12intermediation, financial institutions, capital markets, investments, corporate
13finance, and financial regulation — with a strong empirical, bank-focused
14orientation. This pack is tuned to that nature, not to generic finance writing.
15
16## Default order
17
181. `jbf-topic-selection` — is the question a fit for a bank/intermediation-focused finance journal?
192. `jbf-literature-positioning` — stake the contribution against the banking/finance frontier.
203. `jbf-identification-strategy` — credible causal/empirical design for this field (bank panels, policy shocks, IV, event studies).
214. `jbf-data-analysis` — sample construction, estimation, and the robustness JBF referees expect.
225. `jbf-tables-figures` — clear exhibits with self-contained notes.
236. `jbf-contribution-framing` — make the "so what" land for banking/finance readers and policy audiences.
247. `jbf-writing-style` — concise, results-forward prose plus numbered-reference readiness.
258. `jbf-replication-and-data-policy` — Elsevier Option C data statement plus deposit/link-or-explain package.
269. `jbf-review-process` — what double-anonymized review and the desk screen involve.
2710. `jbf-submission` — Editorial Manager preflight: USD 350 fee, anonymized manuscript + title page, 250-word abstract, keywords, Highlights, AI declaration, data statement.
2811. `jbf-rebuttal` — response-letter strategy for an R&R.
29
30## Quick routing
31
32- Brand-new idea → `jbf-topic-selection`
33- "Why JBF over a top-3 finance journal?" → `jbf-contribution-framing`
34- Worried about endogeneity in a bank panel → `jbf-identification-strategy`
35- Submitting this week → `jbf-submission` (then `jbf-review-process`)
36- Got an R&R → `jbf-rebuttal`
37
38Verify volatile specifics (fee, editor roster, special-issue instructions) on the official
39ScienceDirect Guide for Authors — see `resources/official-source-map.md`.
40
41## Router diagnostics
42
43- Scope is generic finance, not banking/intermediation -> `jbf-topic-selection`.
44- Endogeneity or bank-panel design is weak -> `jbf-identification-strategy`.
45- Licensed-data path is not reproducible -> `jbf-replication-and-data-policy`.
46- Tables omit units, clustering, or economic magnitudes -> `jbf-tables-figures`.
47- Results read as significance-only -> `jbf-writing-style`.
48
49## Stage gates for a JBF lifecycle
50
51Place the manuscript at a gate before routing; do not advance until the exit condition holds.
52
53| Gate | Exit condition | Skill |
54| --- | --- | --- |
55| G0 idea | question names a bank/intermediation/regulation margin, not "finance in country X" | jbf-topic-selection |
56| G1 positioning | closest intermediation-strand papers named with a stated delta | jbf-literature-positioning |
57| G2 design | identifying variation survives the "regulation is endogenous" objection | jbf-identification-strategy |
58| G3 pipeline | bank-panel sample, filters, and clustering documented end to end | jbf-data-analysis |
59| G4 exhibits | baseline → identification → mechanism tables with self-contained notes | jbf-tables-figures |
60| G5 narrative | contribution lands in finance units and policy terms without overreach | jbf-contribution-framing, jbf-writing-style |
61| G6 package | data statement plus Editorial Manager preflight complete | jbf-replication-and-data-policy, jbf-submission |
62| G7 decision | status interpreted; R&R triaged | jbf-review-process, jbf-rebuttal |
63
64## Illustrative routing pass
65
66A draft asks whether the Basel III liquidity coverage ratio shifted bank lending toward short maturities, using a bank-quarter Call Reports panel.
67
68- The question is squarely bank-regulatory, so G0 passes without rerouting.
69- The introduction cites a broad liquidity literature but no closest paper on the LCR and credit supply — route to `jbf-literature-positioning`.
70- Identification leans on plain TWFE around a single adoption date with no untreated banks; `jbf-identification-strategy` flags the missing size-threshold contrast (the rule binds for large banks first) before any table work starts.
71- Only after G2 holds does the pipeline-to-exhibit chain (`jbf-data-analysis` → `jbf-tables-figures`) begin; running it earlier wastes a robustness battery on a design that will change.
72
73## Common misroutes
74
75- Sending an R&R straight to `jbf-writing-style`: triage with `jbf-rebuttal` first — prose fixes cannot answer identification comments.
76- Building exhibits before G2 holds: staggered-DID corrections re-cut every table.
77- Treating the data statement as submission-day paperwork: licensed bank-data documentation starts at G3, not G6.
78- Pitching breadth ("banking and markets and fintech"): JBF rewards one anchored intermediation margin per paper.
79
80## Routing output
81
82```text
83[Gate] G0-G7 position
84[Blocking symptom] ...
85[Route] jbf-... sub-skill
86[Re-entry check] which gate to re-test after the fix
87[Volatile facts] fee / editor roster / calls — re-verify via official-source-map
88```
89
90---
91
92**Source:** [`brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills`](https://github.com/brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills) → `Journal-of-Banking-and-Finance-Skills/skills/jbf-workflow/SKILL.md`
thedixitjain