Submission Preflight (jbv-submission)
When to trigger
- The manuscript is final and you are about to upload
- You need the Editorial Manager checklist for JBV
- You are unsure how to anonymize, what to declare, or whether to pay the APC
- You want to co-submit a data/methods artifact
Where and how
- Portal: Elsevier Editorial Manager (editorialmanager.com/jbvi). Submission is fully online, with stepwise file upload from the ScienceDirect submission link.
- First submission format: provide editable source files; submit a separate title page and a fully anonymized manuscript for double-anonymized review. Strict reference formatting is not required at initial submission if every reference is complete and the style is consistent.
- Current masthead: ScienceDirect lists Sophie Bacq and Simon Parker as Co-Editors-in-Chief; manuscripts route through the current area-editor / handling-editor structure.
Double-anonymized preparation (required)
Review is double-anonymized, so prepare an anonymized manuscript:
- Remove author names, affiliations, and acknowledgements from the manuscript file.
- Cite your own prior work in the third person; remove identifying funding/thanks.
- Keep author identifiers in the Editorial Manager metadata only, not in the file.
Required declarations
- Declaration of competing interest (state "Declarations of interest: none" if applicable).
- CRediT author-contribution statement for corresponding authors.
- Generative-AI disclosure statement describing any AI use in preparation; no statement is needed for basic grammar, spelling, or reference tools.
- Data availability statement: JBV uses Elsevier's Option C research-data policy, so deposit/cite/link research data where possible or explain why data cannot be shared (e.g., proprietary VC data, confidential founder information). The statement is published with the article.
Abstract & metadata
- Abstract concise and factual, ≤ 250 words.
- 1 to 7 keywords reflecting the entrepreneurial phenomenon and disciplinary lens.
- Article highlights: 3 to 5 bullet points, each no more than 85 characters including spaces.
- Graphical abstract: encouraged, submitted as a separate file if used.
- ORCID linked to the corresponding author's account.
Fees / open access
- The subscription publication route lists no publication fee charged to authors.
- Optional open access carries an APC of USD 4,280 (excluding taxes); the open-access choice does not affect peer review or acceptance.
Co-submission (optional)
- On the "Attach files" page you can co-submit a Data in Brief descriptor or a MethodsX protocol article alongside the main manuscript — useful for novel hand-coded datasets or experimental protocols.
Checklist
Anti-patterns
- Identifiers left in the file (author names, "our prior work," thanks) breaking anonymity.
- Missing competing-interest, CRediT, or required AI declaration.
- No Option C data availability statement.
- Abstract over 250 words.
- Missing article highlights.
Submission-stage failure modes and the fix
| Failure caught at upload |
The fix before resubmitting |
| Self-citations in first person ("in our earlier study"). |
Convert to third person; check no in-press personal item de-anonymizes the list. |
| Proprietary VC/founder data, no statement. |
Write a data availability statement explaining the restriction and what can be shared. |
| Generative-AI used but undisclosed. |
Add the AI disclosure (tool and scope); separate from the competing-interest line. |
| Abstract over 250 words, method-heavy. |
Cut to ≤250 and lead with the entrepreneurial phenomenon and contribution. |
Worked micro-example: a one-pass preflight (illustrative)
A founder-team study of accelerator effects is ready to upload. The preflight catches, in order:
- Abstract is 268 words → trimmed to 240, reordered so the opportunity-team mechanism leads (illustrative).
- Self-citations read "we previously showed" → rewritten in third person; an in-press item cited as "Author, in press."
- Data are part Crunchbase (licensed), part hand-coded survey → statement notes the licensed portion cannot be redistributed; the coded instrument is available on request.
- Competing-interest line present, AI line missing → AI disclosure added ("language editing only," illustrative).
- References complete though not yet in journal style → acceptable at first submission; numbered style cleanup deferred to revision or proof.
Calibration anchors (hedged)
- The declarations editors most often bounce a paper for are the competing-interest declaration, CRediT statement, generative-AI disclosure when applicable, and data availability statement.
- Flexible first-submission references do not relax anonymization, title-page separation, declarations, or highlights; treat those as hard gates.
- Fee figures, contacts, and portal URLs change; confirm against the journal's current author guidelines.
Output format
【Portal】Editorial Manager (jbvi) ...
【Anonymization】clean? remaining identifiers ...
【Declarations】competing-interest / AI / data-statement present? ...
【Abstract/metadata】≤250 words; 1-7 keywords; highlights; ORCID ...
【OA/APC】subscription | OA (USD 4,280) ...
【Co-submission】Data in Brief / MethodsX? ...
【Next step】jbv-review-process
Source: brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills → Journal-of-Business-Venturing-Skills/skills/jbv-submission/SKILL.md
1---2name: jbv-submission3description: Use when preparing to submit a Journal of Business Venturing (JBV) manuscript through Elsevier Editorial Manager — double-anonymized preparation, required declarations (competing interest, CRediT, generative-AI when used), flexible first-submission references, the Option C data availability statement, open-access/APC choice, and optional Data in Brief / MethodsX co-submission. Handles the submission preflight; it does not write the paper (jbv-writing-style) or manage the review (jbv-review-process).4---567# Submission Preflight (jbv-submission)89## When to trigger1011- The manuscript is final and you are about to upload12- You need the Editorial Manager checklist for JBV13- You are unsure how to anonymize, what to declare, or whether to pay the APC14- You want to co-submit a data/methods artifact1516## Where and how1718- **Portal**: Elsevier **Editorial Manager** (editorialmanager.com/jbvi). Submission is fully online, with stepwise file upload from the ScienceDirect submission link.19- **First submission format**: provide editable source files; submit a separate title page and a fully anonymized manuscript for double-anonymized review. Strict reference formatting is not required at initial submission if every reference is complete and the style is consistent.20- **Current masthead**: ScienceDirect lists **Sophie Bacq** and **Simon Parker** as Co-Editors-in-Chief; manuscripts route through the current area-editor / handling-editor structure.2122## Double-anonymized preparation (required)2324Review is **double-anonymized**, so prepare an anonymized manuscript:2526- Remove author names, affiliations, and acknowledgements from the manuscript file.27- Cite your own prior work in the third person; remove identifying funding/thanks.28- Keep author identifiers in the Editorial Manager metadata only, not in the file.2930## Required declarations3132- **Declaration of competing interest** (state "Declarations of interest: none" if applicable).33- **CRediT author-contribution statement** for corresponding authors.34- **Generative-AI disclosure** statement describing any AI use in preparation; no statement is needed for basic grammar, spelling, or reference tools.35- **Data availability statement**: JBV uses Elsevier's Option C research-data policy, so deposit/cite/link research data where possible or explain why data cannot be shared (e.g., proprietary VC data, confidential founder information). The statement is published with the article.3637## Abstract & metadata3839- Abstract concise and factual, **≤ 250 words**.40- **1 to 7 keywords** reflecting the entrepreneurial phenomenon and disciplinary lens.41- **Article highlights**: 3 to 5 bullet points, each no more than 85 characters including spaces.42- **Graphical abstract**: encouraged, submitted as a separate file if used.43- ORCID linked to the corresponding author's account.4445## Fees / open access4647- The subscription publication route lists **no publication fee charged to authors**.48- Optional open access carries an **APC of USD 4,280 (excluding taxes)**; the open-access choice **does not affect peer review or acceptance**.4950## Co-submission (optional)5152- On the "Attach files" page you can co-submit a **Data in Brief** descriptor or a **MethodsX** protocol article alongside the main manuscript — useful for novel hand-coded datasets or experimental protocols.5354## Checklist5556- [ ] Separate title page and anonymized manuscript prepared as editable source files57- [ ] Manuscript fully anonymized (no names/affiliations/acknowledgements; third-person self-cites)58- [ ] Competing-interest declaration included59- [ ] CRediT author-contribution statement included60- [ ] Generative-AI disclosure included if AI tools were used61- [ ] Option C data availability statement included62- [ ] Abstract ≤ 250 words; 1-7 keywords; highlights; ORCID linked63- [ ] Open-access/APC choice decided (USD 4,280 if OA; live-check current)64- [ ] Data in Brief / MethodsX co-submission decided6566## Anti-patterns6768- **Identifiers left in the file** (author names, "our prior work," thanks) breaking anonymity.69- **Missing competing-interest, CRediT, or required AI declaration.**70- **No Option C data availability statement.**71- **Abstract over 250 words.**72- **Missing article highlights.**7374## Submission-stage failure modes and the fix7576| Failure caught at upload | The fix before resubmitting |77|-----------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|78| Self-citations in first person ("in our earlier study"). | Convert to third person; check no in-press personal item de-anonymizes the list. |79| Proprietary VC/founder data, no statement. | Write a data availability statement explaining the restriction and what *can* be shared.|80| Generative-AI used but undisclosed. | Add the AI disclosure (tool and scope); separate from the competing-interest line. |81| Abstract over 250 words, method-heavy. | Cut to ≤250 and lead with the entrepreneurial phenomenon and contribution. |8283## Worked micro-example: a one-pass preflight (illustrative)8485A founder-team study of accelerator effects is ready to upload. The preflight catches, in order:8687- Abstract is 268 words → trimmed to 240, reordered so the opportunity-team mechanism leads (illustrative).88- Self-citations read "we previously showed" → rewritten in third person; an in-press item cited as "Author, in press."89- Data are part Crunchbase (licensed), part hand-coded survey → statement notes the licensed portion cannot be redistributed; the coded instrument is available on request.90- Competing-interest line present, AI line missing → AI disclosure added ("language editing only," illustrative).91- References complete though not yet in journal style → acceptable at first submission; numbered style cleanup deferred to revision or proof.9293## Calibration anchors (hedged)9495- The declarations editors most often bounce a paper for are the **competing-interest declaration**, **CRediT statement**, **generative-AI disclosure when applicable**, and **data availability statement**.96- Flexible first-submission references do **not** relax anonymization, title-page separation, declarations, or highlights; treat those as hard gates.97- Fee figures, contacts, and portal URLs change; confirm against the journal's current author guidelines.9899## Output format100101```102【Portal】Editorial Manager (jbvi) ...103【Anonymization】clean? remaining identifiers ...104【Declarations】competing-interest / AI / data-statement present? ...105【Abstract/metadata】≤250 words; 1-7 keywords; highlights; ORCID ...106【OA/APC】subscription | OA (USD 4,280) ...107【Co-submission】Data in Brief / MethodsX? ...108【Next step】jbv-review-process109```110111---112113**Source:** [`brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills`](https://github.com/brycewang-stanford/Awesome-Journal-Skills) → `Journal-of-Business-Venturing-Skills/skills/jbv-submission/SKILL.md`
thedixitjain